Read the following description and answer the question.
In 2005, the Terri Schiavo case raised profound questions about the proper role of government in private medical decisions. Numerous state and federal judges, including Florida Supreme Court justices, upheld the husband's right to remove his wife's feeding tube. Congress nonetheless passed emergency legislation intended to keep her alive, and President George W. Bush signed it into law. Critics charged that the federal government was using its power to override the judicial process in a personal family medical decision.
The Schiavo case's political significance most directly relates to which of the following?
- AThe emergence of the Tea Party as Religious Right activists, angry that Republican leaders had not done enough to keep Terri Schiavo alive, organized a grassroots revolt against the party establishment
- BThe tension between Religious Right pressure on Republicans to intervene in a publicized 'right to life' case and the judicial independence and federalism those same Republicans typically championedCorrect
- CThe Supreme Court's decision to take up the case and issue a sweeping ruling that, for the first time, recognized a constitutional right of patients to refuse life-sustaining medical treatment
- DA landmark extension of federal power over state courts that set new constitutional precedent for congressional intervention in state family-law and end-of-life decisions
Why B is right
The Schiavo case exposed a tension in Republican principles: leaders who championed judicial independence, federalism, and limited government used federal power to override state courts in a family medical decision. Polls showed most Americans opposed congressional intervention, and some conservatives criticized Republican leaders for breaking their own stated principles to satisfy the Religious Right.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Tea Party movement emerged in 2009 in response to the economic stimulus and Affordable Care Act debates; it was not a reaction to the Schiavo case or to Religious Right disappointment with Republican leaders.
- C
- The Supreme Court declined to hear the Schiavo case, and the constitutional right to refuse medical treatment had already been recognized in Cruzan v. Director (1990), so no such first-time ruling occurred.
- D
- The federal legislation produced no durable precedent; federal courts quickly dismissed the case on procedural grounds, and no lasting expansion of federal authority over state family law resulted.