In a February 1947 article in Harper's Magazine, former Secretary of War Henry Stimson defended the decision to drop the atomic bombs on Japan. He argued that the bombs had shortened the war and prevented an invasion of the Japanese home islands that, in his account, would have produced enormous casualties on both sides — far exceeding the deaths caused by the two atomic bombs.
A historian could best use this source to support which of the following arguments?
- AJapanese government records uncovered after the war confirmed Stimson's casualty figures, retroactively validating the administration's decision to use atomic weapons against Japan
- BStimson had privately opposed dropping the atomic bombs in 1945 but reversed his position afterward once their effectiveness in forcing a rapid Japanese surrender became evident
- CStimson's article reflected a unanimous contemporaneous consensus among American military leaders that atomic weapons offered the only path to ending the Pacific War without a costly invasion
- DThe administration's postwar defense of the bombs rested on high invasion-casualty projections, creating a public justification framework that historians have long debated and challengedCorrect
Why D is right
Stimson's 1947 Harper's article is itself a historical document — a postwar justification written specifically to defend the bombing decision against emerging criticism. Historians like Barton Bernstein have shown that the invasion casualty figures cited in the article were far higher than the projections circulating in 1945, and that other options (Soviet entry, modified surrender terms) were not fully explored. The article established the dominant American public narrative justifying the bombs, which subsequent historians have tested, challenged, and refined. Its creation of the 'casualties saved' framework is itself historically significant. (A) is wrong because Japanese records did not confirm the projections. (B) is wrong because Stimson supported using the bombs in 1945 (though he opposed bombing Kyoto); the article defends a decision he had backed at the time. (C) is wrong because the 1947 article was retrospective justification, not a contemporaneous consensus — in 1945 figures like Admiral Leahy and General MacArthur expressed reservations about the bomb's necessity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Japanese records did not confirm the casualty projections; historians continue to debate which figures were genuinely projected in 1945 versus those emphasized in the 1947 justification.
- B
- Incorrect because Stimson supported using the atomic bombs in 1945, though he did argue against bombing the cultural capital Kyoto; his 1947 article defends a decision he had supported at the time, not a position he had changed.
- C
- Incorrect because the 1947 article was retrospective justification, not a contemporaneous military consensus; in 1945, military views were more varied, and figures such as Admiral Leahy and General MacArthur expressed reservations about the bomb's necessity.