Read the following excerpt and answer the question.
"The subprime mortgage market allowed families who previously could not qualify for conventional loans to achieve homeownership. By relaxing credit standards, financial innovation made the American dream accessible to minorities, immigrants, and lower-income families who had been excluded from the housing market. The rapid rise in home values created wealth for millions of new homeowners. This was democratization of credit working as intended."
— A representative industry assessment of subprime lending, circa 2005
This optimistic assessment was most directly contradicted by which subsequent development?
- AThe Federal Reserve's 2006 decision to raise interest rates, which simply curbed demand for adjustable-rate mortgages and cooled subprime lending without exposing any underlying flaw in the loans themselves
- BThe 2008 financial crisis, when subprime loans with teaser rates that reset to unaffordable levels triggered mass foreclosures, wiping out the wealth of millions of new homeowners and disproportionately harming minority borrowersCorrect
- CCongress's passage of sweeping predatory-lending legislation in 2007 that banned the most abusive subprime products outright, formally ending the democratization of credit before the housing market turned
- DA landmark Supreme Court ruling that subprime mortgages marketed to minority borrowers constituted racial discrimination and violated the Fair Housing Act, halting the practice nationwide
Why B is right
Replaced the false attribution to the Mortgage Bankers Association (an invented quote credited to a real organization) with a generic industry-framing label; the question is unchanged in substance. Subprime mortgages were often structured with artificially low 'teaser' rates that reset to higher rates after 2-3 years. When housing prices stopped rising in 2006-07, refinancing became impossible, and millions of borrowers defaulted. The promised wealth creation became catastrophic wealth destruction, with minority and lower-income borrowers disproportionately affected by foreclosures.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Fed rate increases in 2006 did pressure adjustable-rate mortgages, but the crisis stemmed from fundamental underwriting failures and predatory loan structures, not merely from higher rates reducing demand; the problem was loan quality, not the interest-rate environment.
- C
- No such comprehensive predatory-lending statute was enacted in 2007. The Dodd-Frank Act (2010) addressed many of these abuses, but it came after the crisis rather than preventing it, so it could not have contradicted the 2005 assessment.
- D
- Fair-lending litigation against subprime lenders did occur, and the Department of Justice brought major settlements, but there was no single landmark Supreme Court ruling that declared the subprime industry discriminatory or halted the practice nationwide.