Skip to content
AP U.S. History · Period 6: 1865-1898

Immigration

Immigration appears in 15 reviewed AP U.S. History questions and sits in Period 6: 1865-1898. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The movement of roughly twenty million people into the United States between 1880 and 1920, shifting from the 'old' immigration of Germans, Irish, and Scandinavians to the 'new' immigration of Italians, Poles, Greeks, Russians, and eastern European Jews. Most arrived through Ellis Island after 1892 and settled in industrial cities.

Why it matters

Immigrant labor built the steel mills, mines, and packinghouses, and it reshaped urban politics. Because there was no unemployment insurance, workers' compensation, public relief, or pension system, the party machine became the working substitute for a welfare state. That absence is the mechanism behind almost every machine question.

How the exam tests it

Two angles recur. Machine stems pair Boss Tweed's theft with Tammany Hall's jobs, bureaucratic help, and Christmas food baskets, then ask why machines persisted: no alternative institution met immigrant and working-class needs. Exclusion stems ask what a restrictive law reflects, and the answer names racial prejudice, white workers' fear of wage competition, and Western politicians harvesting anti-Chinese votes.

Don’t confuse it with

Keep 'old' and 'new' immigration straight, and remember the categories are the nativists' own. The 'new' immigrants were largely Catholic, Orthodox, and Jewish rather than Protestant, which is precisely what restrictionists seized on; describe the distinction on the exam without adopting its assumptions.

Immigration in real questions

Example 1Medium
The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was the first federal law to restrict immigration on the basis of race or nationality. It barred Chinese laborers from entering the United States, was renewed and strengthened several times before 1900, and remained in force until 1943. The Chinese Exclusion Act most directly reflected which broader pattern in American society and politics in the 1880s?
  1. AThe federal government's effort to manage immigration scientifically by limiting entry of groups that contemporary scholars believed were genetically unsuited for democratic citizenship
  2. BThe convergence of racial prejudice, economic anxiety among white workers, and political calculations by Western politicians who sought to mobilize anti-Chinese sentimentCorrect
  3. CA foreign policy decision to retaliate against China's restrictions on American merchants doing business in Chinese port cities along the Pacific trade routes
  4. DA bipartisan humanitarian response to documented exploitation of Chinese workers by unscrupulous labor contractors who had brought them to America under conditions of virtual slavery

Why B is right

The Chinese Exclusion Act resulted from the convergence of multiple forces: racial prejudice that depicted Chinese immigrants as permanently foreign and unassimilable; economic anxiety among white workers (especially in California) who feared wage competition from Chinese laborers; and political calculations by both Democratic and Republican politicians in Western states who sought votes by mobilizing anti-Chinese sentiment. The Act was the culmination of years of anti-Chinese agitation, violence (including the Rock Springs Massacre of 1885), and local ordinances targeting Chinese residents, eventually elevated to federal policy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because while eugenics ideas were developing in this period, the Chinese Exclusion Act preceded the peak of eugenics influence and was driven primarily by political and economic forces rather than a scientific eugenics program.
C
Incorrect because the Chinese Exclusion Act was a domestic immigration restriction driven by domestic political forces rather than a retaliatory foreign policy measure; while the Burlingame Treaty (1868) had encouraged Chinese immigration, its revision in 1880 allowed the Exclusion Act.
D
Incorrect because the Act was anti-Chinese rather than a protection of Chinese workers; its purpose was exclusion, not protection of Chinese workers from exploitation; advocates of the law were primarily seeking to eliminate Chinese workers from competition with white workers.
Example 2Medium
"Gilded Age political corruption: The political machines of the Gilded Age, particularly Tammany Hall in New York City, organized political power through patronage, favors, and voting bloc coordination. Boss Tweed was convicted of stealing $30-200 million from New York City through fraudulent contracts. Yet machine politicians also provided genuine services: jobs for immigrants, help navigating bureaucracies, and food baskets at Christmas." — Modern description of political machines The persistence of political machines despite widespread corruption most directly reflected which conditions of late nineteenth-century American urban life?
  1. AThe fundamental indifference of immigrant communities to political corruption, since they had no experience of democratic governance in their countries of origin and thus no standard to hold American politicians to
  2. BThe absence of alternative social welfare institutions to address the genuine needs of immigrant and working-class communities, making machine politicians' services valuable despite their corruptionCorrect
  3. CThe failure of middle-class reformers to offer any meaningful alternative political program that could attract working-class and immigrant voters away from machine patronage
  4. DThe corruption of the American electoral system by foreign interests who financed machine politicians in exchange for favorable trade policies and government contracts

Why B is right

Political machines persisted because they provided genuine services that government otherwise did not offer: jobs for the unemployed, help with legal problems, emergency food and housing assistance, social connections for newcomers, and advocacy with an indifferent bureaucracy. In an era without Social Security, unemployment insurance, workers' compensation, public hospitals, or other welfare state institutions, machine politicians served as the social safety net for immigrant and working-class communities. Voters supported machines not from indifference to corruption but because the machines delivered tangible benefits that no alternative institution provided.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because characterizing immigrant communities as indifferent to corruption due to their origins is a stereotyping that ignores the documented cases of immigrant communities organizing against machine corruption; their support for machines was rational and based on services received, not ignorance of democratic standards.
C
Incorrect because while middle-class reformers did sometimes fail to reach working-class voters, framing the explanation entirely as reformer failure ignores the positive reasons that machine politicians were supported; the machines' persistence was primarily about what they provided, not what reformers failed to offer.
D
Incorrect because while contracts and patronage certainly benefited machine politicians' business allies, the machine system was a domestic political phenomenon rather than one driven by foreign interests; the explanation for machine persistence was in immigrant community needs, not foreign manipulation.
Example 3Medium
Read the following excerpt and answer the question. "The new immigration from southern and eastern Europe is qualitatively different from the old immigration from northern and western Europe. The new immigrants — Italians, Poles, Russians, Jews, Greeks — come from non-Protestant, non-democratic societies. They have no tradition of self-government. They congregate in ethnic enclaves rather than assimilating. They are racially inferior to the Anglo-Saxon stock that built American democracy. Immigration restriction is not bigotry — it is self-preservation." — Immigration Restriction League pamphlet, 1896 The sentiments expressed most directly contributed to which of the following?
  1. AThe immediate passage in the 1890s of Chinese Exclusion Act-style laws that categorically barred southern and eastern European arrivals, ending mass immigration from those regions a generation early
  2. BA firm bipartisan congressional consensus in favor of immigration restriction that was repeatedly blocked only by business interests demanding cheap immigrant labor for continued industrial expansion
  3. CThe nativist, pseudo-scientific racial arguments that culminated in the Immigration Acts of 1921 and 1924, whose national-origin quotas were designed to favor northern and western EuropeansCorrect
  4. DThe rise of Social Darwinism as the dominant intellectual framework for explaining social problems, displacing older religious explanations in favor of a sweeping new science of racial hierarchy

Why C is right

The IRL's racial arguments — 'inferior stock,' threat to Anglo-Saxon democracy — became the intellectual foundation for the national-origins quota system of the 1920s. Madison Grant's The Passing of the Great Race (1916) and similar nativist texts drew on this tradition, ultimately producing the Johnson-Reed Act (1924) that essentially banned immigration from southern and eastern Europe.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Chinese Exclusion-style restrictions on European immigrants were not passed in the 1890s; immigration from southern and eastern Europe in fact continued massively through the early twentieth century.
B
Although business interests did oppose restriction and relied on immigrant labor, there was never a settled 'bipartisan consensus' for restriction that business alone blocked; opposition was varied and immigration remained high.
D
While Social Darwinism and nativism overlapped, the IRL's specific contribution was to restriction legislation, not to establishing Social Darwinism as an intellectual framework, which had many applications beyond immigration.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Period 6: 1865-1898.