The Treaty of Tordesillas, signed in 1494 between Spain and Portugal, divided the non-European world along a meridian approximately 370 leagues west of the Cape Verde Islands. Lands to the west went to Spain; lands to the east went to Portugal. The treaty was brokered by Pope Alexander VI and reflected the two Iberian powers' determination to avoid conflict over colonial claims. Notably, it made no provision for the existence or rights of the peoples already living in the territories being divided.
Which of the following most directly contributed to the disregard for indigenous peoples reflected in the treaty described above?
- AThe shared economic interests of Spain and Portugal in maintaining a monopoly on colonial trade that excluded other European powers from the lucrative commerce of the newly discovered lands
- BThe political weakness of Portugal relative to Spain, which forced Portugal to accept unfavorable terms granting Spain the larger and more valuable share of the territories being divided in the Americas
- CThe Christian doctrine that non-Christian peoples held no legal standing in international agreements and that Christian monarchs could legitimately claim sovereignty over their landsCorrect
- DThe geographic ignorance of both Spanish and Portuguese negotiators, who did not yet grasp the full extent of the Americas and so drew the boundary line without appreciating its far-reaching implications
Why C is right
The Treaty of Tordesillas reflects the Christian legal doctrine that non-Christian peoples lacked legal standing in international law, derived from the concept of papal temporal authority and the Crusading tradition. Because indigenous peoples were neither Christian nor recognized subjects of Christian monarchies, they had no standing to object to or participate in the treaty. This doctrine of legal exclusion was fundamental to how European international law justified colonial partition of the non-Christian world.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while both powers sought to exclude other Europeans from colonial trade, this cannot explain why indigenous peoples themselves were excluded from the treaty; the question asks specifically about the basis for ignoring indigenous rights, not European rivalry.
- B
- Incorrect because Portugal was not significantly weaker than Spain in 1494 and actually negotiated favorable terms; Brazil, much of Africa, and the sea route to Asia all went to Portugal, giving it an enormously profitable empire.
- D
- Incorrect because both Spain and Portugal employed skilled cartographers and negotiators who understood approximate geographic positions reasonably well; the exclusion of indigenous peoples was not a product of ignorance but of deliberate legal doctrine.