Read the following description of a critique and answer the question.
By the late 1920s, a number of members of Congress had grown openly critical of U.S. policy toward Latin America. These critics argued that the Monroe Doctrine, as extended by the Roosevelt Corollary, had become a rationale for near-permanent American intervention in the Caribbean and Central America: the United States had occupied Haiti since 1915 and the Dominican Republic since 1916, and had repeatedly sent Marines into Nicaragua, often citing the protection of American lives and financial interests. Critics contended that what Washington described as protection, Latin American observers frequently described as imperialism.
This congressional critique of U.S. interventionism most directly contributed to which of the following subsequent developments?
- AThe Good Neighbor Policy announced by FDR in 1933 that renounced the right of intervention in Latin America and sought to replace military occupation with economic cooperation and multilateral consultationCorrect
- BA congressional investigation of Marine Corps conduct in Haiti and Nicaragua that generated public support for immediate withdrawal of occupation forces and statutory limits on presidential intervention authority
- CThe Clark Memorandum of 1928 that officially repudiated the Roosevelt Corollary and declared that the Monroe Doctrine was not a license for American intervention in Latin American internal affairs
- DThe Kellogg-Briand Pact of 1928 that renounced war as an instrument of national policy, applying to American interventions in Latin America as well as to potential wars among great powers
Why A is right
This congressional critique of Caribbean interventionism reflected a broader American discomfort with occupation policy that culminated in FDR's Good Neighbor Policy. The series of military occupations had generated significant anti-American sentiment throughout Latin America and domestic criticism that the interventions violated principles of self-determination.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- While congressional investigations occurred, no statutory limits on presidential intervention authority emerged in this period; the political response was executive policy change, not legislation.
- C
- The Clark Memorandum (1928) did repudiate the Roosevelt Corollary, and this was a relevant development; but the more significant practical change was FDR's Good Neighbor Policy that actually ended the interventions.
- D
- The Kellogg-Briand Pact was a broad anti-war treaty, not specifically about Latin American intervention; Borah supported it but it was not a direct response to his interventionism critique.