Read the following description of a political strategy and answer the question.
Following the 1994 elections, some congressional strategists argued that the most effective approach for a minority party was systematic obstruction rather than cooperation. In this view, the purpose of the opposition was not to offer alternative governance but to deny the majority any achievement it could campaign on: if the majority passed a measure such as health reform, it would receive credit, while blocking the measure would shift blame onto the majority. Cooperation that might give the other party a usable success was therefore discouraged, and obstruction itself was treated as the core strategy.
The strategy described most directly contributed to which of the following developments in American politics?
- AThe emergence of divided government as the normal condition of American politics, as voters split their tickets to balance one party's control of Congress against the other's hold on the presidency
- BThe rise of primary elections as the dominant force in congressional politics, forcing members to answer to an ideological base that punished compromise with the other party
- CThe growth of executive power as presidents bypassed an obstructionist Congress through executive orders and unilateral regulatory action rather than legislation
- DThe intensification of congressional partisanship and decline of bipartisan policymaking, as opposition parties found obstruction more politically advantageous than cooperative governance with the majorityCorrect
Why D is right
The 'total war' obstruction approach associated with congressional leadership after 1994 became a template for subsequent congressional opposition. Partisan obstruction grew into a dominant political strategy, producing legislative gridlock and eroding the norm of bipartisan governance that had characterized mid-twentieth-century congressional practice.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- While divided government was common, ticket-splitting by voters was actually declining rather than increasing in the 1990s and 2000s; partisan voting alignment was rising, so voters were not deliberately balancing the parties.
- B
- While primary election influence was growing, the strategy described is about floor and legislative obstruction in Congress, not about primary electoral incentives driving member behavior.
- C
- While executive power growth is a real trend, the strategy described is about congressional opposition itself, not about presidential responses to that obstruction.