Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Short Answer Question (SAQ)

3 points3 original prompts6 scored examples

The short answer question (SAQ) is the second half of Section I on the AP World History: Modern exam. You get 40 minutes to answer three SAQs. Together they are worth 20% of your exam score, so each one is roughly 6.7%.

On this page · 6 sections

Each SAQ has three parts, labeled (a), (b) and (c). Each part is worth exactly 1 point, so every SAQ is scored out of 3, and the section is out of 9. The first two questions are required. One gives you a secondary source, such as a historian's argument. The other gives you a primary source, such as a text, image or map from the period. For the third, you choose between two questions with no stimulus. One covers c. 1200 to c. 1750, and the other covers c. 1750 to c. 2001.

Readers score each part on its own. There is no thesis point and no essay structure. A part earns its point if it does what the verb asks with accurate, specific history. "Identify" means name something correct. "Describe" means give its key features. "Explain" means show how or why, with a cause, a link or a result. A wrong claim inside a part can cost that part, but it never costs you the other two parts.

Budget about 13 minutes per question. Two to four sentences per part is usually enough. Length does not score. Precision does.

Read every part before you read the source, so you know what to look for. Underline the dates and the place in each part. A correct fact from the wrong century earns nothing. For a secondary source, put the author's main claim into one sentence before you write. Parts often ask you to identify that claim, or to give evidence that supports or challenges it. For a primary source, note who made it, when and for whom. Then pick outside evidence that the source does not name.

For the choice question, spend one minute deciding. Read all three parts of both options. Pick the one where you can name a specific person, policy or event for every part, not the one with the topic you like best. Label your answers (a), (b) and (c) so the reader can find each one. Write in full sentences. Bullet lists and outlines can lose credit, because they rarely show the link an explain part needs. Do not restate the question. Open with your answer.

Save the last two or three minutes to check each part against its verb. If an explain part has no "because", "so" or "which led to", add one sentence that supplies it. If two parts lean on the same example, swap one for a different case. Check every date you wrote. A careless slip, such as putting the Meiji Restoration in 1688 instead of 1868, can cost a point you had otherwise earned.

The rubric, in plain terms

3 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Part (a)1 pt

Does exactly what the part's task verb asks, usually identify or describe. The answer must be historically accurate and tied to the time and place in the prompt. When a stimulus is given, the answer must match what the source actually says, not a guess about it.

Part (b)1 pt

Earns 1 point for accurately completing the task. A named person, policy, place, institution or event from the right period is the safest way to show that your answer is accurate. If the verb is explain, state the link, such as how one thing caused, enabled or resulted from another. A bare topic name with no connection usually does not earn the point.

Part (c)1 pt

Earns 1 point for accurately completing the task. Use different evidence from (a) and (b) when you can, so each part stands on its own. For a comparison, name both cases and state the shared or differing feature. For a cause or effect, state the mechanism. Stay inside the dates the part gives.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Secondary source: American silver and the world economy, 1550-1700 (Unit 4)

Practice passage written for ScoreGrind. It is an invented historian's argument, not a real publication.

"Historians once told the story of early modern trade as a story of European ships. That picture misses the engine. Silver from Spanish America paid for most of it. It came from the mountain at Potosi, in the Andes, and from Mexican mines such as Zacatecas. Spanish officials forced Andean villages to send workers into the Potosi mines in rotating drafts. The metal then moved two ways. Much of the Peruvian silver crossed the Atlantic to Seville and paid for Spain's wars. Mexican silver was shipped across the Pacific from Acapulco to Manila on the galleons. There, Chinese merchants exchanged silk and porcelain for it. China's enormous demand for silver set the price that made the whole system profitable. Europe was a middleman in a trade whose center lay in Asia."

  1. (a)Identify ONE claim the author makes about the role of China in global trade in this period. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Explain ONE way that a labor system in Spanish America supported the silver trade described in the passage in the period 1550-1700. [1 pt]
  3. (c)Explain ONE way that a state in East Asia responded to the inflow of silver in the period 1550-1700. [1 pt]
Prompt 2

No stimulus: land-based empires, 1450-1750 (Unit 3)

  1. (a)Identify ONE way that a land-based empire expanded its territory in the period 1450-1750. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Explain ONE similarity in the ways that TWO land-based empires recruited or controlled the officials who ran their states in the period 1450-1750. [1 pt]
  3. (c)Explain ONE reason that a ruler of a land-based empire adopted practices from other states in the period 1450-1750. [1 pt]
Prompt 3

Primary source: testimony on child labor in British textile mills, 1832 (Unit 5)

Practice source written for ScoreGrind. It is modeled on the testimony that mill workers gave to the British House of Commons committee on child factory labor chaired by Michael Sadler in 1832. The speaker and the words are invented.

"I went into the flax mill at Leeds when I was nine years old. In the busy season we worked from half past five in the morning until half past eight at night, with half an hour at noon to eat. The machines did not stop, so we could not stop. When a child grew sleepy in the last hours of the shift, the overlooker beat him with a strap to keep him at his frame. My sister caught her hand in the gearing and lost two fingers, and she was sent home without wages. My father could not find steady work, so our family needed what my sister and I earned. I have heard men say that the slaves in the West Indies were better kept than we were."

Source: invented testimony of a former child worker, given before a committee of the British House of Commons, 1832.

  1. (a)Identify ONE working condition described in the source. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Explain ONE way that the purpose of the committee that heard this testimony might have shaped what the witness chose to describe. [1 pt]
  3. (c)Explain ONE way that workers or governments in Europe responded to industrial working conditions in the period 1800-1900. [1 pt]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Secondary source: American silver and the world economy, 1550-1700 (Unit 4) · high-scoring response3/3

(a) The author claims China was the real center of the silver trade. Chinese demand for silver set the price that made the mining and shipping profitable, so Europeans were only middlemen.

(b) The mita system supported the silver trade. Spanish officials took the old Inca labor draft and used it to force a share of adult men from Andean villages to work at Potosi for set terms. This gave the mines a steady supply of cheap workers. Many died from accidents and mercury poisoning, but the draft kept refilling the mines, so silver output stayed high.

(c) Ming China changed its tax system to run on silver. Under the Single Whip reforms of the 1570s and 1580s, many taxes and labor duties were combined into one payment made in silver. This raised demand for silver even more, which is why so much American silver flowed to China through Manila.

How it scored

1/1a — Accurately restates the author's argument that Chinese demand set the price and made China the center of the trade. It does not add outside claims the passage does not make.
1/1b — Names a specific system (the mita) and a specific site (Potosi). It explains the mechanism: a forced, rotating draft kept the mines staffed and output high. That is the 'explain' link the part requires.
1/1c — Names a specific state policy, the Ming Single Whip reforms, with correct dates. It explains how the policy tied China's tax system to silver and why that pulled more silver across the Pacific.
Secondary source: American silver and the world economy, 1550-1700 (Unit 4) · mid-scoring response2/3

(a) The author says China had a huge demand for silver, and that is what made the trade profitable. Chinese merchants traded silk and porcelain for silver in Manila.

(b) The encomienda system gave Spanish settlers the right to native labor. But the Spanish crown passed the New Laws in 1542, which ended forced labor. After that the native people worked in the mines for wages, so the silver trade was built on paid labor.

(c) Ming China started collecting taxes in silver, so the government needed a lot of it. This is one reason why silver from the Americas ended up in China.

How it scored

1/1a — Correctly identifies the author's claim that Chinese demand made the trade profitable. The Manila detail matches the passage.
0/1b — The error is the claim that the New Laws of 1542 ended forced labor, and then using that law as proof that the whole silver economy ran on free labor. The law limited the encomienda on paper, but coerced labor went on. At Potosi, Viceroy Toledo reorganized the mita in the 1570s, and the forced draft kept the mines supplied for two centuries. Mexican mines such as Zacatecas did rely largely on wage labor. A response built on that fact could earn the point if it explained how those wages kept the mines and the trade running.
1/1c — Brief but accurate. It gives a state response (Ming taxes paid in silver) and links it to the flow of American silver to China. Naming the Single Whip reform would be stronger, but the link is enough.
No stimulus: land-based empires, 1450-1750 (Unit 3) · high-scoring response3/3

(a) The Ottoman Empire expanded by using gunpowder weapons. In 1453, Mehmed II used huge cannons to break the walls of Constantinople and took the city, which became the Ottoman capital.

(b) Both the Ottomans and the Mughals built official classes whose rank depended on the ruler. The Ottomans used the devshirme to take Christian boys from the Balkans, convert them and train them as Janissaries or administrators who owed everything to the sultan. The Mughals used the mansabdar system, which gave nobles ranks and land revenue in return for service, and the emperor could move or remove them. In both cases officials were loyal to the ruler instead of to their own families or regions.

(c) Peter the Great of Russia adopted Western European practices because he wanted military power that could match his Western rivals. When Sweden crushed his army at Narva in 1700, the gap became obvious. Peter then rebuilt the army on Western lines, with Western-style drill and officers. He also expanded the navy he had founded at Azov in 1696, building a Baltic Fleet from 1702-03 with Western shipwrights.

How it scored

1/1a — Identifies a specific method (gunpowder artillery) with a named ruler, event and date. Accurate and in the period.
1/1b — Names two empires and a specific institution in each. It states the shared feature clearly: officials whose rank and loyalty came from the ruler. That is a real similarity, not two separate descriptions.
1/1c — Names a ruler and gives the reason: military power to match Western rivals. Narva in 1700 shows why the goal was urgent. The army rebuilding and the Baltic Fleet show the borrowing that followed, and the dates keep the navy's 1696 founding before Narva. The cause-to-reform link is explicit, so a longer list of reforms would not add a point.
No stimulus: land-based empires, 1450-1750 (Unit 3) · mid-scoring response2/3

(a) The Ottomans expanded by conquering Constantinople in 1453 with cannons. Later Suleiman pushed into Hungary and besieged Vienna in 1529.

(b) Both the Ming and the Qing used the civil service exams to pick officials. Men had to pass tests on Confucian texts, so officials were chosen for their learning and trained to be loyal to the emperor.

(c) Peter the Great was influenced by the Enlightenment. He wanted Russians to have more freedom like people in Western Europe, so he made the nobles shave their beards and wear Western clothes and he tried to open Russia to free trade.

How it scored

1/1a — Accurate and specific: the conquest of Constantinople with artillery and Suleiman's push into Hungary are both valid ways the Ottomans expanded.
1/1b — Thin but accurate, and a borderline pairing. The Ming and Qing used the same institution, so the similarity is almost automatic. A safer answer compares different empires. For example, the Qing exams and the Ottoman devshirme both trained officials who owed their posts to the ruler, not to their birth.
0/1c — Misreads Peter's goals. His reforms strengthened autocracy and tightened serfdom rather than expanding freedom, and his economic policy was state-directed and mercantilist, not free trade. The beard and clothing details are real, but they are offered as proof of a wrong reason.
Primary source: testimony on child labor in British textile mills, 1832 (Unit 5) · high-scoring response3/3

(a) The source describes very long hours. In the busy season the children worked from half past five in the morning until half past eight at night, with only half an hour off at noon.

(b) The committee was chaired by Michael Sadler, a member of Parliament who was pushing a bill to limit children's work to ten hours a day. His committee wanted evidence that would win votes for that bill, so it called witnesses with the worst stories and did not hear from the mill owners. That is why the witness stresses beatings, injuries and the comparison to slavery, which echoed Richard Oastler's 1830 campaign against "Yorkshire Slavery."

(c) The British Parliament passed the Factory Act of 1833. It banned children under nine from most textile mills and limited children aged nine to thirteen to nine hours a day. It also created paid factory inspectors to enforce the rules, which made it more than a law on paper.

How it scored

1/1a — Identifies a condition the source actually states, long hours, and supports it with the hours given in the text. It does not invent details the witness never mentions.
1/1b — Uses the attribution line. It names the committee's purpose, winning support for a ten-hour bill, and explains how that purpose shaped the testimony toward the most shocking cases. The Oastler link is accurate outside context.
1/1c — Brings in outside evidence the source does not name: the Factory Act of 1833, with accurate age and hour limits. It explains why the inspectors mattered, so the response is a real explanation, not just a name.
Primary source: testimony on child labor in British textile mills, 1832 (Unit 5) · mid-scoring response2/3

(a) Children were beaten by the overlooker with a strap if they got sleepy late in the long shift.

(b) The witness compares the mill workers to slaves because Britain ended the slave trade in 1807, so the government and the factory owners set up factory work to replace slave labor. The testimony was given to Parliament under oath, so it is a reliable record of what factories were like.

(c) Workers formed trade unions and went on strike for higher wages and shorter hours. Unions gave workers more power because a whole mill could stop at once, so owners had to bargain with them.

How it scored

1/1a — Correctly identifies a condition stated in the source, physical punishment by the overlooker. One accurate sentence is enough for an identify part.
0/1b — Two errors. Factory conditions were not a deliberate government plan to copy slavery. They came from a laissez-faire economy with almost no labor laws, and the slavery comparison was a reformers' argument. The answer also never addresses the committee's purpose, and calling the testimony neutral because it was given to Parliament ignores that Sadler chose witnesses to support his bill.
1/1c — Accurate outside evidence with a clear mechanism: unions let workers act together and stop production, which forced owners to bargain. Naming a specific union or law would make it stronger, but the link earns the point.

Where points die

Treating a law as proof of what actually happened, such as saying the New Laws of 1542 ended forced labor in Spanish America. A colonial law shows what the crown said, not always what happened. The New Laws of 1542 limited the encomienda, but the mita at Potosi kept forcing Andean men into the mines, and debt peonage tied many workers to estates. Not all silver mining was coerced, though. Mexican mines such as Zacatecas relied largely on wage labor. If a part asks how labor worked, describe the practice in the specific place you name, not just the statute.

Explaining Peter the Great as an Enlightenment reformer who wanted freedom, free trade or closer ties with the Catholic Church. Peter's goal was military and state power to match Western rivals. That goal was already behind his Grand Embassy to Western Europe in 1697-98, and the defeat at Narva in 1700 sped up his rebuilding of the army. He tightened serfdom, ran a mercantilist economy and put the Orthodox Church under state control through the Holy Synod. Western dress and beard-shaving were symbols of that program.

Calling Safavid religious policy tolerant, or saying it converted the Ottomans or Arabia to Shia Islam. The Safavids forced their own subjects into Twelver Shia Islam and punished resisters. The result was a distinct Shia Persian identity and long wars with the Sunni Ottomans. It was not mass conversion beyond Iran.

Saying that the Ming or Qing emperors converted to Christianity because Jesuits served at court. Emperors used Jesuits for their technical skills. Matteo Ricci won access to the Ming court with clocks and maps, and he presented Christianity in Confucian terms. Later Jesuits such as Adam Schall von Bell and Ferdinand Verbiest ran the court's astronomy and calendar work. The emperors took the knowledge and did not convert. That selective borrowing is the pattern readers want you to name.

Answering a stimulus part with what you expect the source to say, such as claiming the silver-passage author argues that Europe controlled world trade. Check every claim against the actual text. That passage says the opposite: Europe was a middleman, and the trade's center lay in Asia because Chinese demand set the price. For a primary source, read the attribution line before the text. A witness speaking to a reform committee was chosen to make a case, so treat the words as evidence of that case, not as a neutral record.

Writing two separate descriptions when the part asks for a similarity or a comparison, or naming a topic without an explain link. Name both cases, then state the shared feature in one sentence that mentions both. For explain parts, add the 'because' or 'which led to' step. A named term with no connection scores 0.

Score your own response

0 / 3

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.