"The global financial crisis of 2008 demonstrated that the world's economies are so deeply interconnected that a collapse in the American housing market can destroy jobs in factories in China, farms in Brazil, and banks in Iceland. The complex financial instruments that Wall Street invented to spread risk instead concentrated it. The deregulation that was supposed to unleash entrepreneurial energy instead unleashed reckless speculation. And when the system collapsed, it was not the speculators but ordinary taxpayers who were called upon to pay the price."
— Economic journalist, 2009
The events described in this passage most directly challenged which of the following economic assumptions that had dominated policy-making since the 1980s?
- AThat free markets are inherently self-correcting and that deregulation produces optimal economic outcomesCorrect
- BThat government regulation of financial markets was necessary to prevent speculative excess and protect the public interest
- CThat central banks should maintain fixed exchange rates to ensure monetary stability across national economies
- DThat international trade should be restricted to protect domestic industries from foreign competition
Why A is right
The passage argues that deregulation led to reckless speculation and systemic collapse rather than the optimal outcomes its advocates promised. This directly challenged the neoliberal assumption, dominant since the 1980s under Reagan and Thatcher, that free markets are self-correcting and that reducing government regulation produces the best economic outcomes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the assumption that regulation is necessary was the position that gained credibility after 2008, not the assumption that was challenged; the crisis vindicated rather than undermined the case for financial regulation.
- C
- Incorrect because fixed exchange rates had been abandoned since the collapse of the Bretton Woods system in the early 1970s and were not the dominant policy assumption that the 2008 crisis challenged.
- D
- Incorrect because trade protectionism was not the dominant policy assumption since the 1980s; the crisis challenged free-market deregulation rather than protectionist trade policies.