"Consider the perfection of this commercial system: ships carry manufactured cloth from Manchester to West Africa, where it is traded for enslaved people. These captives are transported to the Caribbean, where their labor produces sugar and tobacco. These goods are carried back to Britain, enriching the merchants, the plantation owners, and the crown. Each leg of the voyage is profitable, and the entire cycle turns without ceasing, binding three continents in a commerce that grows richer each year."
—British merchant, circa 1750
The sentiments expressed most directly reflect which of the following?
- AAdam Smith's free-market argument that international trade between nations is mutually beneficial and maximizes overall economic efficiency
- BMercantilist theory holding that imperial commerce is a zero-sum contest among powers for a fixed quantity of global wealth and bullion
- CThe putting-out system, in which merchants distributed raw materials to rural households for manufacturing destined for Atlantic markets
- DThe triangular trade circuit linking Britain, West Africa, and the Americas through goods, enslaved labor, and plantation commoditiesCorrect
Why D is right
The passage explicitly describes all three legs of the triangular trade: manufactured goods to Africa, enslaved Africans to the Caribbean, and plantation products back to Britain. This is a direct description of the triangular trade system, which the merchant views approvingly as a 'perfect commercial system.'
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Adam Smith actually critiqued mercantilism and the slave trade; his free-trade arguments would not treat enslaved labor as part of a 'perfect commercial system.'
- B
- Mercantilism is a framework for imperial economics, but the passage describes the three-way circuit of the triangular trade, not a zero-sum competition with rival European powers.
- C
- The putting-out system was a domestic manufacturing arrangement; the passage describes intercontinental maritime trade, not rural household production.
"The iron ship moves against wind and tide with equal ease, and in two weeks crosses what once took two months. The coaling stations we have established at Gibraltar, Aden, Singapore, and Cape Town are the hinges upon which our global commerce turns. Where the sailing ship depended on nature, the steamship commands it. British industry has conquered not only markets but the very seas themselves, and now no corner of the earth is more than a month's voyage from our shores."
—British naval engineer, 1870
Which development most directly challenged the situation described?
- AGerman and American industrialization in the late 19th century, which produced rival powers building competing merchant fleetsCorrect
- BThe opening of the Suez Canal in 1869, which reduced the distance between Britain and India but also benefited non-British shipping companies
- CThe abolition of the Atlantic slave trade, which removed what many regarded as the most profitable sector of long-distance maritime commerce
- DThe development of refrigerated shipping, which extended the range of perishable goods that could be transported across the world's oceans
Why A is right
The passage celebrates British industrial and maritime supremacy through the steamship revolution. The development most directly challenging this supremacy was the rise of competing industrial powers—Germany and the United States—in the latter 19th century. These nations built their own industrial capacity, merchant fleets, and eventually naval power, eroding Britain's unique commercial dominance that the passage celebrates.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The Suez Canal (1869) actually reinforced British commercial dominance rather than challenging it; Britain dominated the Canal's traffic and operations and it benefited British India trade enormously.
- C
- Abolition of the slave trade (1807) predates the described steamship era and had largely been absorbed into the commercial system; it did not challenge steam-powered global shipping.
- D
- Refrigerated shipping was a continuation and extension of the same steamship revolution the passage describes, not a challenge to British maritime dominance.