"Let the princes and lords of Germany take heed: the peasants are no longer what they were. We have read the Scriptures; we know that God created all men free and equal; we know that the tithes and rents by which you keep us in poverty are contrary to divine law. We demand the abolition of serfdom, the right to hunt and fish in the forests, and fair rents for our lands. We do not seek war, but if war is forced upon us, God will judge between us."
—Twelve Articles of the Swabian peasants, c. 1525, adapted
A historian studying nineteenth-century nationalism could best use this source to support which argument?
- AThat religious Reformation movements consistently generated successful political revolutions throughout early modern Europe
- BThat German national identity was fundamentally rooted in shared Protestant Christianity rather than ethnic or linguistic community
- CThat pre-industrial grievances over land rights and economic inequality persisted unchanged into the modern industrial era
- DThat communities voiced demands for rights and equality in religious language before secular nationalism emergedCorrect
Why D is right
The question asks how a nineteenth-century nationalism historian would use this early modern source. The document illustrates a pre-nationalist form of political claim-making that uses religious rather than secular-national language to assert equality and rights. A historian could use it to argue that demands for political equality and rights predated secular nationalism and were expressed in the available cultural vocabulary of the time — religion — before nationalist ideology provided a new framework.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- While the Reformation did sometimes accompany political upheaval, this claim overgeneralizes; the Peasants' War was suppressed and the Reformation did not consistently produce successful political revolutions.
- B
- The document does not address ethnic or linguistic identity at all; it focuses on economic grievances and divine law, not the components of German national identity.
- C
- While land grievances persisted, this argument does not specifically relate to nineteenth-century nationalism; it addresses economic continuity rather than the origins or character of nationalist thought.