"Simon Bolivar has liberated the continent from Spanish tyranny, but what has he left in its place? A handful of creole landlords who have inherited the wealth of the viceroyalties and the contempt of the colonial masters. The Indian and the mestizo fought and bled for independence, and now they find themselves laboring on the same estates, paying the same tributes, bowing to the same masters — only the masters now speak of liberty while denying it."
—Anonymous pamphlet, Gran Colombia, c. 1825
Which historical development most directly contributed to the perspective expressed in the excerpt?
- AThe failure of Bolivar's dream of a unified Latin American confederation, which fragmented the region into rival states governed by competing caudillos
- BThe influence of French revolutionary radicalism on independence leaders, which led them to abolish estates and redistribute land to the peasantry
- CThe retention of colonial social hierarchies and landholding patterns after independence, with creole elites simply replacing Spanish officials as the dominant classCorrect
- DThe decline of Latin American export economies caused by the disruption of Atlantic trade and the destruction of plantations during the independence wars
Why C is right
Latin American independence movements were led by creole elites who sought to end Spanish imperial control but had no intention of redistributing land or dismantling the social hierarchy. Indigenous peoples and mestizos who fought in independence armies found that independence changed the nationality of their rulers but not their economic or social condition. Land remained concentrated in elite hands, and labor systems resembling the colonial period persisted.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The fragmentation of Bolivar's confederation into caudillo-led states was a political failure, but it does not directly explain why indigenous and mestizo people remained in poverty; that is a social and economic question the pamphlet is raising.
- B
- French revolutionary land redistribution was not widely influential in Latin America; creole elites feared radical social upheaval, as illustrated by their alarmed response to the Haitian Revolution.
- D
- Economic disruption and damaged trade during the independence wars affected all groups, but the excerpt's critique is specifically about the persistence of social hierarchy and land inequality, not general economic decline.