"The Malabar pepper that once required a year's journey from tree to table in Europe—passed through a dozen hands, taxed at every port, marked up at every caravanserai—now arrives in three months on a ship that carries ten thousand times the load of any caravan. Da Gama's route has not merely shortened the journey; it has broken the monopoly of those who stood between the growers and the buyers. The Venetians weep, the Arab merchants rage, and pepper is now so cheap in Lisbon that what was once a luxury is now a poor man's seasoning."
—Portuguese commercial account, 1510
A historian could best use this source to support which argument?
- APortuguese maritime expansion into the Indian Ocean was driven chiefly by the crown's desire to spread Christianity to Asian peoples rather than by any pursuit of commercial profit from the spice trade
- BVasco da Gama's direct sea route to India disrupted existing spice-trade networks, shifting commercial power from Mediterranean and Arab intermediaries to Atlantic European tradersCorrect
- CSpice prices in Europe fell so steeply after the Portuguese arrival in Asia that the spice trade had lost nearly all of its economic importance to European powers by the year 1525
- DThe opening of the direct sea route to India eliminated the need for overland caravan routes across Asia, which were promptly and permanently abandoned by all the merchants who had used them
Why B is right
The passage directly describes the disruption of the Venetian-Arab spice trade intermediary network by the Portuguese direct sea route—Venetians 'weep,' Arab merchants 'rage,' and pepper prices collapse in Lisbon. This is the classic historical argument about how Portuguese oceanic navigation shifted commercial power from Mediterranean city-states and Arab traders to Atlantic-facing Portugal, disrupting centuries of profitable intermediary trade.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage focuses entirely on commercial consequences—prices, monopolies, profits—not religious motivation; while Christian missionary activity was a Portuguese stated goal, this source does not support that argument.
- C
- The spice trade remained enormously profitable throughout the 16th century and beyond; the passage says pepper became 'a poor man's seasoning' but this means volume increased dramatically as prices fell, not that the trade ceased to matter economically.
- D
- Overland routes were not immediately abandoned; they continued to be used throughout the 16th century by Venetian and Ottoman merchants, though at reduced volumes; the transition was gradual, not instantaneous.
"The Portuguese Estado da India, established in the early sixteenth century, operated not through territorial conquest of large landmasses but through the seizure and fortification of strategic coastal trading posts -- Goa, Hormuz, Malacca, and Macao. By controlling these chokepoints, the Portuguese attempted to divert existing Indian Ocean trade through their own channels and impose a licensing system (the cartaz) on all merchant vessels. Ships without Portuguese licenses risked seizure or destruction. This system represented a fundamental break from the Indian Ocean's traditional pattern of open, multilateral trade." -- Maritime historian's analysis.
The Portuguese trading system described in the passage differed from previous Indian Ocean trade primarily because it
- Aeradicated all non-Portuguese commerce across the entire Indian Ocean basin within just a few short decades
- Bused military force to monopolize trade routes that had previously relied on open, voluntary commercial exchangeCorrect
- Cdepended solely on diplomatic negotiation, rather than naval coercion, to secure trading partners
- Dcreated the first direct commercial connections linking the ports of India with those of China and East Asia
Why B is right
The passage contrasts the Portuguese system of military coercion (seizing ports, requiring licenses, threatening destruction) with the Indian Ocean's traditional 'open, multilateral trade.' The Portuguese innovation was using naval military force to attempt monopoly control over trade routes that had previously functioned through voluntary, decentralized commercial exchange.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while the Portuguese disrupted Indian Ocean trade, they never completely eliminated non-Portuguese commerce; many Asian merchants continued trading by evading, resisting, or accommodating Portuguese demands.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly describes military actions -- seizure, fortification, and destruction of unlicensed ships -- indicating reliance on military coercion, not diplomatic negotiation.
- D
- Incorrect because commercial connections between India and China existed for centuries before the Portuguese arrived, through existing Indian Ocean trade networks.