The following text is original practice text.
Economists have long predicted that automation would displace workers in routine, repetitive jobs. Recent data suggest this displacement is occurring in a non-uniform pattern: workers in middle-wage, middle-skill jobs have experienced the greatest job loss, while both high-wage knowledge workers and low-wage manual service workers have seen relative employment stability. This 'hollowing out' of the labor market has polarized wage distribution, concentrating income at the extremes while eroding the middle-class jobs that once provided upward mobility for workers without four-year college degrees.
Which choice best states the main idea of the text?
- AWorkers without four-year college degrees are no longer capable of finding employment in an automated economy.
- BHigh-wage knowledge workers benefit most from automation because their skills complement rather than compete with technology.
- CAutomation hits middle-wage jobs hardest, polarizing the labor market and eroding paths to the middle class.Correct
- DThe displacement of workers by automation is occurring evenly across all wage and skill levels in the economy.
Why C is right
The passage's central argument is that automation hits middle-wage jobs hardest, creating a hollowing-out effect that polarizes wages and erodes the paths to the middle class that once provided upward mobility. Choice C captures this argument accurately.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the text says middle-class jobs once provided 'upward mobility' for non-degree workers, not that these workers cannot find any employment.
- B
- Incorrect because while the text notes that high-wage workers have seen relative stability, it does not claim they benefit most from automation or explain why.
- D
- Incorrect because the text explicitly states displacement is occurring in a 'non-uniform pattern,' not evenly.
The following text is original practice text.
Economists studying the effects of industrial automation on employment have found divergent outcomes depending on the type of work involved. Routine tasks—both cognitive (data entry, bookkeeping) and physical (assembly-line operations)—have been most vulnerable to automation, with employment in these categories declining significantly since the 1980s. By contrast, non-routine tasks requiring social intelligence, creativity, or complex situational judgment have seen employment growth, as automation complements rather than replaces these skills. The result is a polarizing labor market: growth at the high-skill, high-wage end and the low-wage service sector, with hollowing out of middle-skill, middle-wage routine jobs.
According to the text, automation has caused labor market polarization by
- Aprimarily eliminating high-wage professional jobs while preserving low-wage service sector employment.
- Breplacing all categories of human work equally, forcing workers across skill levels to compete for fewer available positions.
- Celiminating jobs in manufacturing while creating an equivalent number of new positions in the technology sector.
- Ddisproportionately reducing middle-skill routine jobs while leaving high-skill non-routine and low-skill service jobs less affected.Correct
Why D is right
The passage describes polarization as growth at the high-skill, high-wage end and in the low-wage service sector, with 'hollowing out of middle-skill, middle-wage routine jobs.' This matches choice D: routine middle-skill jobs are disproportionately reduced while high-skill non-routine and low-skill service jobs are less affected.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage says high-skill non-routine jobs have grown, not been eliminated.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly describes differential impacts by task type, not equal replacement across all categories.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage describes occupational category effects (routine vs. non-routine), not a sector-by-sector trade between manufacturing and technology.
While researching the economics of automation, a student has taken the following notes:
• Automation—the use of machines and artificial intelligence to perform tasks previously done by humans—has been replacing certain categories of work since the Industrial Revolution.
• Economists David Autor and David Dorn found that routine, codifiable tasks (both manual and cognitive) are most vulnerable to automation, while non-routine and interpersonal tasks are more resistant.
• Manufacturing employment in the United States fell from approximately 19 million workers in 1979 to about 12 million in 2023.
• Economists debate whether automation destroys net jobs or merely shifts employment to new sectors; the Industrial Revolution, for example, ultimately created far more jobs than it eliminated.
• A McKinsey Global Institute report estimated that by 2030, 15% of the global workforce—approximately 400 million workers—could be displaced by automation.
The student wants to explain which categories of work are most at risk from automation and why. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
- AThe historical precedent of the Industrial Revolution suggests that automation may ultimately create more jobs than it destroys, as happened when mechanization shifted workers from agriculture into new industries rather than eliminating employment overall.
- BA McKinsey Global Institute report projected that approximately 400 million workers globally could be displaced by automation by 2030, though economists continue to debate whether automation ultimately creates or destroys net employment.
- CAutomation has already significantly reduced manufacturing employment in the United States, which fell from approximately 19 million workers in 1979 to about 12 million in 2023—a decline that many economists attribute in part to labor-saving technologies.
- DEconomists David Autor and David Dorn found that routine, codifiable tasks, whether manual or cognitive, are most vulnerable to automation because machines can replicate them by rule, while non-routine and interpersonal tasks are more resistant.Correct
Why D is right
Choice D identifies the categories most at risk (routine, codifiable tasks, both manual and cognitive) and explains why (machines can replicate them by rule), using Autor and Dorn's research to accomplish the student's stated goal of explaining which categories of work are most vulnerable and why.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because this choice focuses on the historical precedent of job creation and does not address which categories of work are most vulnerable to automation.
- B
- Incorrect because this choice presents the displacement projection and the broader debate about net job creation but does not explain which categories of work are most at risk.
- C
- Incorrect because this choice presents manufacturing employment data as evidence of automation's impact but does not explain which categories of work are most at risk or why.