The following text is original practice text.
Festinger and Carlsmith's 1959 experiment on cognitive dissonance remains one of social psychology's most counterintuitive findings. Participants were asked to perform a tedious task and then paid either $1 or $20 to tell the next participant the task was enjoyable. Those paid $1—who had insufficient external justification for lying—reduced their dissonance by convincing themselves the task was actually enjoyable. Those paid $20, with ample external justification, did not need to change their attitude. The experiment demonstrated that insufficient reward, paradoxically, can be more effective at producing genuine attitude change than large rewards.
Which choice best describes the overall structure of the text?
- AA research finding is presented, its methodology is criticized as ethically problematic, and an improved alternative is proposed.
- BTwo conflicting theories of attitude change are presented, and an experiment is described as resolving the conflict in favor of one.
- CA classic experiment and its design are described, its counterintuitive finding is explained, and the theoretical point is stated.Correct
- DA psychologist's career is summarized, and the experiment that made him famous is described in detail.
Why C is right
The text describes the experiment (tedious task, two payment conditions), explains the counterintuitive finding ($1 produced more attitude change), and states the theoretical conclusion about insufficient reward. This is design, finding, conclusion.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because no ethical critique of the methodology is offered; the text presents the experiment as a classic, not a problematic one.
- B
- Incorrect because no two competing theories are introduced before the experiment; the experiment itself generated the insight.
- D
- Incorrect because no career summary is provided; Festinger and Carlsmith are mentioned only as the experiment's authors.
The following text is original practice text.
Leon Festinger's cognitive dissonance theory, proposed in 1957, holds that people experience psychological discomfort when they hold two or more contradictory beliefs, or when their behavior contradicts their beliefs. To reduce this discomfort, people change their beliefs, change their behavior, or add new cognitions that reconcile the contradiction. Festinger's classic experiment required participants to perform a tedious task and then tell the next participant it was interesting. Participants paid $1 to lie later reported finding the task more interesting than participants paid $20. Festinger's explanation: the $1 group had insufficient external justification for lying, so they changed their beliefs to align with their behavior.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support Festinger's explanation of the $1/$20 result?
- AThe more tedious the task participants performed, the larger the attitude change shown by both the $1 and $20 groups, confirming that task difficulty moderates dissonance.
- BParticipants paid $1 who were given a believable external justification for lying (for example, being told they had meaningfully helped the researcher) did not show the attitude change toward the task.Correct
- CParticipants paid $20 also rated the task as interesting when asked two weeks later, suggesting that attitude change from dissonance reduction persists over time.
- DParticipants paid $1 later reported feeling more guilty about lying than those paid $20 did, suggesting they were more aware of the contradiction between their behavior and their stated beliefs about the task.
Why B is right
Festinger's explanation is that the $1 group changed their attitudes because they lacked external justification for lying. If giving the $1 group an external justification eliminates the attitude change, this directly confirms that insufficient justification—not the lie itself—caused the attitude shift.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because task difficulty affecting both groups equally would suggest dissonance mechanism generalizes to difficulty, but does not specifically test the external justification mechanism.
- C
- Incorrect because $20 participants also rating the task as interesting later would contradict the original finding (they should not have changed their beliefs because they had sufficient justification) and complicate rather than support Festinger's explanation.
- D
- Incorrect because greater guilt in the $1 group suggests more discomfort but does not directly test whether the absence of external justification caused attitude change.
The concept of cognitive dissonance, introduced by psychologist Leon Festinger in 1957, describes the mental discomfort people experience when they hold two or more contradictory beliefs simultaneously, or when their behavior conflicts with their stated values. People are motivated to reduce this discomfort. _______, a person who smokes cigarettes despite believing smoking is harmful may rationalize the behavior by telling themselves that the health risks are overstated.
- ABy contrast,
- BFor example,Correct
- CMoreover,
- DConsequently,
Why B is right
'For example' correctly introduces a concrete illustration of the cognitive dissonance reduction described in the preceding sentence. The smoker's rationalization is a specific example of how someone reduces discomfort by altering their beliefs.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 'by contrast' introduces an opposing idea, but the smoker example is consistent with and illustrative of the dissonance reduction described.
- C
- Incorrect because 'moreover' adds a new, supplementary point, but the smoker example illustrates the preceding claim rather than adding a new idea.
- D
- Incorrect because 'consequently' signals a result, implying that smokers rationalizing is a consequence of people generally being motivated to reduce discomfort—which is closer to an example than a consequence in this context.