The following text is original practice text.
A team of primatologists studying chimpanzees in Uganda recorded over four hundred distinct gestural communications used by the animals in natural social contexts. The researchers found that many of these gestures were used flexibly—a single gesture could convey different meanings depending on the social situation, and the same meaning could be conveyed by multiple gestures. This flexibility, previously thought to be unique to human language, suggests that the foundations of intentional, context-dependent communication may have deep evolutionary roots predating the emergence of Homo sapiens.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the researchers' conclusion?
- AHuman infants begin using intentional gestures before they develop spoken language, suggesting that gesture precedes speech in development.
- BThe same gestural flexibility observed in the Ugandan chimpanzees is also found in gorillas and bonobos, other great apes closely related to humans.Correct
- CChimpanzees in captivity use fewer distinct gestures than wild chimpanzees, suggesting that social complexity drives gestural development.
- DSome chimpanzee gestures are learned from other group members rather than being entirely innate, implying a degree of cultural transmission.
Why B is right
The researchers conclude that context-dependent communication has 'deep evolutionary roots.' Finding the same flexibility across multiple great apes would indicate this trait is ancestral and predates human evolution, directly supporting the claim.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because human infant development patterns do not speak to the evolutionary origins of flexible communication in non-human primates.
- C
- Incorrect because the relationship between social complexity and gesture development does not directly address whether flexible communication predates humans evolutionarily.
- D
- Incorrect because cultural transmission in chimpanzees is an interesting finding but does not specifically support the claim about evolutionary roots of flexible communication.
The following text is original practice text.
Researchers studying volatile organic compounds (VOCs) emitted by plants have found evidence that some plants use airborne chemical signals to warn neighboring plants of herbivore attacks. When a plant is damaged by insects, it releases specific VOCs that trigger defensive responses in nearby plants of the same species—including the production of compounds that make leaves less palatable or more toxic to insects. Critics have argued that this phenomenon should not be characterized as 'communication' because plants lack the neurological structures associated with intentional signaling in animals. Proponents counter that the functional outcome—information transfer that changes behavior—meets any reasonable definition of communication regardless of the mechanism.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the critics' position?
- AThe same VOC compounds released during herbivore attack are also emitted by plants during drought stress, indicating they do not carry specific herbivore-related information.
- BPlants exposed to VOC signals from damaged neighbors show defensive responses twenty times faster than plants that are directly damaged themselves.
- CThe VOCs released by damaged plants also attract predatory insects that eat the herbivores responsible for the damage.
- DNeighboring plants increase their defensive compound production just as much when they receive no VOC signals from damaged plants.Correct
Why D is right
The critics' position is that the phenomenon is not true communication. If neighboring plants increase defensive production just as much without receiving VOC signals, then the VOCs are not causing the response—undermining the claim that information is being transferred and received.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while this finding complicates the specificity of the signal, it does not directly support the critics' neurological argument or show that communication is not occurring.
- B
- Incorrect because faster defensive responses in neighbors would support the proponents' view that the VOC signal is functionally effective, not the critics' position.
- C
- Incorrect because VOCs attracting predatory insects shows the signals have ecological effects but does not support the critics' argument that this isn't communication.
The following text is original practice text.
A public health researcher is studying whether different communication strategies affect vaccine uptake among vaccine-hesitant adults. She hypothesizes that messages that address specific safety concerns will be more effective than general benefit messages.
The researcher conducts a randomized experiment with 800 vaccine-hesitant participants:
Table: Vaccine uptake rates by communication strategy
| Communication strategy | Vaccination rate at 3-month follow-up |
|---|---|
| No intervention (control) | 18% |
| General benefit message ('Vaccines protect you and your community') | 24% |
| Concern-addressing message ('Vaccines have been rigorously tested for safety') | 39% |
| Personalized concern-addressing message (tailored to individual's specific concern) | 51% |
Which choice uses data from the table to most directly support the researcher's hypothesis?
- AAll three intervention strategies produced higher vaccination rates than the control, confirming that any communication effort is more effective than no intervention.
- BThe personalized concern-addressing message achieved a vaccination rate 51% higher than the no-intervention control, demonstrating its effectiveness.
- CThe general benefit message increased vaccination rates by 6 percentage points over the control, suggesting that even simple messaging has some effect on hesitant adults.
- DBoth concern-addressing messages produced higher vaccination rates than the general benefit message, with personalized messages achieving the highest rate of all strategies tested.Correct
Why D is right
The hypothesis predicts that concern-addressing messages will outperform general benefit messages. Choice D directly supports this: both concern-addressing strategies (39% and 51%) exceeded the general benefit message rate (24%), with the personalized concern-addressing message achieving the highest rate of all (51%). The other options compare interventions to the control rather than to the general benefit message, so they do not test the hypothesis's specific claim.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while all strategies outperformed control, this observation supports the general value of any communication rather than specifically the hypothesis about concern-addressing versus general benefit messages.
- B
- Incorrect because this misrepresents the data: the personalized message achieved a 51% vaccination rate, not a 51 percentage point increase over the control (which would be 18+51=69%).
- C
- Incorrect because this observation describes the general benefit message's performance relative to control, not the comparison between concern-addressing and general benefit messages that the hypothesis predicts.