The following text is original practice text. The report concluded that not only ________ the carbon tax effective at reducing emissions, but it also generated significant revenue that was redirected to renewable energy subsidies.
Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?
- Ais
- Bhas been
- CwasCorrect
- Dhad been
Why C is right
When the correlative conjunction "not only" begins a clause, the sentence undergoes subject-verb inversion, placing the verb before the subject. The structure becomes "not only was the carbon tax effective" rather than "not only the carbon tax was effective." Since the report's finding is described in the past and "but it also generated" uses simple past tense, "was" correctly maintains consistent past tense.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because "is" uses the present tense, but the sentence describes a past finding ("The report concluded"). Consistency with the surrounding past-tense verbs requires past tense here as well.
- B
- Incorrect because "has been" is present perfect, implying ongoing relevance to the present. Since the sentence is reporting a past conclusion using past tense throughout, the present perfect creates an inconsistent time frame.
- D
- Incorrect because "had been" is past perfect, which would imply that the carbon tax's effectiveness preceded some other past event mentioned in the sentence. No such prior reference point is established; the simple past "was" is sufficient.