Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
Wind and solar energy have achieved cost parity with—and in many cases are now cheaper than—fossil fuel electricity generation. Renewable energy installations are now the cheapest source of new electricity capacity in most of the world. These economic facts, combined with declining battery storage costs, suggest that the energy transition is inevitable and accelerating.
Text 2
Cost comparisons between renewables and fossil fuels often omit the full system costs of integrating variable renewable generation. Solar and wind generate electricity only when the sun shines and the wind blows; maintaining grid reliability requires either overbuilding renewable capacity, investing heavily in storage, or maintaining dispatchable backup generation. These integration costs are real and significant and are frequently excluded from levelized cost calculations that make renewables appear cheaper.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the Text 1 author's claim that declining battery storage costs support the inevitability of the energy transition?
- ABy suggesting that grid reliability is not a meaningful constraint because electricity demand is also variable
- BBy arguing that battery storage technology will not improve further and has reached its physical limits
- CBy contending that storage and other integration costs are significant and belong in any honest cost comparisonCorrect
- DBy agreeing that storage costs are declining but arguing that fossil fuel costs are declining at an even faster rate
Why C is right
The author of Text 2 argues that integration costs—including storage—are 'real and significant and frequently excluded' from cost calculations. While the author of Text 1 notes declining storage costs, the author of Text 2 would argue that even declining storage costs leave significant system costs that complicate the picture.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 emphasizes grid reliability as a real constraint, not a non-issue.
- B
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not claim battery technology has reached physical limits; the argument is about current and system costs, not future technology.
- D
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not argue that fossil fuel costs are declining faster; the critique is about omitted integration costs on the renewable side.