Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
The Harlem Renaissance is best understood as a deliberate artistic project. Intellectuals like Alain Locke actively curated which voices and aesthetic styles would represent the 'New Negro' to white patrons and publishers. This curation, while enabling Black artists to reach mainstream audiences, also constrained which stories could be told.
Text 2
To call the Harlem Renaissance a 'deliberate project' risks underestimating the organic energy of its participants. Poets, painters, and musicians were not marionettes guided by elite intellectuals; they pursued individual visions that happened to converge in a moment of extraordinary cultural vitality.
Which choice best describes how the perspective of the author of Text 2 differs from that of the author of Text 1?
- AText 2 argues the Harlem Renaissance was primarily a literary movement, while Text 1 sees it as a visual arts phenomenon.
- BText 2 foregrounds the independence and agency of individual artists, while Text 1 stresses the role of intellectual curation.Correct
- CText 2 emphasizes the commercial motivations of Harlem Renaissance artists, while Text 1 focuses on their political goals.
- DText 2 credits white patrons for the Renaissance's success, while Text 1 credits Black intellectuals.
Why B is right
The author of Text 1 emphasizes Locke's role in curating and shaping the Renaissance (curation by intellectuals), while the author of Text 2 argues artists pursued individual visions independently. This maps directly to B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because both authors refer to multiple art forms (poets, painters, musicians) without privileging one medium.
- C
- Incorrect because neither author focuses on commercial motivation versus political goals; the debate is about agency versus curation.
- D
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not credit white patrons; the Text 2 author credits the artists themselves with organic energy.
Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
The decline of the Western Roman Empire has traditionally been attributed to military pressure from Germanic tribes. This 'barbarian invasion' narrative remains compelling because it is dramatic and well-documented in Roman sources. The fall of Rome becomes a story with identifiable villains and a decisive ending.
Text 2
To treat Germanic migration as the primary cause of Rome's decline is to privilege Roman sources that had every reason to externalize blame. Internal factors—fiscal crisis, plague, agricultural decline, and political fragmentation—had weakened the empire for generations before any Germanic kingdom established itself on former Roman territory.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the Text 1 author's claim that the barbarian invasion narrative is "compelling because it is dramatic and well-documented"?
- ABy agreeing that the narrative is compelling but arguing it should be supplemented with archaeological evidence
- BBy contending that dramatic narratives in history are inherently less reliable than statistical analyses of economic data
- CBy arguing that Roman historical sources are not well-documented enough to support any confident conclusions about the empire's fall
- DBy suggesting that the documentation supporting the narrative reflects the biases of sources motivated to externalize blameCorrect
Why D is right
The author of Text 2 explicitly argues that Roman sources 'had every reason to externalize blame,' meaning the documentation the Text 1 author cites reflects the biases of its sources—it may be extensive, but its origin makes it unreliable. This matches D.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not partially agree with the barbarian narrative; the text pivots entirely to internal factors.
- B
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 never contrasts dramatic narratives with statistical analysis; the argument is about source bias, not narrative form.
- C
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not argue the sources are inadequate in quantity; the critique is about their bias, not their volume.
The following text is original practice text.
The printing press did not create the Protestant Reformation, but it amplified it beyond what any previous reform movement could achieve. Martin Luther's Ninety-Five Theses, nailed to a church door in 1517, would in an earlier era have remained a local dispute. Instead, they were typeset and distributed across German-speaking Europe within weeks. The press transformed arguments that would once have been suppressed or forgotten into a permanent, replicable record that neither the Church nor any secular authority could reliably contain.
The author includes the detail about the Ninety-Five Theses being distributed "within weeks" primarily to
- Ashow that Church authorities failed to suppress the Theses due to poor communication networks
- Bdemonstrate that Luther's arguments were so compelling that readers spread them voluntarily and rapidly
- Cargue that the speed of distribution proved that Luther's theology was already widely accepted before the press
- Dillustrate how quickly the printing press could spread ideas that would once have remained localCorrect
Why D is right
The detail about weeks-long distribution contrasts with the counterfactual that without the press the Theses would have remained local. The rapid spread illustrates the press's transformative power over idea dissemination.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Church communication networks are not discussed; the point is about the press's capability, not Church failure.
- B
- Incorrect because the author attributes rapid spread to the press's technology, not to readers' voluntary enthusiasm.
- C
- Incorrect because the text makes no claim about prior acceptance; the point is about the press enabling what was previously impossible.