The following text is original practice text.
A nutritional epidemiologist is studying the relationship between the proportion of plant-based foods in one's diet and the risk of developing type 2 diabetes. She hypothesizes that individuals consuming higher proportions of plant-based foods will show lower rates of type 2 diabetes incidence.
The researcher analyzes a ten-year cohort study involving 50,000 participants:
Table: Diabetes incidence by dietary pattern over 10 years
| Dietary group | % of calories from plant foods | New type 2 diabetes cases per 1,000 participants |
|---|---|---|
| Low plant diet | 32% | 68 |
| Moderate plant diet | 52% | 51 |
| High plant diet | 70% | 37 |
| Very high plant diet | 88% | 22 |
Which choice most accurately represents the data shown in the table?
- AParticipants in the very high plant diet group developed type 2 diabetes at less than half the rate of participants in the low plant diet group.Correct
- BParticipants consuming fewer than 50% of calories from plant foods had the same diabetes incidence as those consuming more than 70%.
- CThe moderate plant diet group showed no meaningful difference in diabetes incidence compared to the low plant diet group.
- DDiabetes incidence increased with greater plant food consumption across all dietary groups in the study.
Why A is right
The very high plant diet group had 22 cases per 1,000, while the low plant diet group had 68 cases per 1,000. Since 22 is less than half of 68 (half would be 34), this statement is accurate. Choice A correctly represents this comparison.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because participants below 50% plant food consumption had 68 cases per 1,000 while those above 70% had 37—these are substantially different rates.
- C
- Incorrect because the low plant diet group had 68 cases per 1,000 while the moderate group had 51—a meaningful reduction of 17 cases per 1,000.
- D
- Incorrect because the table shows diabetes incidence decreasing (not increasing) as plant food consumption increases.