Marcus studied for hours every night[,] but he still struggled to understand the complex chemistry equations.
Is the comma before 'but' necessary?
- ANo, because the sentence is too short to need a comma.
- BNo, because commas are never used before coordinating conjunctions.
- CYes, because 'but' here joins two independent clauses, and a comma before a coordinating conjunction connecting independent clauses is required.Correct
- DYes, because a comma is required before any coordinating conjunction.
Why C is right
When a coordinating conjunction (FANBOYS) joins two independent clauses, a comma is placed before the conjunction. 'Marcus studied for hours every night' and 'he still struggled to understand the complex chemistry equations' are both independent clauses.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because sentence length has no bearing on comma rules; the grammatical structure (two independent clauses) determines punctuation.
- B
- Incorrect because commas are frequently and correctly used before coordinating conjunctions that join two independent clauses.
- D
- Incorrect because a comma is not required before every coordinating conjunction — only when the conjunction joins two independent clauses, not when it joins words or phrases.
The athlete recovered from his injury[,] and he returned to competition stronger than ever.
Is the comma before 'and' necessary?
- AYes, because 'and' always requires a preceding comma.
- BNo, because commas are not used with the conjunction 'and.'
- CNo, because 'and' here joins a subject with a predicate, not two clauses.
- DYes, because a comma is required before 'and' when it joins two independent clauses.Correct
Why D is right
'The athlete recovered from his injury' and 'he returned to competition stronger than ever' are both independent clauses. A comma is required before a coordinating conjunction (FANBOYS) that joins two independent clauses.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because a comma before 'and' is required only when 'and' joins two independent clauses, not in every use of 'and' (e.g., in a series or with phrases).
- B
- Incorrect because commas are frequently and correctly used before 'and' when it connects two independent clauses.
- C
- Incorrect because 'he returned to competition' is a new independent clause with its own subject ('he'), not simply a predicate of the first clause.
The committee reviewed the applications[, however,] decided not to fill the position at this time. Which choice best corrects the sentence?
- Abut decided not to fill the position at this timeCorrect
- B, however, decided not to fill the position at this time
- C; however, decided not to fill the position at this time
- D— however — decided not to fill the position at this time
Why A is right
The sentence contains two verbs with the same subject ('reviewed...decided'): this is a compound predicate. The coordinating conjunction 'but' correctly joins the two predicates without a comma before it in a compound predicate.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because 'however' used as a parenthetical inside a compound predicate is awkward and nonstandard.
- C
- Incorrect because a semicolon before 'however' would require 'decided not to fill the position' to be an independent clause, but 'decided' still shares its subject with 'reviewed.'
- D
- Incorrect because dashes around 'however' are used for emphatic parenthetical insertions, not for joining compound predicates.