A geneticist analyzes allele frequencies in three isolated populations of the same fish species after 50 generations of separation. The initial frequency of allele B was 0.50 in all three populations.
Population | Population Size | Current Frequency of Allele B
Pop. 1 | 20 | 0.95
Pop. 2 | 500 | 0.53
Pop. 3 | 10,000 | 0.49
Which conclusion best explains the differences among the populations?
- ASmaller populations experience stronger genetic drift, leading to greater deviation from the initial allele frequency.Correct
- BMutation rates are higher in smaller populations, producing new B alleles.
- CNatural selection in Pop. 1 favored allele B, giving its carriers a survival advantage that drove the allele to near-fixation.
- DLarger populations experience more genetic drift, causing greater allele frequency changes.
Why A is right
Genetic drift is random change in allele frequencies from one generation to the next, and its effect is strongest in small populations, where chance has a bigger proportional impact on which alleles get passed on. All three populations started at 0.50. Pop. 1 (size 20) moved the most, to 0.95 (a change of 0.45). Pop. 2 (size 500) moved only slightly, to 0.53 (0.03). Pop. 3 (size 10,000) barely changed, to 0.49 (0.01). The smaller the population, the larger the deviation, which matches drift, so the answer is A.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Mutation rate per gene does not depend on population size, and mutation is far too slow to push a frequency from 0.50 to 0.95 in 50 generations. This choice also fails to explain why Pop. 2 and Pop. 3 barely changed.
- C
- Nothing in the data shows that allele B gives its carriers in Pop. 1 a survival advantage, and selection would not explain why the amount of change follows population size across all three groups. The table supports drift, not selection, as the explanation for all the populations.
- D
- This reverses the relationship in the table: the largest population (10,000) changed the least (0.50 to 0.49), and the smallest (20) changed the most. Drift is weaker in larger populations, not stronger.