Skip to content
ACT · English

Lie vs lay

Lie vs lay appears in 7 reviewed ACT questions and sits in English. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Lie vs lay is tested

Example 1Harder
The book [lay/laid/lain/lies] on the shelf for years before anyone noticed its significance. Which verb form is correct for an object resting on a surface over time?
  1. Alaid
  2. BlayCorrect
  3. Clain
  4. Dlies

Why B is right

'Lay' is the past tense of 'lie' (to recline or rest). 'The book lay on the shelf for years' uses the past tense of the intransitive verb 'lie,' which is correct since the book was resting (not being placed) on the shelf over time in the past.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 'laid' is the past tense of the transitive verb 'lay' (to place something), which requires an object being placed by someone. No one is placing the book here.
C
Incorrect because 'lain' is the past participle of 'lie' and requires a helping verb ('had lain,' 'has lain'); it cannot stand alone as the main verb.
D
Incorrect because 'lies' is the simple present tense of 'lie,' but the sentence requires past tense ('for years before anyone noticed').
Example 2Harder
The museum curator [lay/laid/lain/lying] the ancient mosaic tiles carefully on a padded examination table. Which verb correctly describes the act of placing an object?
  1. Alay
  2. Blying
  3. ClaidCorrect
  4. Dlain

Why C is right

'Laid' is the past tense of the transitive verb 'lay' (to place something). The curator placed the tiles on the table — 'laid' is the correct past tense for this transitive action.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 'lay' is the present tense of 'lay' (to place) or the past tense of 'lie' (to recline); in this past-tense sentence about placing something, 'laid' is correct.
B
Incorrect because 'lying' is the present participle of 'lie' (to recline) and requires a helping verb to form a complete predicate.
D
Incorrect because 'lain' is the past participle of the intransitive 'lie' (to recline); it requires a helping verb and does not mean 'to place.'
Example 3Medium
The documentary [lays/lies/lay/laid] out a compelling argument for major changes to urban housing policy. Which verb is correct for 'to present or set out' (transitive)?
  1. Alaid
  2. BlaysCorrect
  3. Clies
  4. Dlay

Why B is right

'Lays out' is the present tense of the transitive verb 'lay' (to place or present). 'The documentary lays out an argument' — the documentary is placing/presenting the argument. Third-person singular: 'lays.'
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 'laid' is the past tense of 'lay'; the sentence uses present tense.
C
Incorrect because 'lies' is the present tense of the intransitive 'lie' (to recline or be situated); it cannot take a direct object ('an argument').
D
Incorrect because 'lay' is the past tense of 'lie' (intransitive) or the base form of 'lay' (transitive); for the present third-person singular, 'lays' is correct.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from English.