Scientists disagree about whether antibiotic resistance in bacterial populations is primarily driven by natural selection or horizontal gene transfer.
Scientist 1: Antibiotic resistance evolves through natural selection. Random mutations occasionally produce resistant variants. When antibiotics are applied, susceptible bacteria die while resistant ones survive and reproduce, passing resistance genes to offspring. Over many generations, the resistant population grows. This explains why resistance increases in direct proportion to antibiotic use in hospitals.
Scientist 2: Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) — the direct exchange of resistance genes between bacterial cells via plasmids — spreads resistance far faster than selection alone can explain. Bacteria can acquire multiple resistance traits simultaneously through a single plasmid transfer event. Studies show that resistance can spread from one bacterial species to a completely different species within hours, which is impossible through vertical inheritance alone.
Which observation would most directly support Scientist 2's position over Scientist 1's?
- AResistant bacteria have point mutations in genes that encode antibiotic binding targets.
- BA soil bacterium acquires resistance to five antibiotics after being grown alongside resistant S. aureus.Correct
- CHospitals with higher antibiotic prescribing rates have correspondingly higher rates of resistant bacterial infections.
- DThe frequency of resistant bacteria in a population increases over successive generations when antibiotics are present.
Why B is right
A different species acquiring resistance to five antibiotics at once from resistant S. aureus is best explained by HGT via plasmid transfer, not by mutation and selection, which would require many separate mutations over multiple generations.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because point mutations in antibiotic target genes are a product of random mutation and selection, which supports Scientist 1's mechanism.
- C
- Incorrect because greater antibiotic use selecting for resistant strains supports Scientist 1's natural selection argument.
- D
- Incorrect because increasing frequency over generations under antibiotic pressure is the textbook description of natural selection, supporting Scientist 1.
Experiment 7: A microbiologist tested how antibiotic concentration affects bacterial growth. Petri dishes were inoculated with E. coli and exposed to different concentrations of tetracycline. After 24 hours, the number of colony-forming units (CFUs) was counted.
Tetracycline Concentration (μg/mL) | CFU Count (×10⁶)
0 | 450
1 | 320
2 | 185
4 | 62
8 | 8
16 | 0
The Minimum Inhibitory Concentration (MIC) is defined as the lowest concentration that completely inhibits visible bacterial growth. Based on the data, what is the MIC of tetracycline for this E. coli strain?
- A16 μg/mLCorrect
- B8 μg/mL
- C4 μg/mL
- D2 μg/mL
Why A is right
At 8 μg/mL, 8 × 10⁶ CFUs remain, indicating incomplete inhibition. At 16 μg/mL, the CFU count is 0, meaning all bacterial growth is inhibited. By definition, the MIC is the lowest concentration achieving complete inhibition, which is 16 μg/mL.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because at 8 μg/mL, 8 × 10⁶ CFUs are still growing — the bacteria are inhibited substantially but not completely, so this is not the MIC.
- C
- Incorrect because at 4 μg/mL, 62 × 10⁶ CFUs are still present — significant bacterial growth remains, far from complete inhibition.
- D
- Incorrect because at 2 μg/mL, 185 × 10⁶ CFUs persist — less than the control but far from inhibited — making this well below the MIC.
Experiment 1: A biologist studied the effect of antibiotic concentration on the growth of two bacterial strains: a wild-type and a resistant mutant. Growth was measured as optical density (OD600) after 24 hours.
Antibiotic Concentration (μg/mL) | Wild-type OD600 | Resistant Mutant OD600
0 | 1.80 | 1.78
1 | 1.32 | 1.76
4 | 0.44 | 1.71
8 | 0.11 | 1.68
16 | 0.02 | 1.65
32 | 0.00 | 1.60
What does the similar growth of both strains at 0 μg/mL suggest?
- AResistance mutations always increase bacterial growth rate.
- BThe resistant mutant grows more rapidly than the wild-type in antibiotic-free conditions.
- CBoth strains would be equally inhibited by higher antibiotic concentrations.
- DIn the absence of antibiotics, both strains have comparable growth fitness.Correct
Why D is right
At 0 μg/mL, wild-type OD600 = 1.80 and resistant mutant OD600 = 1.78 — nearly identical. This indicates that the resistance mutation does not significantly impair or enhance growth in the absence of antibiotic selection pressure.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the nearly equal growth rates at 0 μg/mL (with wild-type slightly higher) suggests the resistance mutation does not increase growth rate.
- B
- Incorrect because the resistant mutant (1.78) grows slightly less than the wild-type (1.80), not more rapidly.
- C
- Incorrect because the data clearly show the resistant mutant is not inhibited at higher concentrations, while the wild-type is completely inhibited at 32 μg/mL.