A biologist studying natural selection in a beetle population collected data over 5 generations. Initially, 50% of beetles were brown and 50% were green in a brown-leaf forest environment. The table shows how the ratio changed:
Generation | Brown Beetles (%) | Green Beetles (%)
0 | 50 | 50
1 | 62 | 38
2 | 73 | 27
3 | 81 | 19
4 | 88 | 12
5 | 93 | 7
Which explanation best accounts for the observed trend?
- AGreen beetles mutated into brown beetles at an increasing rate over generations.
- BBrown beetles were better camouflaged, so predators ate them less often.Correct
- CBrown beetles reproduced more times per year than green beetles due to a hormonal advantage.
- DGreen beetles migrated to other habitats, reducing their frequency in this population.
Why B is right
In a brown-leaf environment, brown coloration provides camouflage against predators. Natural selection favors better-camouflaged individuals, leading to increased survival and reproduction of brown beetles each generation — exactly what the data show.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because natural selection does not cause individual organisms to mutate; it acts on variation already present in the population.
- C
- Incorrect because reproductive rate differences due to hormones are not implied by the data, and this mechanism is not related to the environmental selective pressure described.
- D
- Incorrect because migration is not mentioned in the experimental setup, and the question specifically asks about natural selection in this population.
Scientist 1: Antibiotic resistance is primarily an evolutionary problem: when antibiotics kill susceptible bacteria, resistant mutants are selected. Resistance genes arise through random mutation and are amplified by natural selection under antibiotic pressure. The solution is antibiotic stewardship — using antibiotics only when necessary to reduce selection pressure and slow resistance evolution.
Scientist 2: Antibiotic resistance is primarily an ecological problem driven by horizontal gene transfer (HGT) across bacterial species and ecosystems. Resistance genes spread between unrelated bacterial species via plasmids in soil, water, hospitals, and farms — without requiring prior antibiotic exposure. The solution must include environmental remediation: removing antibiotic residues from wastewater, reducing agricultural antibiotic use that contaminates waterways, and monitoring resistance gene spread across ecosystems.
A study shows that soil bacteria from a pristine Arctic site unexposed to antibiotics carry resistance genes identical to those found in hospital pathogens. Which scientist does this evidence most directly support?
- AScientist 2, because the Arctic has high antibiotic levels in permafrost from natural actinomycete bacteria.
- BScientist 1, because the identical genes prove that resistant mutations arise repeatedly and independently.
- CScientist 2, because resistance genes found in antibiotic-naive environments suggest horizontal gene transfer across ecosystems, independent of direct antibiotic selection.Correct
- DScientist 1, because the Arctic bacteria must have evolved resistance independently through natural mutation.
Why C is right
Finding identical resistance genes in pristine Arctic soil (no antibiotic exposure) and hospital pathogens directly supports Scientist 2's argument that resistance genes spread horizontally across ecosystems without requiring antibiotic selection pressure. This could not be explained by convergent evolution (identical genes are unlikely to arise independently by random mutation) but is consistent with HGT and environmental dispersal.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the premise says the site is unexposed to antibiotics; this option invents an alternative explanation not provided in the evidence.
- B
- Incorrect because while identical mutations can theoretically recur, finding the exact same resistance genes in unrelated environments strongly implies genetic transfer, not repeated independent mutation.
- D
- Incorrect because identical gene sequences arising independently by random mutation is essentially impossible; the finding points to gene transfer, not independent evolution.
A biologist conducted a predation experiment using model bird attacks on stick insects (Phasmatodea). Two color morphs exist in the population: green (matches leaves) and brown (matches bark). Predation was measured in two habitat types. Results (% of insects captured per trial): Leaf-dominated habitat: Green morph = 12%, Brown morph = 41%. Bark-dominated habitat: Green morph = 38%, Brown morph = 14%. After 10 generations in leaf-dominated habitat: Green morph frequency = 78%, Brown morph = 22%. The initial population was 50:50. What evolutionary process do these results demonstrate?
- ANatural selection via differential predation based on background matching (crypsis)Correct
- BSexual selection favoring green-colored individuals as mates
- CGenetic drift causing random changes in morph frequency
- DMutation pressure, with recurrent new mutations steadily raising the frequency of the green allele
Why A is right
The data show that predation rates differ between morphs depending on habitat type: green morphs survive better in leaf habitat (12% vs. 41% predation), while brown morphs survive better in bark habitat (14% vs. 38% predation). Over 10 generations in leaf habitat, the green morph increased from 50% to 78% — consistent with natural selection favoring the background-matching (cryptic) phenotype. This is directional natural selection driven by differential predation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the experiment measures bird predation, not mating preferences; there is no evidence of sexual selection in these data.
- C
- Incorrect because genetic drift produces random fluctuations, not the directional pattern seen here (consistent advantage of green in leaf habitat); the experimental design demonstrates differential predation, not random change.
- D
- Incorrect because mutation pressure would require a mutation rate and directionality that are not described; the clear mechanism is differential survival (predation), not mutation.