The student earned a scholarship, [she/who/which/and she] had maintained a perfect GPA throughout high school.
Which option creates a grammatically correct sentence?
- Awho
- Bshe
- Cwhich
- Dand sheCorrect
Why D is right
The stem asks which option creates a grammatically correct sentence. 'And she had maintained a perfect GPA throughout high school' joins two independent clauses with a comma plus the coordinating conjunction 'and,' producing a correct compound sentence. Choice A ('who') is flawed: placed immediately after 'a scholarship,' the relative clause attaches to the nearest noun 'scholarship' rather than to 'student,' a misplaced relative clause. Choice B ('she') creates a comma splice. Choice C ('which') wrongly uses a thing-pronoun for a person. Only D is grammatically correct.
Why the other 2 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because 'she had maintained a perfect GPA' would create a comma splice — two independent clauses joined with only a comma.
- C
- Incorrect because 'which' refers to things, not people; the student is a person, so 'who' is correct.
The merger between the two corporations[,] which was announced last Tuesday[,] is expected to be completed by year's end.
Are the commas around 'which was announced last Tuesday' used correctly?
- AYes; commas correctly set off this nonrestrictive relative clause.Correct
- BNo; 'that' should replace 'which,' and commas should be removed.
- CNo; only one comma is needed, before 'which.'
- DNo; 'which' clauses never require commas.
Why A is right
The relative clause 'which was announced last Tuesday' is nonrestrictive — it provides additional information but is not essential to identifying which merger is being discussed (there is only one). Nonrestrictive clauses are correctly set off by commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because 'that' is used for restrictive clauses (no commas); this clause is nonrestrictive and properly uses 'which' with commas.
- C
- Incorrect because nonrestrictive clauses require commas both before and after the clause (not just before).
- D
- Incorrect because 'which' clauses that are nonrestrictive (providing extra, non-essential information) do require commas.
The film's climactic scene[,] in which the two rivals finally confront each other face to face[,] was filmed over the course of three exhausting days.
Are the commas around the relative clause correct?
- ANo; 'that' should replace 'which' and the commas should be removed.
- BYes; the nonrestrictive relative clause is correctly set off by commas.Correct
- CNo; parentheses should be used instead of commas.
- DNo; semicolons should replace the commas.
Why B is right
The relative clause 'in which the two rivals finally confront each other face to face' is nonrestrictive — it provides additional information about the scene but is not essential to identifying it. Nonrestrictive clauses are correctly set off by commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because nonrestrictive clauses use 'which' with commas, not 'that' without commas; 'that' would indicate a restrictive clause.
- C
- Incorrect because while parentheses could be used, the commas are not wrong; both are acceptable for nonrestrictive modifiers.
- D
- Incorrect because semicolons cannot be used to set off a clause within a sentence; they join independent clauses.