Scientists disagree about the primary cause of the Cambrian Explosion.
Scientist 1: Rising atmospheric oxygen triggered the explosion by making large, metabolically active animals possible.
Scientist 2: The evolution of eyes and predation triggered an evolutionary arms race, rapidly diversifying body plans.
Which finding would most directly challenge Scientist 1's oxygen hypothesis?
- ALarge Cambrian animals had higher oxygen demands than pre-Cambrian animals.
- BOxygen levels rose significantly before the Cambrian but animal diversification lagged by tens of millions of years.Correct
- CFossil evidence shows eyes and mineralized skeletons appearing simultaneously at the Cambrian boundary.
- DPredator-prey fossil pairs are found in the earliest Cambrian deposits.
Why B is right
If oxygen rose significantly well before the Cambrian but animal diversification did not follow immediately, the temporal gap challenges the oxygen hypothesis — if oxygen were the trigger, diversification should have begun when oxygen rose, not tens of millions of years later.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because large animals having higher O2 demands is consistent with Scientist 1's argument, not a challenge to it.
- C
- Incorrect because this finding supports Scientist 2's predation/arms race hypothesis by showing eyes and defenses appeared together at the Cambrian boundary.
- D
- Incorrect because early predator-prey pairs support Scientist 2's arms race model, not challenge Scientist 1's oxygen model.
Figure 3 describes a cross-section through a sedimentary rock sequence exposed on a hillside. From bottom to top: (1) a thick limestone layer containing marine fossils, (2) a thin coal seam, (3) sandstone containing freshwater mollusk fossils, (4) another limestone layer with marine fossils, and (5) a conglomerate layer at the top. A fault cuts through all five layers at a 70° angle.
Based on the principle of original horizontality and the fossil evidence, what sequence of paleoenvironments does this rock sequence suggest?
- AMarine → marine → marine → marine → alluvial fan
- BFreshwater → marine → terrestrial → freshwater → marine
- CMarine → terrestrial/swamp → freshwater → marine → alluvial fanCorrect
- DAlluvial fan → freshwater → marine → terrestrial/swamp → marine
Why C is right
Layer 1 (marine fossils) = marine environment. Layer 2 (coal seam) = terrestrial swamp/forest where plant material accumulated. Layer 3 (freshwater mollusk fossils) = freshwater environment. Layer 4 (marine fossils) = marine environment again. Layer 5 (conglomerate) = high-energy alluvial/river deposit. The sequence from bottom to top reflects changing paleoenvironments.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because it ignores the coal seam (terrestrial) and sandstone with freshwater fossils, which indicate non-marine environments between the two limestone layers.
- B
- Incorrect because it starts with freshwater, but Layer 1 (the bottom/oldest) contains marine fossils, not freshwater.
- D
- Incorrect because it places the alluvial fan (conglomerate) at the bottom, but Layer 1 is limestone with marine fossils, not conglomerate.
Table 4 shows fossil occurrence data for five major animal groups across geological time periods:
Group | First Appearance (million years ago) | Present Today?
Cephalopods (nautiloids) | 500 | Yes
Trilobites | 521 | No (extinct 252 Mya)
Dinosaurs (non-avian) | 230 | No (extinct 66 Mya)
Mammals | 225 | Yes
Hominids | 7 | Yes
A paleontologist argues that the appearance of organisms in the fossil record reflects their actual evolutionary origin. Based on the table, which ordering of evolutionary origin from oldest to most recent is correct?
- ACephalopods → Trilobites → Mammals → Dinosaurs → Hominids
- BHominids → Mammals → Dinosaurs → Cephalopods → Trilobites
- CTrilobites → Cephalopods → Dinosaurs → Mammals → HominidsCorrect
- DMammals → Dinosaurs → Trilobites → Cephalopods → Hominids
Why C is right
Ordering by first appearance from oldest to most recent: Trilobites (521 Mya) → Cephalopods (500 Mya) → Dinosaurs (230 Mya) → Mammals (225 Mya) → Hominids (7 Mya). This is the correct sequence from oldest to most recent evolutionary origin.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because this incorrectly places cephalopods (500 Mya) before trilobites (521 Mya); trilobites appeared ~21 million years earlier.
- B
- Incorrect because this is the reverse order (most recent to oldest), placing hominids first when they evolved most recently at 7 Mya.
- D
- Incorrect because this places mammals (225 Mya) before dinosaurs (230 Mya); dinosaurs appeared approximately 5 million years before mammals.