Scientists disagree about the dominant mechanism driving the movement of tectonic plates.
Scientist 1: Mantle convection is the primary driver of plate tectonics. Hot material rises from deep in the mantle, spreads laterally beneath plates, drags the plates along via friction, then cools and sinks at subduction zones. The pattern of seafloor age (youngest at mid-ocean ridges, oldest near trenches) supports continuous convection-driven spreading.
Scientist 2: Slab pull — the gravitational sinking of cold, dense oceanic plates at subduction zones — provides the dominant force. GPS measurements show plates move faster where they are attached to subducting slabs than where they are not. Convection likely plays a secondary role, but the primary energy input is gravitational potential energy released as slabs sink.
Which observation would most directly challenge Scientist 2's position?
- APlates move at speeds proportional to how much of their edge is attached to a subducting slab.
- BPlates without any subducting slabs move at velocities comparable to those with large slabs.Correct
- CSubducting slabs are denser and colder than the surrounding mantle material.
- DThe oldest oceanic crust is found near subduction zones, not at mid-ocean ridges.
Why B is right
Scientist 2's position depends on slab pull being the dominant force, predicting that plates with more subducting slab should move faster. If plates without subducting slabs move at comparable speeds, this undermines the primacy of slab pull as the driving mechanism.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because this finding would support Scientist 2 by confirming that greater slab attachment correlates with higher plate velocity.
- C
- Incorrect because this confirms a key premise of Scientist 2's argument (dense slabs sink), so it would support rather than challenge the slab-pull hypothesis.
- D
- Incorrect because the pattern of crust age relates to seafloor spreading rates and is the evidence Scientist 1 cites; it would support Scientist 1, not challenge Scientist 2.
Figure 4 describes a diagram of a convergent plate boundary where an oceanic plate (denser, basaltic) subducts beneath a continental plate (less dense, granitic). Features labeled include: (1) a deep ocean trench where the plates meet, (2) a subduction zone where the oceanic plate descends at approximately 45°, (3) a volcanic arc 100–200 km inland from the trench, and (4) a zone of frequent earthquakes along the subducting slab called the Wadati-Benioff zone.
What causes volcanoes to form 100–200 km inland from the trench at a convergent boundary, rather than directly at the trench?
- AThe subducting slab reaches sufficient depth at 100–200 km inland to release water, which lowers the melting point of mantle rock, generating magma that rises.Correct
- BVolcanic activity is driven by friction between the two plates, which is greatest at the inland distance.
- COcean water pulled into the trench resurfaces 100–200 km inland as steam-driven volcanic eruptions.
- DContinental rock is thinner at 100–200 km inland, allowing magma to escape more easily.
Why A is right
As the oceanic slab subducts and reaches depths of about 100 km, elevated pressure forces water out of hydrated minerals in the slab. This water lowers the melting point of the overlying mantle wedge (flux melting), generating magma that rises to form a volcanic arc at the surface directly above the 100 km depth point — which is typically 100–200 km inland from the trench.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because frictional heating is greatest at the shallow, near-trench portion of the subduction zone, not 100–200 km inland where the slab is deeper.
- C
- Incorrect because ocean water does not travel as a liquid through the rock; it is released from mineral structures under pressure and promotes melting of surrounding mantle rock.
- D
- Incorrect because continental crust is generally thicker inland, not thinner, and the driving mechanism is flux melting due to water release, not thickness variation.
Experiment 1: A geologist used magnetic anomaly data to study seafloor spreading at a mid-ocean ridge. Oceanic crust retains the magnetic polarity of Earth's field at the time it forms. The geologist measured the width of magnetic polarity bands on either side of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, where Earth reverses magnetic polarity every 200,000–700,000 years.
Age of Crust (million years ago) | Distance from Ridge (km) | Magnetic Polarity
0–0.78 | 0–20 | Normal (+)
0.78–1.0 | 20–26 | Reversed (-)
1.0–1.8 | 26–46 | Normal (+)
1.8–2.6 | 46–67 | Reversed (-)
2.6–3.6 | 67–92 | Normal (+)
What is the average spreading rate of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge (per side) in cm/year?
- A5.1 cm/year
- B1.0 cm/year
- C2.6 cm/yearCorrect
- D10.2 cm/year
Why C is right
Total distance for one side: 92 km = 9,200,000 cm, over 3.6 million years. Rate = 9,200,000 cm / 3,600,000 years = 2.56 ≈ 2.6 cm/year per side. The data and relationship in the passage point to this result more directly than the other choices.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 5.1 cm/year would be approximately double the correct answer and would represent the full ridge spreading rate (both sides combined), not per side.
- B
- Incorrect because 1.0 cm/year would cover only 36,000,000 cm = 360 km in 3.6 million years, far more than the 92 km shown.
- D
- Incorrect because 10.2 cm/year would represent roughly quadruple the per-side rate — far too fast for the Mid-Atlantic Ridge.