Which sentence uses 'who' or 'which' correctly according to standard relative clause conventions?
- AThe policy which requires safety helmets was introduced in 2019.
- BThe engineer who designed the bridge won a national award.Correct
- CThe textbook which the professor wrote became a bestseller.
- DShe is the student which earned the highest score on the exam.
Why B is right
Use 'who' for people. For things, use 'that' when the clause is restrictive (needed to identify the noun, no commas) and 'which' when it is nonrestrictive (extra information set off by commas). In B, 'who designed the bridge' refers to 'the engineer,' a person, so 'who' is correct. D wrongly uses 'which' for a person ('the student'). A and C use 'which' without commas in restrictive clauses that identify which policy and which textbook, where ACT convention requires 'that.' Only B follows the rules, so the answer is B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The clause 'which requires safety helmets' identifies which policy is meant, so it is restrictive. With no commas, ACT convention calls for 'that requires safety helmets.'
- C
- 'Which the professor wrote' identifies which textbook is meant, so it is a restrictive clause. ACT convention calls for 'that' (or no pronoun at all: 'The textbook the professor wrote').
- D
- 'The student' is a person, so the relative pronoun must be 'who' ('the student who earned the highest score'). 'Which' is never used for people.