Skip to content
ACT · English

Restrictive clause

Restrictive clause appears in 5 reviewed ACT questions and sits in English. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Restrictive clause is tested

Example 1Medium
The documentary [that explores the history of jazz music in New Orleans] has been streaming on multiple platforms since its release. The underlined clause is:
  1. Aa restrictive clause correctly used without commasCorrect
  2. Ba nonrestrictive clause that should be set off with commas
  3. Can appositive phrase that should be set off with commas
  4. Da nonrestrictive clause that should use 'which' instead of 'that'

Why A is right

The clause 'that explores the history of jazz music in New Orleans' restricts the noun 'documentary' — it tells us which documentary is being discussed (not just any documentary). Restrictive clauses use 'that' and are not set off with commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the clause is restrictive, not nonrestrictive — it identifies which specific documentary is meant.
C
Incorrect because the clause is a relative clause introduced by 'that,' not an appositive noun phrase.
D
Incorrect because 'which' is used for nonrestrictive clauses; since this clause is restrictive, 'that' is the correct relative pronoun.
Example 2Medium
The two candidates [who ran for city council in the recent election] offered vastly different visions for the city's future. The underlined clause is:
  1. Aa nonrestrictive clause that should use 'which' instead of 'who'
  2. Ba nonrestrictive clause incorrectly missing commas
  3. Can appositive phrase that should be set off with commas
  4. Da restrictive clause correctly written without commasCorrect

Why D is right

The clause 'who ran for city council in the recent election' restricts which two candidates are being discussed — not just any candidates, but these specific ones. Restrictive clauses are not set off with commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 'who' correctly refers to people; 'which' refers to things and would be wrong here.
B
Incorrect because the clause is restrictive (it identifies which candidates), so commas would be incorrect.
C
Incorrect because this is a relative clause introduced by 'who,' not a noun phrase appositive.
Example 3Medium
The software update [that the developers released last Tuesday] fixed over two hundred known bugs. The underlined clause is:
  1. Anonrestrictive and should use 'which' instead of 'that'
  2. Brestrictive and correctly written without commasCorrect
  3. Cnonrestrictive and should be set off with commas
  4. Da participial phrase incorrectly placed after the noun

Why B is right

The clause 'that the developers released last Tuesday' restricts which software update is meant — not just any update, but the specific one released last Tuesday. Restrictive clauses use 'that' and are not set off with commas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 'which' is used for nonrestrictive clauses; this is a restrictive clause, so 'that' is correct.
C
Incorrect because the clause is restrictive; adding commas would make it seem like all software updates fixed bugs, not just this one.
D
Incorrect because the clause is a relative clause introduced by 'that,' not a participial phrase.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from English.