The professor's analysis was both [penetrating] and [comprehensive], offering readers an unusually thorough treatment of the subject. The sentence uses 'both...and' to:
- Aemphasize that the analysis possessed two complementary qualities simultaneouslyCorrect
- Bcontrast two opposing qualities in the analysis
- Cindicate that one quality was more important than the other
- Dsuggest the analysis was partially effective but not fully successful
Why A is right
'Both...and' is a correlative conjunction that emphasizes the simultaneous presence of two qualities. Here it highlights that the analysis was penetrating AND comprehensive — two positive, complementary qualities that together make it unusually thorough.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because 'penetrating' and 'comprehensive' are complementary, not opposing, qualities; contrast would use 'although' or 'despite.'
- C
- Incorrect because 'both...and' treats the two qualities equally; no hierarchy is implied.
- D
- Incorrect because 'both...and' does not suggest partial effectiveness; it affirms both qualities fully.
A writer includes the following sentence in a paragraph about habitat loss: 'Orangutans, which are found only in Borneo and Sumatra, face extinction due to deforestation.' Why might the writer have included the detail about where orangutans are found?
- ATo emphasize that the threat is geographically limited, making total extinction more plausibleCorrect
- BTo encourage readers to visit Borneo and Sumatra as tourist destinations
- CTo prove that deforestation does not affect animals outside Asia
- DTo suggest that orangutans should be relocated to other continents
Why A is right
The sentence's main claim is that orangutans face extinction from deforestation. Noting that they live only in Borneo and Sumatra shows how small their range is: if the forests on those two islands are cut down, the species has nowhere else to survive. The detail therefore makes the threat of total extinction more believable and supports the paragraph's point about habitat loss, which makes A correct.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Nothing in the sentence or in a paragraph about habitat loss promotes travel. The place names show how limited the orangutans' range is; they are not there to invite tourists.
- C
- The detail is about where orangutans live, not about where deforestation does or does not harm animals. The sentence makes no claim about animals outside Asia.
- D
- The sentence describes the risk to orangutans in their current habitat and proposes no solution. Moving them to other continents is never suggested.
A student writing about urban farming includes this sentence: 'Rooftop gardens, which can produce hundreds of pounds of vegetables annually, also help reduce a building's energy consumption by providing insulation.' Why might the writer have included the phrase 'which can produce hundreds of pounds of vegetables annually'?
- ATo suggest that rooftop gardens should replace grocery stores
- BTo argue that rooftop gardens are more productive than traditional farms
- CTo establish that rooftop gardens are practically useful before introducing their secondary benefitCorrect
- DTo contradict the main claim about energy savings
Why C is right
The phrase 'which can produce hundreds of pounds of vegetables annually' names a concrete, measurable benefit of rooftop gardens: they grow real food. Placing that detail first shows the gardens are practically useful. The word 'also' then adds a second benefit, insulation that lowers energy use. The phrase works as a foundation for the sentence's additional point, so the answer is C.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Nothing in the sentence compares rooftop gardens with grocery stores or suggests replacing them. Producing hundreds of pounds of vegetables shows the gardens are useful, not that they could supply a whole community.
- B
- The sentence never mentions traditional farms, so no comparison is made. The phrase describes what rooftop gardens produce on their own terms, without ranking them against other kinds of farming.
- D
- The word 'also' shows that the energy-saving point adds to the food-production detail rather than conflicting with it. Both ideas present rooftop gardens as beneficial.