Scientists disagree about whether sleep is primarily driven by circadian rhythm or homeostatic sleep pressure.
Scientist 1: Circadian rhythms (internal clocks, melatonin) drive sleep timing.
Scientist 2: Adenosine accumulation during wakefulness drives sleep pressure, and caffeine blocks adenosine receptors to reduce sleepiness.
According to Scientist 2, how does caffeine reduce sleepiness?
- ABy blocking the brain's adenosine receptorsCorrect
- BBy increasing melatonin secretion during the day
- CBy resetting the circadian clock to delay perceived nighttime
- DBy stimulating SCN neurons to extend the wake phase
Why A is right
Scientist 2 explicitly states that 'caffeine blocks adenosine receptors to reduce sleepiness.' This is precisely the mechanism described in Scientist 2's framework, where accumulated adenosine drives sleep pressure; blocking its receptors prevents adenosine from signaling sleepiness.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because melatonin is central to Scientist 1's circadian rhythm model; Scientist 2 does not invoke melatonin as the mechanism for caffeine's effects.
- C
- Incorrect because resetting the circadian clock is a concept from Scientist 1's framework; caffeine's role in the circadian model is not what Scientist 2 describes.
- D
- Incorrect because the SCN (suprachiasmatic nucleus) is Scientist 1's mechanism for circadian regulation; Scientist 2 invokes adenosine receptors, not SCN stimulation.
Scientists disagree about the main drivers of sleep disorders in modern society.
Scientist 1: Artificial light at night — particularly the blue-wavelength light emitted by smartphones, tablets, and LED lighting — suppresses melatonin production and delays the circadian clock. Studies show that 2 hours of tablet use before bed delays sleep onset by 90 minutes and reduces REM sleep. The global rise in sleep disorders tracks precisely with smartphone adoption rates. Reducing blue light exposure in the evening by wearing blue-blocking glasses or using night-mode settings substantially improves sleep quality.
Scientist 2: The dominant driver of modern sleep disorders is psychological stress and social media anxiety, not light per se. When people use devices before bed, it is the content (social comparison, news, notifications) that activates the sympathetic nervous system and elevates cortisol. Studies controlling for device type (active vs. passive screen use) show that reading an ebook with minimal social interaction is far less disruptive than social media use at identical screen brightness. Addressing mental health and stress is more effective than focusing on light filters.
Which experimental design would most directly test whether light or content type causes the sleep disruption?
- AAdminister cognitive performance tests to sleep-deprived subjects after a night of heavy device use.
- BSurvey teenagers about their bedtime device habits and compare their answers to self-reported sleep quality.
- CCompare sleep quality in groups using equally bright devices showing social media vs. passive text.Correct
- DMeasure melatonin levels in a sample of smartphone users at bedtime.
Why C is right
By holding brightness (light) constant while varying content type, this experiment isolates the effect of content versus light. If social media causes worse sleep than passive reading at the same brightness, it supports Scientist 2. If both cause equal disruption despite same brightness, it undermines Scientist 2 and strengthens Scientist 1's light hypothesis.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because cognitive performance after sleep deprivation is a consequence of poor sleep, not a test of the causal mechanism (light vs. content); heavy device use bundles light and content together.
- B
- Incorrect because surveys measure correlation, not causation, and cannot separate light effects from content effects; this design cannot distinguish between the two hypotheses.
- D
- Incorrect because measuring melatonin levels tests only the light-melatonin pathway (Scientist 1's mechanism) without comparing it to content effects; it cannot resolve the dispute.
A researcher measured the effect of sleep duration on next-day reaction time (ms) in 30 adult volunteers. Each subject was tested after five different sleep durations. Average reaction time (ms) by sleep duration: 4 hours: 387 ms. 5 hours: 342 ms. 6 hours: 298 ms. 7 hours: 265 ms. 8 hours: 256 ms. 9 hours: 258 ms. 10 hours: 272 ms. What is the optimal sleep duration for minimizing reaction time based on these data?
- A7 hours
- B9 hours
- C8 hoursCorrect
- D10 hours
Why C is right
Reaction time (lower = better) reaches its minimum at 8 hours sleep (256 ms). At 9 hours, reaction time increases slightly to 258 ms, and at 10 hours it rises further to 272 ms. The optimal performance occurs at exactly 8 hours, which minimizes reaction time.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because at 7 hours the reaction time is 265 ms, still improving; the minimum is reached at 8 hours (256 ms).
- B
- Incorrect because at 9 hours the reaction time (258 ms) is slightly higher than at 8 hours (256 ms), indicating performance has begun to decline.
- D
- Incorrect because at 10 hours the reaction time (272 ms) is substantially higher than the minimum at 8 hours, suggesting performance decreases with excessive sleep.