Table 3 shows data from a soil analysis comparing properties of three soil types at the same depth:
Soil Type | Particle Size (mm) | Water Retention (%) | Drainage Rate (cm/hr) | Organic Matter (%)
Sand | 0.05–2.0 | 10 | 25 | 1
Loam | 0.002–2.0 | 35 | 7 | 5
Clay | <0.002 | 65 | 0.5 | 3
A farmer wants to grow crops requiring moderate water drainage (5–10 cm/hr) and high organic matter. Which soil type best meets both criteria?
- ASand
- BLoamCorrect
- CA mixture of sand and clay in equal proportions
- DClay
Why B is right
Loam has a drainage rate of 7 cm/hr (within the 5–10 cm/hr range) and the highest organic matter content (5%), making it the only soil type that satisfies both criteria specified by the farmer.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because sand has a drainage rate of 25 cm/hr, far exceeding the 5–10 cm/hr requirement, and contains only 1% organic matter.
- C
- Incorrect because the question asks about the soil types presented in the table; a mixture is not one of the measured options, and the table contains sufficient data to identify the best match.
- D
- Incorrect because clay has a drainage rate of only 0.5 cm/hr, well below the required 5–10 cm/hr range.
Experiment 2: A biologist studied the relationship between soil moisture and the height of prairie grasses in a gradient from dry upland to wet lowland sites along a 2 km transect:
Site | Distance from Upland (m) | Soil Moisture (%) | Mean Grass Height (cm)
1 | 0 | 8 | 42
2 | 400 | 15 | 71
3 | 800 | 24 | 103
4 | 1,200 | 38 | 142
5 | 1,600 | 52 | 168
6 | 2,000 | 68 | 158
Why does mean grass height decrease slightly at the wettest site (68% soil moisture) compared to site 5 (52%)?
- AWaterlogged soils may create anaerobic conditions that limit root respiration and nutrient uptake.Correct
- BThe grass species at site 6 is genetically shorter.
- CSalt concentration increases at wet lowland sites, stunting growth.
- DHigher moisture reduces photosynthesis by decreasing CO2 concentration.
Why A is right
At very high soil moisture (68%), soils become waterlogged and oxygen-depleted (anaerobic). Plant roots require oxygen for aerobic respiration; anaerobic conditions reduce nutrient uptake and can cause root damage, explaining the slight decrease in grass height despite ample water.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the experiment measures the same community of prairie grasses across a moisture gradient; genetic differences between sites are not implied by the transect design.
- C
- Incorrect because salt concentration is not typically elevated in freshwater prairie lowlands; saline conditions would require a separate explanation and are not suggested by the experimental setup.
- D
- Incorrect because photosynthesis is not limited by high soil moisture; CO2 availability is governed by atmospheric concentration and stomatal opening, not soil water content.
Scientists studied the relationship between soil organic matter (SOM, %) and water-holding capacity (WHC, % water by dry mass) across six soil types. Data: Sand: SOM = 0.8%, WHC = 12%. Sandy loam: SOM = 1.6%, WHC = 24%. Loam: SOM = 2.4%, WHC = 38%. Clay loam: SOM = 3.1%, WHC = 52%. Clay: SOM = 4.2%, WHC = 68%. Peat: SOM = 48%, WHC = 380%. A student claims that for every 1% increase in SOM, WHC increases by approximately 15%. Is this claim supported by the data for mineral soils (excluding peat)?
- AYes, but only between sandy loam and clay soils; the 15% claim does not apply to sand.
- BNo, the relationship in mineral soils is non-linear and the 15% claim underestimates the actual rate at high SOM.
- CNo, the rate of WHC increase per 1% SOM increase is much higher in peat than in mineral soils.
- DYes, the data show approximately 15% increase in WHC per 1% SOM increase throughout the range of mineral soils.Correct
Why D is right
Checking the rate for mineral soils: Sand to Sandy loam: ΔWHC = 12 pp, ΔSOM = 0.8%; rate = 12/0.8 = 15%/1% SOM. Sandy loam to Loam: ΔWHC = 14 pp, ΔSOM = 0.8%; rate = 17.5%/1% SOM. Loam to Clay loam: ΔWHC = 14 pp, ΔSOM = 0.7%; rate = 20%/1% SOM. Clay loam to Clay: ΔWHC = 16 pp, ΔSOM = 1.1%; rate = 14.5%/1% SOM. Average rate across mineral soils ≈ 15–16%/1% SOM. The claim is approximately supported. Answer A is the best available answer.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the sand-to-sandy loam segment (the first interval) actually gives almost exactly 15%/1% SOM (12/0.8 = 15), which supports applying the claim to sand as well.
- B
- Incorrect because the rate across mineral soils ranges from ~14.5 to ~20 per 1% SOM, averaging approximately 15–17 — broadly consistent with the 15% claim; the claim is not a dramatic underestimate.
- C
- Incorrect because this answer addresses peat, but the question asks about mineral soils only; the student's claim is restricted to mineral soils (sand through clay).