Selection for Antibiotic Resistance in E. coli
Researchers grew ten replicate populations of Escherichia coli in flasks of liquid growth medium. Five flasks contained a low dose of streptomycin, an antibiotic that blocks the bacterial ribosome. Five control flasks contained no antibiotic. Every 24 hours, a sample from each flask was transferred to a fresh flask of the same type. After each transfer, the researchers plated a sample from each flask onto high-streptomycin agar and recorded the percentage of cells that formed colonies (percent resistant).
Mean percent resistant cells: Day 0 — control flasks: 0.001%; streptomycin flasks: 0.001% Day 4 — control flasks: 0.001%; streptomycin flasks: 12% Day 8 — control flasks: 0.002%; streptomycin flasks: 64% Day 12 — control flasks: 0.001%; streptomycin flasks: 98%
Separately, the researchers found that in antibiotic-free medium, resistant cells divide about 15% more slowly than susceptible cells.
- (a)Describe the role of genetic variation in evolution by natural selection. Explain how streptomycin-resistant cells can be present in populations that have never been exposed to streptomycin. [2 pts]
- (b)Identify the dependent variable in this experiment. Explain why the flasks without antibiotic are a necessary control for the researchers' conclusion. [2 pts]
- (c)Describe the difference in how percent resistance changes over time between the streptomycin flasks and the control flasks. Support your description with specific data from the table. [2 pts]
- (d)On day 12, the researchers remove streptomycin from the five treated flasks and continue daily transfers in antibiotic-free medium for 12 more days. Predict how the percentage of resistant cells in these flasks will change, and justify your prediction using the growth-rate data. [3 pts]