Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Short FRQs

4 points4 original prompts8 scored examples

Section II of the AP Biology exam gives you six free-response questions in 90 minutes, and the section counts for 50% of your exam score. Questions 1 and 2 are the long FRQs, while Questions 3 through 6 are the short FRQs, worth 4 points each, so together the four short questions carry 16 raw points. Each long question is worth roughly twice as much as a short one, so the short questions make up close to half the section, which is why you should never leave them for the last ten minutes.

On this page · 6 sections

Each short question has a fixed job: - Question 3, Scientific Investigation: an experiment is described, usually without results. You explain the biology behind it, identify parts of the design, and predict results. - Question 4, Conceptual Analysis: a biological situation with a change in it. You describe and explain the process, then predict the effect of a disruption and justify it. - Question 5, Analyze a Model or Visual Representation: a diagram, pathway, or model. You describe what it shows, explain how its parts relate, and use or extend the model. - Question 6, Analyze Data: a table or graph. You describe the data, sometimes calculate, and use the data to evaluate a claim or hypothesis.

In released exams the 4 points on each short question are spread across its lettered parts. Often that means four parts, (a) through (d), at 1 point each. Some questions have fewer lettered parts, and a part can split into (i) and (ii), with each sub-item scored as its own point. A prediction and its justification are normally two separate points, so you can earn the prediction point even if your reasoning misses. Plan on roughly 10 minutes per short question, which leaves about 25 minutes for each long question.

Readers score point by point against a rubric, looking for the specific statement each part asks for, and extra correct material earns nothing extra. A statement that contradicts your correct answer inside the same part can cost you that point, so never argue both sides. The task verb tells you what earns the point. "Identify" needs a short, exact answer with no explanation, while "describe" needs the relevant features. "Explain" needs the how or why: the mechanism. "Justify" needs evidence or reasoning that supports a claim you already made. "Calculate" needs the work and the number. Label each answer (a) through (d) so the reader can find it quickly.

The rubric, in plain terms

4 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Describe or explain the core concept (usually part a)1 pt

The letters are not fixed. Each of Questions 3 to 6 mixes these four skills in its own order, so read each part's verb and match it to a row here. This point goes to stating the biological concept or process the question rests on, accurately and with its mechanism. On Scientific Investigation (Q3) and Conceptual Analysis (Q4), it is usually the opening part: for an enzyme, say it lowers activation energy by binding substrate at its active site, not that it 'adds energy'. On Model questions (Q5), it is describing what one component does in the diagram. On Data questions (Q6), the matching point is describing the data: name the trend and quote at least one real value.

Identify a design element, or analyze a relationship or calculate1 pt

Give the one precise item the part asks for. On Q3, that is usually a controlled variable, a control group, or a null hypothesis. On Q4, it is often explaining how one step of the process causes the next, such as how an inducer releases a repressor from DNA. On Q5, it is a relationship between parts of the diagram. On Q6, it is often a calculation with the work shown and a correct final value. A vague answer, such as 'keep conditions the same', earns nothing.

Predict an outcome, or use evidence to evaluate a claim1 pt

On Q3, Q4 and Q5, this is usually a clear directional prediction (increase, decrease, no change) that follows from the new condition or disruption in the stem. On Q6, this point usually goes to using specific values from the data to say whether they support or refute a stated claim, and the prompt will tell you when values are required. Either way, the answer must commit to one outcome.

Justify the prediction with a mechanism1 pt

Supply the reasoning behind the prediction or result, using a biological mechanism. Name what changes at the molecular, cellular, or population level, and show how that change produces the outcome. Restating the prediction in new words earns nothing, and neither does an explanation built on a misconception, such as organisms mutating on purpose. On Q4 and Q5 this is usually the last part, and it must follow the specific disruption the stem describes.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Temperature and an Enzyme from a Cold-Water Fish (Scientific Investigation)

Antarctic icefish live in seawater as cold as -1.9°C. Lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) is an enzyme that converts pyruvate to lactate. In doing so it oxidizes NADH to NAD+.

Researchers purified LDH from icefish muscle and from cow muscle. Cow body temperature is about 38°C. The researchers plan to measure the initial reaction rate of each enzyme at 0°C, 10°C, 20°C, 30°C, and 40°C. They will measure the rate as the micromoles of NADH used per minute. Each reaction tube will contain a buffer, pyruvate, NADH, and one of the two enzymes. Earlier work showed that icefish LDH unfolds above about 30°C, and the unfolded chains clump together into clusters that do not refold when the sample is cooled.

  1. (a)Describe how LDH increases the rate of the reaction it catalyzes. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Identify one variable, other than temperature, that the researchers must keep the same in every reaction tube. [1 pt]
  3. (c)In a separate trial, the researchers hold a sample of icefish LDH at 40°C for 15 minutes. They then cool it to 0°C and measure its reaction rate. Predict how this rate will compare with the rate of icefish LDH that was kept cold the whole time and measured at 0°C. [1 pt]
  4. (d)Justify your prediction from part (c). [1 pt]
Prompt 2

Switching On the Genes for Lactose Use (Conceptual Analysis)

In the bacterium Escherichia coli, three genes needed to use the sugar lactose sit next to each other on the chromosome and are transcribed together as one mRNA. One of them codes for the enzyme β-galactosidase, which splits lactose into glucose and galactose. This group of genes, called the lac operon, has a promoter where RNA polymerase binds and an operator, a short DNA sequence that lies between the promoter and the genes.

A separate gene, lacI, is always transcribed and codes for a repressor protein. When the cell takes in lactose, some of it is converted to allolactose, which can bind the repressor. In all parts of this question, assume the growth medium contains no glucose.

  1. (a)Describe the role of the repressor protein when no lactose is present. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Explain how adding lactose to the medium leads to transcription of the lac operon genes. [1 pt]
  3. (c)A mutant strain has a change in the operator sequence that prevents the repressor from binding to it. The lacI gene and the repressor protein are normal. Predict the amount of β-galactosidase this strain will make when no lactose is present, compared with a normal strain in the same medium. [1 pt]
  4. (d)Justify your prediction from part (c). [1 pt]
Prompt 3

A Signaling Pathway That Releases Glucose (Model or Visual Representation)

A diagram shows how a liver cell responds to the hormone epinephrine. The steps, in order, are: 1. Epinephrine binds a G protein-coupled receptor on the outside of the plasma membrane. 2. The receptor changes shape and activates a G protein by causing it to swap GDP for GTP. 3. The active G protein activates the membrane enzyme adenylyl cyclase. 4. Adenylyl cyclase converts ATP to cyclic AMP (cAMP) in the cytoplasm. 5. cAMP binds and activates protein kinase A (PKA). 6. PKA phosphorylates phosphorylase kinase, which then phosphorylates and activates glycogen phosphorylase. 7. Glycogen phosphorylase breaks glycogen into glucose-1-phosphate. The cell converts this to glucose and releases it into the blood.

The diagram also shows that the G protein switches itself off by hydrolyzing its bound GTP to GDP, and that an enzyme called phosphodiesterase breaks down cAMP.

  1. (a)Describe the role of cAMP in this pathway. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Based on the model, explain how the binding of one epinephrine molecule can lead to the release of many glucose molecules. [1 pt]
  3. (c)A mutation produces a G protein that can bind GTP but cannot hydrolyze it. Predict how glucose release by a liver cell with this mutation will change after epinephrine is removed from the blood. [1 pt]
  4. (d)Justify your prediction from part (c). [1 pt]
Prompt 4

Shell Color and Bird Predation on Two Islands (Data Analysis)

A species of land snail lives on two nearby islands. Shell color is controlled by one gene with two alleles. The allele for a dark shell (D) is dominant to the allele for a pale shell (d). Island A is covered in dark volcanic rock. Island B is covered in pale coral sand.

Researchers tethered 100 live dark-shelled snails and 100 live pale-shelled snails at random spots on each island. After 48 hours they counted how many snails of each color had been taken by thrushes, birds that hunt by sight. They also surveyed the shell colors of free-living adult snails on each island.

Table 1. Percent of tethered snails taken by thrushes in 48 hours Island A (dark rock): pale shells 62%; dark shells 18% Island B (pale sand): pale shells 15%; dark shells 57%

Table 2. Frequency of dark-shelled adults in the wild population Island A: 0.84 Island B: 0.11

The researchers hypothesize that bird predation on snails that do not match their background maintains the difference in shell color between the islands.

  1. (a)Using Table 1, describe how the color of the background affects which snails thrushes take. [1 pt]
  2. (b)For the purpose of this calculation, assume the snail population on Island B is in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium for the shell-color gene. Calculate the frequency of the D allele on Island B. Show your work. [1 pt]
  3. (c)Use specific values from Table 1 to evaluate whether the results support the researchers' hypothesis. [1 pt]
  4. (d)Explain how differences in predation like those in Table 1 could produce, over many generations, the different shell-color frequencies shown in Table 2. [1 pt]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Temperature and an Enzyme from a Cold-Water Fish (Scientific Investigation) · high-scoring response4/4

a) LDH binds pyruvate and NADH in its active site. It holds them in a position that stabilizes the transition state, so it lowers the activation energy of the reaction. More molecules can get over the energy barrier per second, so the reaction goes faster. LDH does not change the ΔG of the reaction.

b) The concentration of pyruvate must be the same in every tube.

c) The rate of the heated icefish LDH will be lower than the rate of the icefish LDH that was kept cold.

d) Icefish LDH evolved to work at about -2°C, so its structure is held together by weak bonds that only need to be stable at cold temperatures. At 40°C the extra heat breaks the hydrogen bonds and other weak interactions that hold its tertiary structure. The protein unfolds (denatures), so the active site changes shape and pyruvate can't bind well. The stem says the unfolded icefish LDH clumps together, so cooling it back to 0°C doesn't bring the shape back. Fewer working enzyme molecules are left, so the rate drops.

How it scored

1/1a — Earned: Names the mechanism: binding at the active site, stabilizing the transition state, lowering activation energy. The added note that ΔG is unchanged is correct and does not contradict anything.
1/1b — Earned: Pyruvate concentration is a specific, valid controlled variable. Enzyme concentration, NADH concentration, pH, or volume would also earn it.
1/1c — Earned: A clear directional prediction: lower.
1/1d — Earned: Explains that heat breaks the weak interactions holding tertiary structure, which changes the active site. It then uses the stem's fact that the unfolded enzyme clumps and does not refold, which is exactly why the rate stays low after cooling.
Temperature and an Enzyme from a Cold-Water Fish (Scientific Investigation) · mid-scoring response2/4

a) LDH gives energy to the reactants so they have enough energy to react. This makes the reaction happen faster.

b) The pH of the buffer should be the same in all the tubes.

c) The heated enzyme will have a lower rate than the one that stayed cold.

d) At 40 degrees the enzyme molecules move too fast, so they bump into the substrate too quickly to bind to it. This makes the reaction slower.

How it scored

0/1a — Not earned: Enzymes do not add energy or raise the energy of the reactants. They lower the activation energy barrier. This is a common misconception and it cannot earn the point.
1/1b — Earned: Buffer pH is a valid variable to hold constant.
1/1c — Earned: Correct directional prediction.
0/1d — Not earned: The rate was measured at 0°C, after cooling, so 'moving too fast at 40°C' does not explain the result. The response never says the enzyme's shape changed. Lasting loss of activity needs denaturation of the active site as its reason.
Switching On the Genes for Lactose Use (Conceptual Analysis) · high-scoring response4/4

a) When there is no lactose, the repressor protein binds to the operator. The operator sits between the promoter and the genes, so the bound repressor blocks RNA polymerase from moving along the DNA and transcribing the genes. This keeps the cell from wasting energy making enzymes for a sugar that isn't there.

b) Some of the lactose that enters the cell is changed into allolactose. Allolactose binds to the repressor and changes its shape, so the repressor can no longer hold onto the operator and falls off. Now RNA polymerase can move from the promoter through the operator and transcribe the three genes into one mRNA, which is translated into β-galactosidase and the other proteins.

c) The mutant strain will make a lot of β-galactosidase even with no lactose, much more than the normal strain, which makes almost none.

d) In the mutant the repressor is still made and still works, but it can't attach to the changed operator sequence. Since nothing is blocking the DNA, RNA polymerase transcribes the operon all the time, whether lactose is there or not. The normal strain's repressor stays bound when lactose is absent, so its genes stay off.

How it scored

1/1a — Earned: States that the repressor binds the operator and explains how that blocks RNA polymerase, which is the mechanism and not just the label 'turns the genes off'.
1/1b — Earned: Follows the causal chain in order: allolactose binds the repressor, the repressor changes shape and releases the operator, and RNA polymerase can then transcribe.
1/1c — Earned: A clear comparison: the mutant makes much more enzyme than the normal strain when lactose is absent.
1/1d — Earned: Places the defect in the operator, not the repressor, and explains that a working repressor with no binding site cannot block transcription. It also contrasts this with the normal strain.
Switching On the Genes for Lactose Use (Conceptual Analysis) · mid-scoring response2/4

a) The repressor binds to the operator and blocks RNA polymerase, so the genes for using lactose are not transcribed when there is no lactose.

b) When lactose is added, the lactose binds to the operator instead of the repressor. Since the lactose is taking up the spot, the repressor can't bind there anymore, so the genes get turned on and the cell makes the enzyme to break down lactose.

c) The mutant will make more β-galactosidase than the normal strain.

d) The mutation means the cell can't make the repressor protein anymore. With no repressor, there is nothing to stop RNA polymerase, so the genes are always on and the enzyme is always made.

How it scored

1/1a — Earned: Says the repressor binds the operator and blocks RNA polymerase, which gives both the role and how it works.
0/1b — Not earned: The inducer (allolactose) binds the repressor protein and changes its shape. It does not bind the operator DNA or compete for the repressor's spot. The causal step that earns the point is missing.
1/1c — Earned: Commits to a direction: more enzyme than the normal strain with no lactose present.
0/1d — Not earned: The stem says the lacI gene and the repressor are normal and the change is in the operator. Blaming a missing repressor justifies the right prediction with the wrong mutation, so the reasoning does not fit the disruption that was described.
A Signaling Pathway That Releases Glucose (Model or Visual Representation) · high-scoring response4/4

a) cAMP is a second messenger. Epinephrine binds the receptor on the outside of the cell and does not enter it. Adenylyl cyclase makes cAMP from ATP inside the cell. cAMP then moves through the cytoplasm and binds PKA, which switches PKA on. So cAMP carries the signal from the membrane to the enzymes inside the cell.

b) The signal is amplified at each step. One active adenylyl cyclase makes many cAMP molecules. Each active PKA phosphorylates many phosphorylase kinase molecules, and each of those activates many glycogen phosphorylase molecules. Each glycogen phosphorylase then breaks off many glucose units. The number of active molecules multiplies at every step, so one hormone molecule leads to thousands of glucose molecules.

c) Glucose release will keep going after epinephrine is removed instead of dropping back down.

d) Normally the G protein turns itself off by hydrolyzing GTP to GDP. Then adenylyl cyclase stops, phosphodiesterase breaks down the cAMP, and PKA goes inactive. The mutant G protein stays bound to GTP, so it stays active even with no hormone on the receptor. It keeps activating adenylyl cyclase, so cAMP keeps being made faster than phosphodiesterase can remove it. PKA stays on, and the cell keeps breaking down glycogen and releasing glucose.

How it scored

1/1a — Earned: Identifies cAMP as a second messenger and says what it does in this model: it is made inside the cell and activates PKA, relaying the signal from the membrane.
1/1b — Earned: Uses the relationship between the steps in the diagram: each enzyme activates many copies of the next, so the signal multiplies. That is amplification, stated with the model's own parts.
1/1c — Earned: A clear directional prediction: release stays high after the hormone is gone.
1/1d — Earned: Names the normal off switch (GTP hydrolysis), explains that the mutant G protein stays active without the hormone, and follows the effect down the pathway through cAMP and PKA to glycogen breakdown.
A Signaling Pathway That Releases Glucose (Model or Visual Representation) · mid-scoring response2/4

a) cAMP is a second messenger. It is made by adenylyl cyclase and it turns on protein kinase A, which passes the signal on to the next enzymes.

b) The signal gets bigger as it goes through the pathway because there are a lot of steps. Each step makes the signal stronger, so at the end there is a big response and a lot of glucose.

c) The liver cell will keep releasing glucose even after the epinephrine is gone.

d) The G protein can't break down GTP, so the receptor stays in its active shape and keeps holding onto epinephrine. Because the receptor never lets go, it keeps sending the signal to adenylyl cyclase and the cell keeps breaking down glycogen.

How it scored

1/1a — Earned: Names cAMP as a second messenger and gives its job in this model: made by adenylyl cyclase, it activates PKA and relays the signal.
0/1b — Not earned: Amplification comes from each activated enzyme acting on many copies of the next molecule, not from the number of steps alone. The response never states that one-to-many relationship, so it does not use the model.
1/1c — Earned: A clear prediction that glucose release continues after the hormone is removed.
0/1d — Not earned: The mutation is in the G protein, and the stem says epinephrine has been removed, so the receptor is not still holding hormone. The point needs the G protein staying in its active GTP-bound form and continuing to switch on adenylyl cyclase.
Shell Color and Bird Predation on Two Islands (Data Analysis) · high-scoring response4/4

a) Thrushes take more of the snails that don't match the background. On dark Island A, 62% of pale snails were taken but only 18% of dark snails. On pale Island B it flips: 57% of dark snails were taken but only 15% of pale snails.

b) Pale snails are dd, so q² = 1 - 0.11 = 0.89. q = √0.89 = 0.943 p = 1 - 0.943 = 0.057 The frequency of D on Island B is about 0.06.

c) The data support the hypothesis. On both islands, the snail that contrasts with the ground was taken about 3 to 4 times as often (62% vs 18% on A, 57% vs 15% on B). Since thrushes hunt by sight, this matches predators removing snails that don't blend in. It only shows one 48-hour trial, but the pattern reverses exactly when the background reverses.

d) Shell color varies because the D and d alleles already exist in the population. On Island A, dark snails survive bird attacks more often, so more of them live to reproduce and pass on the D allele. Each generation the D allele makes up a bigger share of the gene pool, so dark shells become common (0.84). On Island B the pale dd snails survive and reproduce more, so the d allele increases and dark shells stay rare (0.11). The birds don't change any snail's color. They just change which snails reproduce.

How it scored

1/1a — Earned: States the pattern, that mismatched snails are taken more, and supports it with values from both islands.
1/1b — Earned: Correctly starts from the recessive phenotype (q² = 0.89), takes the square root, and subtracts from 1. Final value of about 0.06 with work shown. Notice that a real population under the selection shown in Table 1 would not be in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. The prompt states the assumption only to make the math possible, so you accept it for this part instead of arguing with it, and you can still discuss selection in part (d).
1/1c — Earned: Commits to 'support' and uses the comparison that actually tests the hypothesis: the reversal of predation when the background reverses, with numbers.
1/1d — Earned: Links differential survival to differential reproduction, then to a change in allele frequency over generations. It also makes clear that the variation existed before selection.
Shell Color and Bird Predation on Two Islands (Data Analysis) · mid-scoring response1/4

a) On Island A the birds ate more pale snails (62%) than dark snails (18%). On Island B the birds ate more dark snails (57%) than pale ones (15%).

b) Dark = 0.11, so p² = 0.11 p = √0.11 = 0.33 The frequency of D is 0.33.

c) Yes, the data support the hypothesis because the birds ate a lot more of the snails that were easy to see against the ground on each island.

d) Over many generations the snails on Island A became darker so the birds couldn't see them. The snails that needed to blend in developed mutations for darker shells, and they passed these on to their babies, so now most of them are dark.

How it scored

1/1a — Earned: Describes the difference on both islands with correct values.
0/1b — Not earned: 0.11 is the frequency of all dark-shelled snails, both DD and Dd, so it is p² + 2pq, not p². The calculation must start from the pale (dd) snails, q² = 0.89.
0/1c — Not earned: It commits to 'support', but it never cites a value from Table 1. An evaluation on a Data question must use specific numbers, such as 62% vs 18% on Island A, to show the claim holds.
0/1d — Not earned: Describes mutations arising because the snails 'needed' them. Mutations are random with respect to what an organism needs. Predation only changes which variants survive and reproduce. A directed-mutation explanation cannot earn the point.

Where points die

Writing that organisms mutate because they need to, as in 'the bacteria became resistant to survive the antibiotic' or 'the snails developed darker shells to hide'. Mutations are random with respect to what the organism needs. The antibiotic or the predator does not decide which variants arise. A useful variant may have existed before the pressure or may appear during it. Either way, selection only changes which variants survive and reproduce. Write it as differential survival, then differential reproduction, then a change in allele frequency across generations. Any hint of directed mutation costs the explanation point.

Saying an enzyme adds energy to a reaction or raises the energy of the reactants. An enzyme lowers activation energy by binding substrate in its active site and stabilizing the transition state. On an energy diagram only the peak drops. The reactants, the products, and ΔG stay where they were. The reaction reaches the same endpoint, just faster.

Mixing up the Hardy-Weinberg terms, such as setting the dominant phenotype equal to p², or treating 2pq as an allele frequency. p and q are allele frequencies. p² is homozygous dominant, 2pq is heterozygous, and q² is homozygous recessive. The dominant phenotype is p² + 2pq, so you cannot take its square root. Always start from the recessive phenotype: it equals q². Take the square root to get q, then p = 1 - q.

Offering evidence that does not test the hypothesis being evaluated. Examples: a link between shell color and rainfall, proof that the color is inherited, or a phylogeny of the populations, used to support a camouflage hypothesis. Evidence for a selection hypothesis must show that the trait changes survival or reproduction under the proposed agent. A climate correlation points to a different cause, such as heat balance. Inheritance shows the trait can be passed on, not that it helps. A phylogeny shows relatedness, not advantage. Pick the data that compare fitness across conditions.

Crediting natural selection for any change in allele frequency, even when the stem says a small group founded a population and an allele became common 'by chance'. Chance changes in small populations are genetic drift. The founder effect is drift that happens when a few individuals start a new population. Selection needs a trait that affects fitness. If the stem gives no fitness difference and stresses chance or small numbers, name drift. Gene flow is the movement of alleles between populations, carried by migrating individuals or by their gametes, such as pollen, and a fully isolated population receives none.

Answering 'justify' or 'explain' with a restated prediction, or answering 'identify' with a vague phrase like 'keep everything the same'. Each part pays for exactly what its verb asks. A justification must name the mechanism, such as heat breaking the weak bonds that hold the active site's shape. An identification must name one specific item, such as substrate concentration or pH. Read the verb before you write.

Score your own response

0 / 4

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.