Skip to content
AP Biology · Cell Structure and Function

Evidence

Evidence appears in 5 reviewed AP Biology questions and sits in Cell Structure and Function. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

In AP Biology, evidence is data from an observation or experiment that supports or refutes a specific claim. The strongest evidence tests the proposed cause directly, so it shows that changing one variable changes the outcome.

Why it matters

Science Practice questions ask you to judge claims, not just recall facts. You earn those points by telling apart data that only shows a pattern from data that shows a cause.

How the exam tests it

A stem gives a hypothesis, such as snail shell color hiding snails from birds, and asks which evidence would support it most strongly. The answer is usually a manipulative experiment that measures the proposed mechanism, like birds eating more snails that do not match their background.

Don’t confuse it with

Students mix up correlation with causal evidence: noting that dark snails live on dark islands only restates the pattern, while a predation test checks why the pattern exists.

Evidence in real questions

Example 1Medium
A biologist studying a population of land snails on a series of islands finds that snails on islands with dense vegetation have darker shells, while snails on islands with sparse, light-colored vegetation have lighter shells. The biologist hypothesizes that shell color provides camouflage from bird predators. Which of the following types of evidence would most strongly support this hypothesis?
  1. AA survey showing that shell color varies with average temperature and rainfall across all islands
  2. BGenetic crosses confirming that shell color is inherited as a single gene with dark dominant to light
  3. CA molecular phylogeny showing that the dark-shelled and light-shelled populations are closely related
  4. DA predation experiment showing that birds preferentially eat snails whose shells do not match their backgroundCorrect

Why D is right

The hypothesis proposes that shell color camouflage reduces predation by birds. The strongest evidence would be a predation experiment that directly tests whether birds preferentially eat snails whose shells do not match their background. That would establish a causal link between coloration, predation, and fitness.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because a correlation with climate (temperature and rainfall) would point to another explanation, such as thermoregulation, and would not support the camouflage hypothesis.
B
Incorrect because knowing how shell color is inherited does not show that the color gives a selective advantage through camouflage.
C
Incorrect because a phylogeny shows how the populations are related but does not explain why shell color differs between islands or show a selective advantage.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Cell Structure and Function.