A researcher compares two proteins: Protein A has a high proportion of hydrophobic amino acid residues on its surface, while Protein B has predominantly hydrophilic residues on its surface. In an aqueous cellular environment, which protein is more likely to be a transmembrane protein, and what logic supports this prediction?
- AProtein B, because the phosphate heads of the bilayer are hydrophilic and attract proteins with hydrophilic surfaces
- BProtein A, because hydrophobic amino acids on its surface are compatible with the nonpolar interior of the lipid bilayerCorrect
- CProtein A, because hydrophobic proteins are repelled by water and accumulate in membranes regardless of function
- DProtein B, because hydrophilic surfaces interact favorably with the aqueous cytoplasm on both sides of the membrane
Why B is right
Transmembrane proteins must span the hydrophobic core of the lipid bilayer (made of fatty acid tails). Segments that pass through the membrane are rich in hydrophobic amino acids, which are thermodynamically stable in the nonpolar membrane interior. Hydrophilic regions of transmembrane proteins are typically found in loops exposed to the aqueous environments on each side of the membrane.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The phospholipid heads being hydrophilic would attract hydrophilic proteins to the surface, not through the bilayer; this describes peripheral protein association, not transmembrane.
- C
- While hydrophobic proteins do associate with membranes, the reasoning that they 'accumulate regardless of function' is incorrect; membrane insertion is a regulated, targeted process.
- D
- Hydrophilic surface proteins are more likely to be peripheral membrane proteins or soluble cytoplasmic proteins, not transmembrane proteins that must traverse the hydrophobic core.
The plasma membrane creates a selective permeability barrier. Rank the following molecules from most to least permeable across an unmodified phospholipid bilayer (no transport proteins):
- AWater > Na+ > CO2 > glucose
- BGlucose > CO2 > Na+ > water
- CCO2 > water > glucose > Na+Correct
- DNa+ > water > CO2 > glucose
Why C is right
Membrane permeability to a substance depends primarily on its size and polarity/charge. Small nonpolar molecules cross most easily: CO2 is small and nonpolar (highly permeable). Small polar molecules cross slowly: water is small but polar (crosses slowly without aquaporins). Larger polar molecules cross very poorly: glucose is larger and polar (requires transporter). Ions essentially cannot cross: Na+ carries a formal charge (+1) and its hydration shell makes it thermodynamically unfavorable to cross the nonpolar bilayer core (extremely low permeability).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- While water is more permeable than glucose and Na+, it is less permeable than CO2 (nonpolar gas); ranking water above CO2 is incorrect.
- B
- Glucose is less permeable than CO2 or water because it is larger and more polar; Na+ as an ion is less permeable than water; this ranking places glucose above CO2 and Na+ above water, which is incorrect.
- D
- Ions (Na+) are among the least permeable molecules across lipid bilayers; placing Na+ as the most permeable contradicts the basic principle that charged species cannot readily cross the hydrophobic bilayer core.