Which of the following molecules has a bond angle closest to 107∘?
- ABFX3
- BHX2O
- CCHX4
- DNHX3Correct
Why D is right
Ammonia (NHX3) has one lone pair on nitrogen and three bonding pairs — four total electron groups. The lone pair compresses the H−N−H bond angle from the ideal tetrahedral 109.5∘ to approximately 107∘. HX2O has two lone pairs, compressing its angle to ∼104.5∘. CHX4 (ideal 109.5∘) and BFX3 (trigonal planar, 120∘) have different angles.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. BFX3 has trigonal planar geometry with three bonding pairs and no lone pairs on boron, giving bond angles of exactly 120∘.
- B
- Incorrect. HX2O has two lone pairs on oxygen, compressing the H−O−H bond angle to approximately 104.5∘, not 107∘.
- C
- Incorrect. CHX4 has no lone pairs on carbon; all four electron groups are bonding, giving the ideal tetrahedral angle of 109.5∘.
In the molecule HX2S, the H-S-H bond angle is approximately 92∘, much smaller than the 104.5∘ in HX2O. What is the best explanation for this smaller angle?
- ASulfur bonds with nearly pure 3p orbitals, which lie at about 90∘ to each other.Correct
- BThe S−H bond is less polar than O−H, causing greater bond pair-bond pair repulsion.
- CHX2S has three lone pairs on sulfur, which compress the bond angle more than HX2O's two lone pairs.
- DSulfur is larger than oxygen, so its bonding orbitals spread farther apart around the central atom.
Why A is right
Oxygen in HX2O uses sp3 hybrid orbitals (∼109.5∘ ideal, reduced to 104.5∘ by lone pairs). Sulfur, being larger and in Period 3, uses nearly pure 3p orbitals for bonding with less s-character. The mutual repulsion between p orbital lobes is minimized at 90∘, giving HX2S a bond angle close to 90∘ rather than 104.5∘.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. Bond polarity (electronegativity difference) affects lone pair repulsion, not directly the bond pair-bond pair repulsion; the bond angle in HX2S is smaller due to orbital type (p vs. sp3), not polarity.
- C
- Incorrect. HX2S has two lone pairs on sulfur (just like HX2O has two lone pairs on oxygen), not three; the bond angle difference is due to hybridization differences between the two molecules.
- D
- Incorrect. Larger size by itself does not cause smaller bond angles; the key is the orbital hybridization and p-orbital geometry.
Which of the following best explains why lone pair-lone pair (LP-LP) repulsion is greater than lone pair-bond pair (LP-BP) repulsion, which in turn is greater than bond pair-bond pair (BP-BP) repulsion?
- ALone pairs contain more electrons than bonding pairs, creating greater charge density.
- BBonding pairs repel less because they are shared between two atoms, reducing their effective charge.
- CLone pairs repel more because they occupy lower-energy orbitals that lie closer to the central nucleus.
- DLone pairs are held by only one nucleus and spread over more angular space than bonding pairs.Correct
Why D is right
Lone pairs are attracted only to the central atom, so their electron density is more diffuse and occupies greater angular space. Bond pairs are attracted to two nuclei and are more compact and 'pinched' between the bonded atoms. The greater spatial extent of lone pairs creates stronger repulsion with adjacent electron groups, compressing bond angles.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Both lone pairs and bonding pairs consist of exactly two electrons; lone pairs do not contain more electrons.
- B
- Incorrect. While bonding pairs are shared between two atoms (which does constrain them), calling this a 'reduced effective charge' is misleading; the correct explanation relates to the spatial distribution of electron density.
- C
- Incorrect. Lone pairs are in the outermost shell and are not lower in energy or closer to the nucleus than bonding electrons in the same shell; the key is the angular space they occupy.