Carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) has four polar C-Cl bonds, yet the molecule is nonpolar overall. Which concept best explains this observation?
- AThe tetrahedral symmetry of CCl4 causes the bond dipoles to cancel, resulting in zero net dipole moment.Correct
- BThe large size of chlorine atoms distorts the electron cloud symmetrically, eliminating the net dipole.
- CLone pairs on chlorine atoms generate dipole moments that exactly cancel the C-Cl bond dipoles.
- DThe C-Cl bonds are actually nonpolar because carbon and chlorine have similar electronegativities.
Why A is right
Each C-Cl bond is polar because chlorine (EN = 3.16) is more electronegative than carbon (EN = 2.55), creating individual bond dipoles pointing toward Cl. However, CCl4 is tetrahedral and perfectly symmetric. The four bond dipole vectors point in equivalent directions separated by 109.5°, so they cancel by vector addition to give a net dipole moment of zero. This distinguishes bond polarity (a bond property) from molecular polarity (a geometry-dependent property).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Atomic size does not redistribute dipoles in a way that eliminates polarity. The key factor is vectorial cancellation due to tetrahedral symmetry.
- C
- Lone pairs on chlorine do contribute to local electron density but are already accounted for in the bond dipole vectors. They do not separately cancel the bond dipoles.
- D
- Carbon and chlorine have a significant electronegativity difference (~0.61), so C-Cl bonds are genuinely polar. The nonpolarity of CCl4 is due to geometry, not bond nonpolarity.