Which of the following correctly explains why Cr (chromium) has the electron configuration [Ar] 3d5 4s1 rather than the expected [Ar] 3d4 4s2?
- AChromium loses one 4s electron to the 3d subshell because 3d orbitals are larger and can accommodate more electrons.
- BThe nuclear charge of chromium is too high for the 4s2 configuration to be stable at the 3d4 level.
- CA half-filled 3d subshell (3d5) with one 4s electron provides extra stability due to exchange energy from having 6 electrons with parallel spins.Correct
- DThe 4s orbital is at higher energy than 3d in transition metals, so electrons prefer the 3d subshell.
Why C is right
The [Ar] 3d5 4s1 configuration places one electron in each of the five 3d orbitals plus one in 4s. The half-filled 3d5 configuration has maximum exchange energy because all 6 electrons (5 in 3d + 1 in 4s) have parallel spins (by Hund's rule). This symmetric half-filling provides exceptional stability that outweighs the expected pairing in 4s.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Orbital size does not determine electron configuration exceptions. The stability is due to exchange energy from the half-filled subshell symmetry, not orbital size.
- B
- Nuclear charge does not specifically destabilize 3d4 4s2. Many elements maintain similar configurations. The exception is specific to the special stability of half-filled d subshells.
- D
- While 3d and 4s energies are close, this explanation oversimplifies and applies incorrectly. The key is the special stability of the half-filled 3d5 configuration, not just an energy ordering argument.