Which of the following molecules violates the octet rule by having an expanded octet on the central atom?
- APCl5Correct
- BNH3
- CCO2
- DBCl3
Why A is right
PCl5 has phosphorus as the central atom bonded to 5 chlorine atoms. This requires 10 electrons around phosphorus, which exceeds the octet (8 electrons). Phosphorus can accommodate an expanded octet because it has accessible 3d orbitals. Elements in Period 3 and below can form expanded octets.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. NH3 has nitrogen with 3 bonds and 1 lone pair (8 electrons total), satisfying the octet rule.
- C
- Incorrect. CO2 has carbon with 4 bonds (two double bonds) and 8 electrons around it, satisfying the octet rule.
- D
- Incorrect. BCl3 violates the octet rule but by having an incomplete octet (only 6 electrons around boron), not an expanded octet.