Skip to content

AP English Language and Composition · technique

How to write the rhetorical analysis essay

On this page · 5 sections

Question 2 hands you one piece of nonfiction, usually a speech, a public letter, or an argumentative essay, plus a headnote naming who wrote it, for whom, when, and why. You explain how the writer's choices work on that audience. You do not summarize the content, and you do not argue about whether the writer is right. You are writing about strategy.

The score is six points across three rows. Row A, the thesis, is one point: a defensible claim about rhetorical choices, not a restatement of the passage's topic. Row B, evidence and commentary, is worth zero to four and decides most essays. Zero means you only restate your thesis, repeat information from the passage, or point at things that have nothing to do with your claim. One point means your evidence is mostly general rather than specific, and you summarize that evidence instead of explaining how it supports your argument. Two means you have specific evidence and you connect it to your thesis, but your paragraphs do not build on each other. Three means your claims form a line of reasoning and you explain how some evidence supports it. Four means you explain consistently, and you show how multiple choices serve the writer's argument, purpose, or message. Row C, sophistication, is one point, awarded sparingly for a genuinely complex handling of the rhetorical situation or its tensions.

Section II runs two hours fifteen minutes total: a fifteen-minute reading period, then two hours of writing for all three essays. Two hours is 120 minutes, and 120 divided by three is the forty minutes College Board suggests for each free-response question. That forty is where the clock plan in step seven comes from. All three essays weigh the same and Section II is 55 percent of your exam score, so this one essay is roughly 18 percent of the total. A reader scores it in a few minutes against that rubric and nothing else. Notice that the prompt prints the rubric in plain language. It tells you to write a thesis that analyzes the writer's rhetorical choices, to select evidence supporting your line of reasoning, to explain how that evidence supports the reasoning, to demonstrate an understanding of the rhetorical situation, and to use appropriate grammar and punctuation. That is a free reminder on the page, and the rhetorical situation line is the one students skip.

The steps

  1. 1

    Strip the headnote before you read the passage

    The headnote is two or three sentences and it hands you the rhetorical situation: the writer, the audience, the occasion, and the exigence, meaning the pressure or event that made writing necessary right then. Those are the course's own terms, and the prompt tells you to demonstrate an understanding of the rhetorical situation, so think in them. Convert them into one purpose statement built on a verb: to push already-sympathetic donors from feeling bad to acting. Not "to persuade the reader," which describes every text ever written. Name the audience specifically, because a general is talking to soldiers who may die, a governor is talking to legislators who can vote against her, and those two situations reward opposite moves. Everything you write later gets tested against this sentence. If a paragraph does not connect a choice to this purpose and this audience, it is not earning Row B.

  2. 2

    Read once with a pen, marking turns rather than devices

    Almost every Question 2 passage moves through two to four movements. A writer will open warm and turn cold, or open with a story and turn to policy, or concede for a paragraph and then attack. Bracket those blocks in the margin and label each with a verb: praises, concedes, indicts, redefines, offers a way out. That skeleton is your line of reasoning, and a line of reasoning is what separates a Row B score of two from a three. Hunting for metaphors gives you a pile of unrelated observations instead. Also watch pronouns and addressee, since a shift from "we" to "you" is usually the hinge of the whole passage.

  3. 3

    Write a thesis that names the arc, not a list

    A workable shape: the writer does X early in order to make Y possible later, so that this audience will Z. Example shape: she spends the opening establishing shared grievance, then reframes the dispute as a legal question, so that lawmakers can back her without appearing to switch sides. Test it two ways. Would this sentence be false if applied to a different passage? If not, it is not defensible and Row A gives nothing. Does it name what the writer wants from these listeners? If not, add it. Skip the elaborate introduction. Get to this sentence by your third line and start the first body paragraph.

  4. 4

    Build each body paragraph as claim, evidence, commentary, purpose

    Aim for three body paragraphs, one per movement, in passage order because that shows the argument developing. Open with a claim about a choice: what the writer does and why there. Then quote in fragments, three to eight words, embedded in your own sentence. Long block quotations eat your time and buy no credit, and readers score commentary, not quotation. Then two to four sentences of analysis. Then one sentence tying the effect back to the purpose you named in step one. Keep a rough ratio of one line of quoting to four lines of your own writing.

  5. 5

    Push commentary through two steps of "so what"

    Step one is effect: what does this choice make the audience feel, concede, or picture? Step two is stakes: why does that specific effect matter given the occasion? Saying that a rhetorical question "engages the reader" is a dead end because it is true of every rhetorical question. Saying that the question forces listeners who consider themselves allies to answer for their own silence is analysis, because it depends on who is in the room. Naming a device is worth zero by itself. Anaphora, antithesis, and juxtaposition are labels for a move, and Row B pays for the move's function. If you can delete the device name and your sentence still explains the effect, you are writing real commentary.

  6. 6

    Spend two deliberate sentences buying sophistication

    The point rewards complexity, and there are three reliable routes. First, situate a choice in the constraints of the rhetorical situation: this writer had to attack her own audience without losing them, so the concession in the middle is not politeness but insurance. Second, explain a tension the passage holds open, such as praising a country while indicting it, or urging patience and urgency together. Third, sustain a consistently controlled style of your own, which is the least reliable route under time. Write your sophistication sentence into the final body paragraph or the last two lines. Do not save it for a conclusion you may never reach.

  7. 7

    Run the clock deliberately

    Forty minutes per essay: eight to read the headnote, annotate movements, and write the thesis; twenty-eight to draft; four to reread. Question 2 sits second in the booklet, but you may answer the three questions in any order, so long as you protect the forty minutes each. Never leave an essay unstarted to polish another, because the first two Row B points are the cheapest points on the exam. Write no conclusion beyond a single sentence naming the purpose again. It costs ten seconds and reads as finished. During the reread, fix only what a reader would trip on: a missing quotation mark, a sentence that lost its verb, a paragraph with evidence and no commentary.

Worked through

Take a passage of the type that appears constantly, a public speech with a hostile point to make to a friendly crowd. Frederick Douglass, invited by the Rochester Ladies' Anti-Slavery Society, spoke at Corinthian Hall on July 5, 1852, at an Independence Day observance. Everything below paraphrases that public-domain speech in my own words. Treat these movements as a map of what Douglass does, not as text you could reproduce from memory on the exam.

Situation, from the headnote: the audience is white, northern, and already anti-slavery, and they invited him. The exigence is the holiday itself, which treats the founding as finished business. Purpose: to strip these sympathetic listeners of the comfort of celebration and convert their sympathy into obligation.

Movements, marked on one read. He opens with long, genuine praise for the founders and their principles. He hinges on a pronoun, telling the audience that this Fourth of July belongs to them and not to him. He turns to a run of questions, including what the day means to the enslaved. He closes by reading the nation's founding documents as arguments against slavery.

Thesis: Douglass praises the founders warmly enough that his listeners accept him as a fellow patriot, then splits the shared we of the holiday into a yours and a mine. The celebration becomes an interrogation, and an audience expecting a compliment must answer for what it has tolerated.

One body paragraph, on the hinge: the pronoun split does the heavy work. Douglass has spent pages inside his audience's story, and when he separates their holiday from his own position, he removes himself from a national identity his listeners assumed he wanted. That is more damaging than accusation. An accusation invites a defense, but a withdrawal leaves the audience holding a holiday that has quietly stopped including someone standing in front of them. Because they are abolitionists, they cannot answer that the exclusion is fine. The only available response is discomfort, which is exactly the state Douglass needs before he asks anything of them.

Sophistication sentence: the risk in this speech is that Douglass is attacking his own funders, and the early praise plus the closing appeal to the founding documents keeps the indictment survivable, shaming the audience without releasing it from the cause.

That is a full Row B argument built from four annotations. The evidence is short, the commentary is long, and every paragraph answers to the purpose sentence.

Common mistakes

  • Listing devices instead of explaining them. A paragraph that identifies anaphora, then metaphor, then a rhetorical question, and stops at identification, is a scavenger hunt. Row B pays for what a choice does to that audience, so the device name is optional and the effect is not.

  • Retelling the passage in order and calling it analysis. If your sentences could be replaced by "then he says," you are summarizing. That caps Row B at one or two points no matter how clean the writing is.

  • Using ethos, pathos, and logos as the essay's structure. Three paragraphs, one appeal each, produces claims that sit side by side instead of building. Those terms name the mode of an appeal, not its function, and an essay organized around them usually has no line of reasoning.

  • A thesis that would fit any passage. "The author uses many rhetorical devices to persuade the audience" is a description of writing itself, not a defensible claim. It scores zero on Row A and leaves the body paragraphs with nothing to prove.

  • Arguing with the writer. Agreeing, disagreeing, or explaining your own views on the topic is off task, and so is judging whether the argument is effective without analyzing how it works.

  • Ignoring the headnote and quoting too much. Audience, occasion, and exigence are printed for you, and most sophistication points live there. Long quotations burn minutes and add nothing, since readers score your explanation rather than the passage's words.

Checklist

  • Can you state the writer's purpose in one verb phrase that names the specific audience?
  • Can you name the exigence, the pressure or event that made this text necessary right then?
  • Can you mark two to four places where the passage turns and say what changes at each?
  • Would your thesis be false if applied to a different passage?
  • Does every body paragraph open with a claim about a choice rather than a device name or a plot point?
  • Is every quotation under about eight words and folded into your own sentence?
  • For each piece of evidence, have you written at least two sentences on its effect on this audience and why that effect serves the purpose?
  • Have you written one sentence naming a constraint, risk, or tension the writer had to manage?
  • Can you finish in forty minutes with four left over to reread?

More AP English Language and Composition technique