On this page · 5 sections
Free-response Question 1 hands you a short prompt and then six sources — occasionally seven — on one debatable public question. At least one is visual or quantitative: a bar graph, a political cartoon, a photograph, an advertisement. The task line asks you to develop your own position and support it with material from at least three of the sources. Section II runs 2 hours 15 minutes, which includes a 15-minute reading period at the start, and the suggested split is 40 minutes per essay. Section II is 55% of your exam score; the 45-question multiple-choice section is the other 45%.
Scoring is a six-point analytic rubric, the same three rows used on all three essays. Row A, thesis, is worth 1 point for a defensible position that actually answers the prompt. Row B, evidence and commentary, is worth 0–4, and the ladder is close to mechanical. Referencing fewer than two sources earns 0. Referencing two sources and summarizing what they say earns 1. Evidence from or references to at least three sources, still summarized, earns 2. The 3 requires two things at once: specific evidence from at least three sources supporting all claims in a line of reasoning, plus explanation of how some of that evidence supports the reasoning. The 4 keeps that same evidence requirement and upgrades the commentary — you explain consistently across the whole response, not in one strong paragraph. Row C, sophistication, is a single point given sparingly for real complexity. Nothing is scored for length, for handwriting, or for having five paragraphs. Readers move fast — assume a couple of minutes with your essay — so what you want credit for has to be visible fast.
The steps
- 1
Read the task line before you read a single source
The 15-minute reading period covers all three prompts, but the synthesis packet is the one worth spending it on. Find the sentence that states the task and turn it into a question you can answer yes, no, or 'only if.' Write that question in the margin. Then read the sources in packet order and, after each one, write no more than eight words: what it claims, and what you could use it to prove. Annotate for use, not for meaning. This is not a reading-comprehension test, and you get nothing for understanding a source you never deploy. Read the visual early — a graph gives you a hard number in fifteen seconds, and hard numbers are the easiest specific evidence in the packet. Leave the reading period with a position, three sources tagged to support it, and one source tagged as the strongest objection to it. Budget about eight of the fifteen minutes here.
- 2
Write a thesis that someone could argue against
Row A is binary and it is lost in predictable ways. A sentence that reports the existence of a debate earns nothing. A sentence that restates the prompt in new words earns nothing. Neither does a balanced summary that lists what each side believes and never lands. What earns the point is a defensible position: a claim a reasonable, informed person could dispute. The most useful shape carries a condition or a cause — 'X is worth doing only when Y,' or 'X fails because Z.' A qualified thesis is not a hedge; the qualification is what makes it arguable, and it hands you your paragraph order for free. Keep it to one or two sentences and put it at the end of a three-sentence introduction. Your reader is moving fast and needs to know what to score you against before the first body paragraph.
- 3
Build a line of reasoning, then assign sources to it
The single most common structure on this essay is one paragraph per source, in the order the packet printed them. The rubric caps nothing on structure — a source-ordered essay that ties each source to a claim and explains how it supports the reasoning can still reach 3 or 4. But that layout almost always turns into a report of each source in turn, and a response that summarizes instead of explaining stalls at Row B 2. So invert it. Write your two to four claims first, on scratch paper, in an order where each claim makes the next one necessary. Then assign sources to claims. A source can appear in two paragraphs. A paragraph can use two sources. A source you tagged during reading but cannot attach to a claim gets cut, and cutting it costs you nothing as long as three remain. Test the order by reading only your claim sentences aloud in your head: if they still form an argument with the evidence stripped out, you have a line of reasoning. If they read as a list of topics, reorder before you start writing.
- 4
Cite so a reader can count in one pass
Readers count distinct sources, and the count sets your Row B ceiling. Fewer than two sources scores 0. Exactly two caps you at 1. Three is the threshold for everything above that. Two conventions both work: a parenthetical tag, as in (Source C), or attribution inside the sentence, as in 'the teacher survey in Source E.' Pick one and stay consistent so nothing gets missed. Quoting is not required — accurate paraphrase counts fully as evidence, and paraphrase is faster to write and easier to comment on. A source you name without using is a weaker case. A sentence like 'Source F also discusses this issue' does count toward the three-source threshold, so it can help you reach a 2, but it supplies no evidence — and 3 and 4 require specific evidence from at least three sources behind every claim. Bare mentions cost you the top half of the row. For the visual or quantitative source, cite the specific thing it shows: a value, a gap between two bars, a detail in the image. 'The graph shows a trend' is not evidence.
- 5
Make commentary explain the mechanism, not repeat the evidence
Two things separate Row B 2 from Row B 4, and only one of them is commentary. The first is evidence. At 2 you may still be referencing three sources loosely; at 3 and 4 every claim in your line of reasoning has to carry specific evidence, and at least three sources have to supply it. A claim with nothing attached holds you at 2 no matter how much explaining follows. The second is commentary, and that is the only difference between 3 and 4: at 3 you explain how some of your evidence supports the reasoning, at 4 you do it consistently, all the way through. So after every piece of evidence, answer one question in writing: how does this prove my claim? Not what it says — how it works. If your sentence after the evidence would still be true with the claim deleted, it is summary. Watch the phrase 'this shows that,' which nine times out of ten is followed by a paraphrase of the sentence before it. Aim for roughly one sentence of evidence to two of commentary. One brilliantly analyzed paragraph followed by two paragraphs of quotation does not reach 4.
- 6
Go after the sophistication point on purpose
Row C is one point and it is refused far more often than it is given. Readers award it for a small set of real moves. You can name a genuine tension between two sources and explore it instead of resolving it cheaply. You can state the limits or costs of your own position and explain why it holds anyway. You can situate the question in a broader context that changes what is at stake. A consistently vivid and persuasive style can also earn it, but individual impressive words cannot. What almost never works is a token 'some may argue' sentence dismissed in the next clause, or a conclusion that suddenly announces the topic matters to society. The safest insurance is structural: build the tension into the thesis in step two, and the complexity is already load-bearing rather than bolted on at the end.
- 7
Run the clock deliberately
Suggested time is 40 minutes of writing per essay after the reading period. Inside that, spend about five minutes converting your reading notes into claims, thirty writing, and five finishing. Do not draft an introduction longer than three sentences. Evidence and commentary are not earned there; the thesis is. Do not write a long conclusion — a two-sentence close that names what your position costs or implies is worth more than a summary of your own paragraphs. If you are running out of time, do not start a new body paragraph. Finish the one you are in, then add two sentences of thesis-level thinking about the limits of your argument. That protects Row C and keeps Row B commentary consistent, which is what the rubric rewards. An essay with three fully explained paragraphs beats an essay with five that trail off.
Worked through
The prompt and sources below were written for this guide. They are not a released College Board prompt, and every number in them is invented.
Prompt: Hundreds of U.S. districts have shortened the school week to four days. Write an essay that synthesizes material from at least three of the sources and develops your position on whether districts should adopt a four-day school week.
Source A — a rural superintendent's memo claiming a 3% budget saving and fewer teacher vacancies after the switch. Source B — a research summary finding small math-score declines in switching districts, concentrated in elementary grades. Source C — a bar graph of off-day childcare spending as a share of household income, by income quartile. Source D — an op-ed by a parent who takes unpaid Fridays to stay home. Source E — a teacher survey in which a large majority report better planning time and lower burnout. Source F — an editorial arguing that school schedules are childcare policy whether districts admit it or not.
Reading-period notes, eight minutes, eight words or fewer each. A: 3% saving, fewer vacancies — claim 1. E: retention mechanism — claim 1. B: cost exists, small, uneven — claim 2, also my strongest objection. C: numbers, bottom quartile hit hardest — claim 3, the pivot. D: human version of C. F: gives me the reframe — Row C.
Thesis: A four-day week is defensible only where the district funds the fifth day, because the savings are real but they are collected from the families with the least slack.
Outline. Claim 1: the savings and staffing gains are real and specific (A, E). Claim 2: the academic cost is small, which is why the schedule survives scrutiny (B). Claim 3: the cost does not disappear, it moves onto households, and unevenly (C, D). Close: the choice is not four days against five, it is who pays for the fifth (F).
Here is the third paragraph written badly first. 'Source C shows a bar graph of childcare spending by income quartile. The lowest quartile spends much more than the highest. This shows that the four-day week affects low-income families. Source D agrees, since the parent takes unpaid Fridays.' Two sources appear, so the count is fine, but every sentence restates the packet. 'This shows that' is followed by a paraphrase rather than an explanation. A reader scores that as summary, and Row B stalls at 2.
Now the same paragraph doing the work. 'The graph in Source C puts a price on the fifth day: households in the bottom income quartile spend roughly four times the share of income on off-day care that the top quartile does. The ratio matters more than the dollars. A district that trims 3% from its budget (Source A) has not eliminated the cost of Friday. It has moved that cost off a public budget, where taxpayers spread it, onto private budgets, where it lands hardest on families with no slack to absorb it. Source D shows the transfer at ground level: a parent covering Friday with a day of lost wages is paying tuition to a school that is closed. The savings in Source A are therefore not savings for the community at all. They are a transfer, and the schedule is defensible only if the district spends part of that 3% buying the fifth day back.'
What that earns. Row A: 1, because the thesis takes a conditional position a reasonable person could reject. Row B: on track for 4, because three-plus sources appear, each claim carries specific evidence, and the commentary explains a mechanism — a cost moving from public to private budgets — instead of restating the sources. Row C: plausible, because the essay names the tension between A's real savings and C's real costs and resolves it by reframing the question along the line Source F suggests, rather than by picking a side and ignoring the other.
Common mistakes
Six paragraphs, one per source, in the order the packet printed them. The rubric does not score layout, but that layout drags the writing toward reporting each source in turn — and summary instead of explanation is what holds Row B at 2, however clean the prose is.
A thesis that describes the debate instead of joining it — 'there are many opinions on this issue,' or a balanced restatement of both sides. That scores 0 in Row A and leaves the body with no spine to organize itself around.
Naming a third source without using it: 'Source F also addresses this' adds a name and no evidence. The mention still counts toward the three-source threshold, so a 2 is reachable, but 3 and 4 need specific evidence from three sources behind every claim, and the essay cannot get there.
Skipping the visual or quantitative source because it feels harder to quote. It is normally the fastest specific evidence in the packet, and a named value or a gap between two bars is exactly the kind of detail that lifts commentary above summary.
Quote-dropping: a long quotation lands at the end of a paragraph and is left to argue on its own. Nothing is explained, so the evidence is scored as summarized rather than used.
Chasing Row C with vocabulary or with a token counterargument waved away in half a sentence. Sophistication comes from exploring a tension, naming the limits of your own position, or reframing the stakes — not from sounding formal.
Checklist
- Can you state your position in one sentence that an informed person could reasonably dispute?
- Can you point to at least three sources you actually used and say which claim each one supports?
- Can you check that every claim in your essay — not just your best one — has specific evidence attached to it?
- Can you find, in every body paragraph, a sentence that explains how the evidence proves the claim rather than repeating what the evidence said?
- Can you name the strongest objection to your thesis and show the exact place where your essay handles it?
- Can you cite every source so a reader counting quickly cannot miss one?
- Can you say what the visual source specifically shows — a number, a gap, an image detail — instead of its general topic?
- Can you finish the reading period in about eight minutes holding a thesis and a claim outline?
- Can you name which Row C move your essay is making: a tension explored, a limitation stated, or the stakes reframed?