Read the following passage.
Dr. Nkemdirim arrived at every faculty meeting twelve minutes early and sat in the same chair, third from the left, back row. He brought his own tea in a thermos. He never interrupted a colleague's argument, even when the argument was visibly wrong, which it often was. His patience had once been mistaken for agreement, then for weakness, then—by those who had been on committees with him long enough—for something more unsettling: a kind of perfect attention that missed nothing and conceded nothing. His reviews in journals were brief, almost surgical. He thanked reviewers in acknowledgments but never effusively. When a junior colleague, newly hired, submitted a manuscript she had not shared with him beforehand, he said only: 'The argument in section three will not hold.' She spent the weekend rewriting section three. On Monday he read it and said: 'Better.' That was all.
The word 'surgical' in describing his reviews primarily suggests...
- Athat his reviews are unnecessarily harsh and cause emotional damage to those who receive them
- Bthat he views academic writing as a form of illness requiring treatment by a superior intellect
- Cprecise, efficient intervention that removes what is unsound with minimal excess or sentimentCorrect
- Dthat Dr. Nkemdirim has a scientific background that informs his approach to literary and academic discourse
Why C is right
'Surgical' as a modifier connotes precision, economy, and purpose—cutting only what needs cutting, with no waste. Applied to written reviews, it suggests he identifies exactly what is wrong and excises it without embellishment or cruelty. The metaphor reinforces the characterization of controlled, effective competence.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage does not indicate emotional damage; the junior colleague rewrites her section and is told 'better'—a functional, not wounding, exchange.
- B
- While 'surgical' does imply hierarchy of expertise, the passage does not suggest condescension or a view of others as ill.
- D
- His background is academic, not medical; the word is used as a metaphor for style, not as a biographical clue.