Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Analogy

Analogy appears in 14 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Analogy is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following poem and answer the question. The Beekeeper's Calendar In January the hive is a fist, clenched against the cold, each bee a knuckle pressed against the next. In April the fist opens, fingers reaching for the blossoms the way a child reaches for a word it hasn't learned yet — with clumsy, absolute conviction. In August the hive is a city with no unemployment, no streets, no idle hour. Every wing has an assignment. In October the hive begins to subtract. The drones are expelled — those beautiful, useless males who never learned to feed themselves — and the colony closes rank around what it can afford to keep. The poem's depiction of the hive across seasons most closely parallels which of the following?
  1. AA human community's cycles of expansion and necessary contractionCorrect
  2. BA protest against the exploitative practices of commercial beekeeping
  3. CThe lifecycle of a single bee from its birth to its eventual death
  4. DA scientific taxonomy classifying bee species by their seasonal behavior

Why A is right

The poem traces the hive through seasonal phases — winter's defensive contraction, spring's expansion, summer's productivity, and autumn's reduction. These parallel the rhythms of human communities: gathering resources, expanding, achieving peak productivity, and contracting to preserve what is essential.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the poem observes hive behavior with admiration, not critical advocacy.
C
Incorrect because the poem describes the collective hive across seasons, not the life of an individual bee.
D
Incorrect because the poem is literary, not scientific; it uses metaphor and personification rather than classification.
Example 2Medium
Read the following dramatic excerpt carefully before choosing your answer. Setting: A college office. PROFESSOR WADE, 60s, meets with a graduate student, PRIYA, 20s. PRIYA: I want to write my thesis on failure. PROFESSOR WADE: Whose failure? PRIYA: Everyone's. The way we build entire lives around avoiding it and then are surprised when it arrives anyway. PROFESSOR WADE: That's not a thesis. That's a diary entry. PRIYA: (unfazed) A diary entry is just a thesis that hasn't found its evidence yet. PROFESSOR WADE: (pause, then smiling) That's... actually not bad. Say more. PRIYA: What if failure isn't the opposite of success? What if it's the medium? The way water isn't the opposite of swimming -- it's the thing you swim in? PROFESSOR WADE: (leaning forward) You're proposing that failure is the environment, not the outcome. PRIYA: Exactly. We don't fail. We fail in. The way we live in a city. It's the condition, not the event. Priya's analogy comparing failure to water ("the thing you swim in") most directly reframes failure as
  1. Aan all-encompassing medium one continually operates within rather than a discrete negative eventCorrect
  2. Ba condition that arises only within academic institutions and the peculiar pressures of scholarly life
  3. Ca fundamentally restorative process that cleanses and ultimately benefits everyone who undergoes it
  4. Da menacing external force that threatens to overwhelm and drown whoever happens to encounter it

Why A is right

Priya's analogy distinguishes between water as an obstacle (the opposite of swimming) and water as a medium (the thing you swim in). Applied to failure, this reframes it from a discrete negative event (something that happens to you) to an ambient condition (something you operate within). Her subsequent formulation -- 'We don't fail. We fail in' -- confirms that failure is being reconceived as an environment, 'the condition, not the event,' comparable to the city one lives in or the water one swims in.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because Priya frames failure as universal ('everyone's') and environmental ('the condition'); the academic setting is incidental to the argument, which addresses the human experience broadly.
C
Incorrect because the analogy does not characterize failure as positive or cleansing; it redefines failure's category (from event to condition), not its moral value.
D
Incorrect because Priya's water analogy is specifically non-threatening; water is presented as the medium of swimming, not as a drowning risk. The analogy normalizes failure rather than dramatizing it.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.