Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Choice

Choice appears in 4 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Choice is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer. The bar in the Hotel Colombo had exactly fourteen stools, and Ruben knew each one's personality: stool three wobbled, stool seven was too high, stool eleven had a crack in the leather that pinched your trousers. He drank at stool nine, which had no personality at all—no wobble, no height issue, no crack—and this was precisely why he chose it. In a life characterized by excess—too much money, too many women, too many countries visited without being seen—stool nine offered the rare comfort of adequacy. It was enough. Not exceptional, not memorable, not the subject of any story worth telling, but enough, and Ruben had reached the age when enough was the most radical thing a man of his appetites could pursue. The passage characterizes stool nine's lack of personality as appealing to Ruben because
  1. Aits ordinary plainness offers a deliberate retreat from excess that has itself become an aspirationCorrect
  2. Bhis fortune has finally run out, so he must now settle for whatever unremarkable seat happens to be available
  3. Che has grown so numb to his surroundings that he genuinely cannot perceive any difference among the fourteen stools
  4. Dthe hotel management has reserved this particular stool for him in order to limit its liability for the damaged seats

Why A is right

Ruben, characterized by excess ('too much money, too many women, too many countries'), chooses the stool defined by its lack of personality—its adequacy rather than its distinctiveness. This is not indifference but deliberate choice: 'enough was the most radical thing a man of his appetites could pursue.' The stool's ordinariness represents a conscious retreat from excess, and 'enough' has become an aspiration precisely because it is the opposite of Ruben's habitual life.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the passage establishes Ruben has 'too much money,' ruling out financial constraint or a lost fortune as a motivation.
C
Incorrect because Ruben has catalogued each stool's personality with precision, demonstrating keen awareness of his surroundings rather than numb indifference.
D
Incorrect because the passage presents Ruben's choice as personal and philosophical; there is no mention of hotel management, assigned seating, or liability.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.