Read the following passage, then answer the question.
From a psychological detective fiction:
"What made Constance unusual—her colleagues would have said unnerving—was not that she remembered everything. It was that she remembered everything in the order it mattered, not the order it happened. She could tell you at once that the housekeeper's hands shook only on the right side, that the widow had answered questions about the garden in the present tense and questions about her husband in the future, and that the clock in the hall had been moved six inches since the photograph taken three years prior. Her colleagues noted events. Constance noted the shape of what events were trying not to say. 'Everyone lies,' she told the inspector once. 'But only about the true things. Everything else they tell you straight.'"
Constance's distinction—that people lie 'only about the true things'—is best described as:
- AA pun on 'true,' playing its modern sense of factual accuracy against its archaic sense of faithful or loyal to a person
- BA paradox that doubles as a characterization device, inverting ordinary investigative logic to define her cognitive methodCorrect
- CBathos, as an initially profound-sounding observation deflates into an empty tautology once its terms are examined closely
- DDramatic irony, since the inspector will later discover that Constance's own account of events is subject to the very rule she names
Why B is right
The statement is paradoxical: if someone lies about something, that thing must be 'true' (significant, real), while everything else—the unimportant—is reported honestly. This inverts the conventional investigative assumption that lies conceal everything relevant. The paradox is also a characterization device: it defines Constance's method and establishes her as someone who thinks in reversals. The statement is both cognitively surprising and structurally central to her characterization.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- No pun is activated; 'true' is used in its standard modern sense of factual, and the context invokes or signals no archaic meaning of faithful or loyal.
- C
- Bathos requires a drop to the trivial; this statement does not deflate but gains force on examination, functioning as the passage's concluding insight rather than an empty tautology.
- D
- No dramatic irony is established in the excerpt; the inspector's future discoveries are not hinted at, and nothing here undermines Constance's statement from outside the passage.