Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer.
Jorge's English arrived in his mouth already apologizing. 'Sorry, my English is not so good,' he would say, in English that was, by any reasonable measure, more than good—it was precise, grammatical, and inflected with a formality that native speakers had long since abandoned, the way antique furniture retains a craftsmanship that modern furniture has traded for convenience. He used the subjunctive correctly. He never split an infinitive. He deployed semicolons in speech, which is something even English professors have stopped doing. But his English was not native, and in a country that measured fluency by the presence or absence of an accent, Jorge's accent—a slight emphasis on the second syllable of words that English stressed on the first—was a border crossing he could never fully complete.
The comparison of Jorge's formal English to 'antique furniture' most directly suggests that his language
- Ais now outdated and largely ineffective for the demands of modern social interaction
- Breveals both his age and the historical era in which he first learned English
- Cpossesses a craftsmanship and precision that native speakers have traded away for convenienceCorrect
- Dis deliberately affected to impress native listeners with his intellectual superiority
Why C is right
The antique furniture comparison establishes that Jorge's English 'retains a craftsmanship that modern furniture has traded for convenience'—his subjunctive use, intact infinitives, and spoken semicolons are qualities native speakers have abandoned, not because they are wrong but because contemporary English has prioritized casual convenience over formal precision. His language demonstrates a craftsmanship that persists precisely because he learned English as a second language, preserving rules native speakers have relaxed.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 'antique' in this context connotes quality and craftsmanship rather than obsolescence; the furniture comparison values Jorge's precision, not disparages it.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage attributes Jorge's formality to his status as a non-native speaker, not to the era of his education; the antique comparison is about quality, not chronology.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage presents Jorge's formality as the natural product of careful learning, not as deliberate affectation; he begins by apologizing for his English, not by displaying it.