Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Rhetoric

Rhetoric appears in 10 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Rhetoric is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage. October 3rd. Today I discovered that if you press your tongue against a battery, the whole world tastes like a secret. Mama said stop that right now. But she didn't say why, which means she doesn't know what it tastes like, which means she never tried, which means grown-ups have stopped putting things in their mouths to learn about them, which means they have stopped learning. This is my theory: people get tall and forget how to be curious. Their legs grow long and carry them past the interesting things too quickly. A tall person walks right over a puddle. A short person has to walk THROUGH it and that is how you find out that puddles have a smell like old pennies and promises. Daddy says theories need evidence. Here is my evidence: I asked him what clouds taste like and he said 'water vapor.' That is not a taste. That is giving up. The child narrator's chain of logical reasoning about the battery (sentences 2-3) is best characterized as
  1. Aa deliberate parody of scientific reasoning intended to amuse an adult reader
  2. Ba logically valid deductive argument that exposes adults' underlying hypocrisy
  3. Ca flawed but rhetorically persuasive syllogism reflecting the narrator's worldviewCorrect
  4. Dan emotionally manipulative appeal deliberately crafted to win the reader's sympathy

Why C is right

The child's chain of reasoning—from 'she didn't say why' to 'they have stopped learning'—follows a logical structure but contains gaps (the mother might know the taste without articulating it). However, the syllogism is rhetorically persuasive because it captures a genuine insight about how adults lose experiential curiosity, revealing the narrator's worldview that direct sensory engagement equals genuine knowledge.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the narrator is entirely sincere; the humor emerges from the reader's adult perspective on a child's earnest reasoning, not from any deliberate parody by the narrator.
B
Incorrect because while the reasoning has logical structure, it is not deductively valid—it contains unstated assumptions and logical leaps, and the narrator's goal is understanding rather than exposing hypocrisy.
D
Incorrect because the narrator is making a genuine philosophical argument about curiosity, not seeking sympathy; the passage is characterized by confidence and conviction rather than vulnerability.
Example 2Easier
Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer. We buried him on a Wednesday. The sky was blue. The birds were singing. The grass in the cemetery was the particular shade of green that exists only in places where the soil is regularly enriched by decay—a green so vivid it seemed like a boast, or an argument, or the earth's refusal to observe the same silence the mourners had agreed upon. I stood at the edge of the grave and thought about how the word 'grave' means both a hole in the ground and a demeanor, and how the English language had, with the accidental precision of a thrown knife, embedded death inside the word for seriousness, as though it had always known that the two were the same thing—that to be serious is, at its root, to be aware of the grave. The narrator's observation about the double meaning of the word 'grave' is an example of
  1. Awordplay designed to create dark humor and lighten the scene's somber mood
  2. Betymology used as a rhetorical device to deepen the passage's meditation on death and meaningCorrect
  3. Can error in linguistic analysis, since the two meanings of 'grave' are etymologically unrelated
  4. Da digression that distracts from the emotional weight of the burial scene

Why B is right

The narrator uses the double meaning of 'grave' (burial site / serious demeanor) as a rhetorical device to deepen the passage's meditation: 'to be serious is, at its root, to be aware of the grave.' Whether or not the etymology is historically accurate, the narrator uses the word's dual meaning as a tool for philosophical reflection on the connection between seriousness and mortality, enriching the burial scene rather than distracting from it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the observation is contemplative and somber, not humorous; the connection between seriousness and death intensifies rather than lightens the mood.
C
Incorrect because the passage's literary value does not depend on etymological accuracy; the narrator uses the coincidence of meaning as a rhetorical device, and the passage explicitly describes it as 'accidental precision.'
D
Incorrect because the linguistic observation directly engages with the scene's central subject (death and burial), deepening rather than distracting from it.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.