Skip to content

Free-response practice

FRQ 3

10 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

FRQ 3 is the last of the three free-response questions on the AP Environmental Science exam. It presents a short scenario about a realistic environmental problem, usually with a data table, a graph or a list of quantities. You answer a chain of lettered parts, A through E, and most of them contain sub-parts. Several sub-parts ask you to calculate something, while the others ask you to identify, describe or explain the science behind those numbers. Many versions also ask you to propose a solution and describe a drawback of it.

On this page · 6 sections

The question is worth 10 points. The free-response section gives you 70 minutes for all three questions and counts for 40% of your exam score. Because each of the three questions is worth 10 points, FRQ 3 alone is roughly 13% of your final score. Budget about 23 minutes for it, and protect that time, because students who overspend on FRQ 1 often reach FRQ 3 with ten minutes left. A four-function, scientific or graphing calculator is permitted on the exam.

Readers score each sub-part independently, and almost every sub-part is worth exactly 1 point. There is no thesis and no essay structure, and a wrong answer in one place never subtracts a point earned somewhere else. That has two practical consequences. First, answer every sub-part even when you are uncertain, because a blank always scores zero. Second, keep each answer short and aimed squarely at its task verb.

The number of calculations and the points for each part change from year to year, and a calculation can show up in any part. The rubric below is a model built for this guide's two practice prompts, so do not expect Part C to always hold three calculations.

Calculation points follow their own rules. Readers look for your setup, meaning the numbers from the stimulus written into an equation, followed by the answer with the correct units. A correct bare number frequently earns nothing, since the reader cannot see where it came from. When a later part depends on an answer you got wrong earlier, readers usually award credit if you carried that wrong value through correctly. A slip in part C therefore does not have to cost you part D as well.

The task verbs carry different expectations. "Identify" wants a name or a short phrase, while "describe" wants enough detail to show what actually happens. "Explain" wants a cause connected to an effect, usually with the word because. "Calculate" wants visible arithmetic with units attached. "Propose a solution" wants one specific, realistic action, and the drawback you describe has to belong to that same solution rather than to the problem in general.

The scenario can come from any unit, but it usually draws on the heaviest ones. Global Change (about 18% of the course), Pollution (about 17%) and the Living World (about 15%) supply many of the settings. Expect energy use and emissions, nutrient runoff, population growth, the 10% rule and comparisons between greenhouse gases. The mathematics is rarely harder than percent change, unit conversion and multi-step multiplication. Most students lose points through skipped setup, dropped units and a wrong denominator, not through difficult math.

The rubric, in plain terms

10 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Model rubric for this guide's prompts, Part A: identify and describe (2 points)2 pts

One point for correctly identifying the term, process or substance the question asks for, such as a nutrient, a gas or a type of decomposition. One point for describing a process with real detail, so the answer shows what happens and in what order. A label alone does not earn the describe point.

Model rubric for this guide's prompts, Part B: explain using the data (1 point)1 pt

Gives a cause-and-effect explanation that answers the question and uses the scenario. When the question points to specific data, such as temperatures or a time frame, the answer must use those data. Restating a number from the stimulus without saying why it matters does not earn the point.

Model rubric for this guide's prompts, Part C: three calculations (3 points)3 pts

One point for each of three calculations. Each point needs a visible setup with the stimulus numbers and a correct answer with correct units. An answer that correctly uses a wrong value carried from an earlier part still earns the point. A bare number with no work, or an answer in the wrong unit, does not.

Model rubric for this guide's prompts, Part D: multi-step calculation and interpretation (2 points)2 pts

One point for a multi-step calculation, set up and solved correctly with units. One point for explaining what the result shows or how the proposed fix works, through a named mechanism tied to the scenario. Vague verbs like "filters" or "helps" without a mechanism do not earn it.

Model rubric for this guide's prompts, Part E: solution and drawback (2 points)2 pts

One point for proposing a specific, realistic solution that would reduce the problem in the scenario and differs from any solution the prompt already gives. One point for describing a real drawback of that same solution, such as its cost, a lost benefit or a new environmental harm. A drawback that belongs to a different solution, or to the problem itself, earns nothing.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Capturing methane on a dairy farm

A dairy farm in Wisconsin keeps 800 cows. Each cow releases about 120 kilograms (kg) of methane (CH4) per year through enteric fermentation, the microbial digestion that happens in its stomach. The farm stores manure in an open lagoon, where the waste sits beneath standing water and decomposes. The lagoon releases another 40 kg of methane per cow per year.

The farm plans to cover the lagoon and install an anaerobic digester, which will capture 85% of the methane the lagoon currently releases. The captured methane will be burned in a generator to produce electricity for the farm's milking equipment and refrigeration.

Useful information: - 1 metric ton = 1,000 kg - Over 100 years, 1 metric ton of methane causes as much warming as 28 metric tons of carbon dioxide (CO2). - Burning 1 metric ton of methane releases 2.75 metric tons of CO2.

  1. (A)(i) Identify the type of decomposition that produces methane in the manure lagoon. (ii) Describe how methane in the atmosphere traps heat near Earth's surface. [2 pts]
  2. (B)Explain why cutting methane emissions slows warming faster over the next 20 years than cutting the same mass of CO2 emissions. [1 pt]
  3. (C)(i) Calculate the mass of methane, in metric tons, that the lagoon releases each year. (ii) Using your answer to (i), calculate the CO2-equivalent of the lagoon's yearly methane, in metric tons. (iii) Calculate the CO2-equivalent, in metric tons per year, that the digester will keep out of the atmosphere if the captured methane were simply destroyed. [3 pts]
  4. (D)(i) The captured methane is burned rather than destroyed. Calculate the net yearly reduction in CO2-equivalent emissions after you account for the CO2 released by burning. Show your work. (ii) Explain why burning the methane still lowers the farm's effect on warming, even though burning releases CO2. [2 pts]
  5. (E)(i) The digester does nothing about the methane the cows release from digestion. Propose a solution that would reduce that methane. (ii) Describe one drawback of the solution you proposed. [2 pts]
Prompt 2

Nitrogen runoff and a dying lake

Fenwick Lake, a fictional lake, sits in an agricultural watershed in Iowa, where corn farms cover 2,000 hectares (ha). Farmers apply 150 kg of nitrogen fertilizer per hectare each spring. Water monitoring suggests that 20% of the applied nitrogen washes into the lake each year, mostly as dissolved nitrate carried by streams.

Every summer an algal bloom turns the lake surface green. A state environmental agency measured dissolved oxygen (DO) near the lake bottom on two dates last year.

| Month | Water temperature | Bottom DO | | April | 12 degrees C | 8.0 mg/L | | August | 26 degrees C | 1.6 mg/L |

The agency proposes paying farmers to establish strips of native grasses and trees along the streams that feed the lake. These riparian buffer strips would reduce the nitrogen reaching the lake by 45%. The strips would remove 120 ha from corn production, and the agency would compensate farmers $400 per hectare per year for that land. The 45% reduction already includes the effect of taking those 120 ha out of corn, so do not subtract their fertilizer separately.

  1. (A)(i) Identify one nutrient other than nitrogen that commonly runs off farm fields and feeds algal blooms. (ii) Describe how an algal bloom leads to low dissolved oxygen near the lake bottom. [2 pts]
  2. (B)Using the temperature data in the table, explain why bottom dissolved oxygen is lowest in late summer. [1 pt]
  3. (C)(i) Calculate the mass of nitrogen, in kg, that reaches the lake each year. (ii) Calculate the percent change in bottom dissolved oxygen from April to August. (iii) Calculate the mass of nitrogen, in kg, that would reach the lake each year after the buffer strips are planted. [3 pts]
  4. (D)(i) Calculate the yearly cost of the program for each kilogram of nitrogen it keeps out of the lake. Show your work. (ii) Explain how the buffer strips reduce the nitrogen that reaches the lake. [2 pts]
  5. (E)(i) Propose a solution, other than buffer strips, that would reduce nitrogen runoff from the farms. (ii) Describe one drawback of the solution you proposed. [2 pts]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Capturing methane on a dairy farm · high-scoring response10/10

A (i) Anaerobic decomposition. The manure is covered by water, so there is no oxygen available, and methanogenic archaea decompose the organic matter into methane. (ii) Sunlight reaches the ground and warms it, and the ground gives off infrared radiation. Methane molecules absorb that infrared energy and re-emit it in all directions, including back down toward the surface. This keeps heat in the lower atmosphere instead of letting it escape to space.

B Methane only remains in the atmosphere for about 12 years before it is chemically broken down, while CO2 stays for centuries. Over a 20 year period methane traps roughly 80 times more heat per ton than CO2, so reducing it has a large effect almost immediately. Reducing CO2 also helps, but the benefit is spread across a much longer period.

C (i) 800 cows x 40 kg/cow = 32,000 kg. 32,000 kg / 1,000 = 32 metric tons of methane per year. (ii) 32 t CH4 x 28 = 896 metric tons CO2e per year. (iii) 896 t CO2e x 0.85 = 761.6 metric tons CO2e per year.

D (i) Methane captured = 32 t x 0.85 = 27.2 t CH4. CO2 from burning = 27.2 t x 2.75 = 74.8 t CO2. Net reduction = 761.6 - 74.8 = 686.8 metric tons CO2e per year. (ii) Combustion converts methane into CO2, and a ton of CO2 causes far less warming than a ton of methane. The farm releases 74.8 t of CO2 instead of 761.6 t CO2e of methane, so the total warming effect is much smaller. The electricity could also replace power the farm currently buys from fossil fuel plants.

E (i) Add a feed supplement such as the red seaweed Asparagopsis to the cattle feed, because it inhibits the microorganisms in the cow's stomach that produce methane. (ii) The seaweed is expensive to cultivate and transport, so it increases the cost of feeding 800 cows every day and reduces the farm's profit.

How it scored

2/2A — Both points earned. Part (i) names anaerobic decomposition and correctly connects it to the absence of oxygen under the water. Part (ii) traces the complete pathway, from the surface emitting infrared radiation to methane absorbing it and re-emitting energy back toward the ground.
1/1B — Earned. The answer supplies the mechanism the question requires: methane's short atmospheric lifetime combined with a much larger warming effect over 20 years. It also contrasts this with the centuries-long lifetime of CO2, which explains why the timing of the benefit differs.
3/3C — All three earned. Each step shows its setup with stimulus numbers, converts kilograms to metric tons before multiplying, and labels the units. Writing "t CO2e" keeps it obvious which gas and which measurement each number describes.
2/2D — Both earned. Part (i) calculates the captured methane, converts it to the CO2 released by burning, and subtracts, so every step is visible to the reader. Part (ii) compares the two results directly, and the remark about replacing fossil-fuel electricity is additional but accurate. Real carbon accounting often treats CO2 from burning biogas as carbon-neutral, because that carbon came from plants the cows ate. Here the question tells you to subtract it, so follow the question.
2/2E — Both earned. The solution is specific and targets digestion rather than the lagoon, so it answers the question that was actually asked. The drawback is a genuine cost of that same solution, and connecting it to the 800-cow herd makes it concrete.
Capturing methane on a dairy farm · mid-scoring response5/10

A (i) Anaerobic decomposition because there is no oxygen in the lagoon. (ii) Methane is a greenhouse gas that damages the ozone layer. When the ozone gets thinner more of the sun's rays get through to Earth and it gets hotter.

B Methane is 28 times stronger than CO2. CO2 has a GWP of 1 so it is the weakest greenhouse gas, so cutting methane matters more.

C (i) 800 x 40 = 32,000 metric tons (ii) 32,000 x 28 = 896,000 metric tons CO2 (iii) 896,000 x 0.85 = 761,600 metric tons

D (i) Burning methane makes CO2, so 761,600 - 27,200 = 734,400 metric tons (ii) Methane has a GWP of 28 and CO2 has a GWP of 1. So when you burn the methane and turn it into CO2 it is way less powerful at trapping heat. That means it still helps even though there is CO2.

E (i) The farm could reduce the number of cows it has. (ii) Even with fewer cows the lagoon would still give off some methane because the digester only gets 85%.

How it scored

1/2A — One of two. Part (i) is correct, but part (ii) confuses two separate environmental problems. Ozone depletion allows more ultraviolet radiation to reach the surface, which is not how greenhouse gases warm the planet. The answer needed methane absorbing infrared radiation emitted by the surface and re-radiating it downward.
0/1B — Not earned. The "28 times" figure is copied from the stimulus, and it is a 100-year value, so it cannot explain a 20-year effect. Calling CO2 "the weakest" misreads global warming potential, because CO2 is simply the reference gas assigned a value of 1. The point required methane's short lifetime of about 12 years and its much larger warming effect over two decades.
2/3C — Two of three. Part (i) multiplies correctly but never divides by 1,000, so 32,000 kilograms is reported as 32,000 metric tons with the wrong unit. Parts (ii) and (iii) carry that incorrect value forward with correct setups, so readers apply carry-forward credit and award both of them.
0/1D — Not earned for part (i). The student subtracts the mass of methane as though it were the mass of carbon dioxide released by combustion. The multiplication by 2.75 is missing, so the net figure is incorrect even after allowing for the earlier unit error.
1/1D — Earned for part (ii). Comparing the warming effect per ton of the two gases is the correct reasoning, and it explains why converting methane into CO2 lowers the total warming.
1/2E — One of two. Reducing the herd is a valid, specific way to cut methane from digestion, so the proposal earns credit. The drawback does not, because it describes a limitation of the digester rather than a cost of keeping fewer cows. Lost milk sales and lower farm income would have earned the point.
Nitrogen runoff and a dying lake · high-scoring response9/10

A (i) Phosphorus, usually from fertilizer or manure in the form of phosphate. (ii) The extra nutrients allow algae to reproduce very rapidly near the surface. When the algae die they sink to the bottom, where aerobic bacteria decompose the dead material and consume dissolved oxygen faster than it can be replaced, so the bottom water becomes hypoxic.

B By August much of the algae from the summer bloom has died and sunk, so decomposition at the bottom is at its maximum. The decomposers consume the oxygen, so the DO drops to 1.6 mg/L. That is below about 2 mg/L, the level where water is considered hypoxic and most fish cannot survive.

C (i) 2,000 ha x 150 kg/ha = 300,000 kg applied. 300,000 kg x 0.20 = 60,000 kg N per year. (ii) (1.6 - 8.0) / 8.0 x 100 = -80%. DO fell by 80%. (iii) 60,000 kg x (1 - 0.45) = 60,000 x 0.55 = 33,000 kg N per year.

D (i) Cost: 120 ha x $400/ha = $48,000 per year. Nitrogen kept out: 60,000 - 33,000 = 27,000 kg. $48,000 / 27,000 kg = about $1.78 per kg of nitrogen. (ii) The roots of the grasses and trees absorb nitrate from the water before it reaches the stream, and the plants use that nitrogen to grow. The vegetation also slows the runoff so more water infiltrates the soil, where bacteria in saturated soil convert nitrate into nitrogen gas through denitrification.

E (i) Farmers could plant cover crops such as winter rye after the corn harvest, because the rye absorbs leftover nitrogen in the soil so it does not wash away during spring rainstorms. (ii) Farmers have to pay for the seed and for the labor and fuel needed to plant and later terminate the rye, which is an additional expense every year.

How it scored

2/2A — Both earned. Phosphorus is correct, and the description presents the full sequence in order: rapid growth, die-off, sinking, decomposition by aerobic bacteria, and oxygen consumption that outpaces resupply.
0/1B — Not earned. The question directs the student to use the temperature data, and this answer never mentions temperature at all. The missing idea is that warm water holds less dissolved oxygen than cold water, so the 26 degree water in August holds less than the 12 degree water in April. The decomposition reasoning is accurate, but it does not answer the question as written.
3/3C — All three earned. Each answer displays its setup and units. Part (ii) correctly uses the starting value, 8.0 mg/L, as the denominator, which is the step students most frequently get wrong.
2/2D — Both earned. Part (i) finds the nitrogen kept out by subtraction before dividing, and every quantity is labeled. Part (ii) identifies two genuine mechanisms, nitrate uptake by roots and denitrification in waterlogged soil, instead of claiming the plants "filter" the water.
2/2E — Both earned. Cover crops are a specific solution that differs from buffer strips, and the answer explains how they work. The drawback is a realistic yearly expense attached to that same practice.
Nitrogen runoff and a dying lake · mid-scoring response4/10

A (i) Phosphorus (ii) The algae grow so much that they use up all the oxygen in the water. At night they can't do photosynthesis so they just breathe in oxygen and the fish suffocate.

B Warm water can't hold as much oxygen as cold water. In August the water is 26 degrees, so it holds less oxygen than in April at 12 degrees, and the DO is lower.

C (i) 2000 x 150 = 300,000 x .20 = 60,000 kg (ii) 8.0 - 1.6 = 6.4, 6.4/1.6 = 4 x 100 = 400% decrease (iii) 60,000 x .45 = 27,000 kg

D (i) 120 x 400 = $48,000. 48,000 / 27,000 = $1.78 per kg (ii) The plants act as a filter and filter the nitrogen out of the water before it gets to the lake.

E (i) The state should ban nitrogen fertilizer on all the farms right away so there's no more runoff. (ii) It would take a long time for the lake to recover because there is still nitrogen in the lake.

How it scored

1/2A — One of two. Phosphorus is correct, but the description blames the living algae, and nighttime respiration is not what drains oxygen at the lake bottom. The bottom becomes hypoxic because the algae die and sink, and bacteria consume the oxygen while decomposing them. Without decomposition the sequence is incomplete.
1/1B — Earned. The answer uses both temperatures from the table and states the principle that warm water holds less dissolved oxygen than cold water.
1/3C — One of three. Part (i) is correct with units. Part (ii) divides by the August value, 1.6, instead of the April starting value, 8.0, so 400% is wrong; the correct answer is an 80% decrease. Part (iii) calculates the nitrogen removed, 27,000 kilograms, instead of the nitrogen still reaching the lake, which is 33,000 kilograms, a classic misreading of the question.
1/1D — Earned for part (i). The cost per kilogram requires the quantity of nitrogen kept out of the lake, which happens to equal the 27,000 kilograms calculated in C(iii). The setup is visible and the answer is correct.
0/1D — Not earned for part (ii). "Filter" describes no biological or physical mechanism. The answer needed nitrate absorption by roots, slower runoff that allows water to infiltrate the soil, or denitrification by soil bacteria.
0/2E — Zero of two. The rubric requires a realistic solution, and an immediate ban on all nitrogen fertilizer is not one, because corn cannot grow profitably without it and the farms would have no time to adjust. A gradual cut in fertilizer rates or precision application would have earned the point. The drawback also fails, because slow recovery is a property of the lake rather than a cost of the ban. Lower corn yields and lost farm income would have earned that point.

Where points die

Writing only the final number for a calculation, or doing the math on the calculator and copying the result. Write the setup every time: the stimulus numbers, the operation and the units, followed by the answer. Readers cannot credit arithmetic they cannot see, and a visible setup is also what allows them to award carry-forward credit after an earlier mistake.

Losing track of units, especially kg versus metric tons, or hectares versus total area. Carry the units through every line, as in "800 cows x 40 kg/cow = 32,000 kg", and check which unit the question requests before you write the final answer. Dividing kilograms by 1,000 to get metric tons is worth an entire point on many questions.

Using the wrong denominator for percent change, or reporting the amount removed when the question asks for the amount left. Percent change is (new minus old), divided by old, times 100. The starting value is always the denominator. When a fix cuts something by 45%, the amount left is the original times 0.55. Reread the question to see which one it wants.

Treating global warming as an ozone-hole problem, or misreading global warming potential. Greenhouse gases warm Earth by absorbing infrared given off by the surface; ozone loss is about ultraviolet. CO2 has a GWP of 1 because it is the reference gas, not because it is harmless. Methane's short lifetime of about 12 years makes its warming effect over 20 years far larger than its 100-year GWP suggests. Water vapor is a strong greenhouse gas, but its amount in the atmosphere is set by temperature, so it acts as a feedback that amplifies warming rather than a forcing that human emissions control.

Saying algae "use up the oxygen" or that plants "filter" pollutants, with no mechanism. Name the actual process. In eutrophication, the algae die, sink and are decomposed by aerobic bacteria, which consume the oxygen. Buffer strips work by root uptake of nitrate, by slowing runoff so water soaks in, and through denitrification by soil bacteria.

Proposing an unrealistic fix or giving a drawback that does not match it. Pick a specific, workable action, such as cover crops, precision fertilizer use, feed additives or a smaller herd. Catalytic converters cannot turn CO2 or methane into oxygen. An immediate total ban is not realistic, so it does not earn the solution point. Then give a cost or harm caused by that same action, not a weakness of a different solution.

Score your own response

0 / 10

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.